Its a win for CA final students

MRINAL DAXINI (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (128 Points)

23 May 2011  

Re: Fw: CA FINAL MAY 2011 LAW PAPER OUT OF SYLLABUS

Monday, 23 May, 2011 10:02 AM
 
From:

Add sender to Contacts

 
 
To:
"mrinal daxini"
 
Dear Student
 
The matter has been taken note of and it will be appropriately addressed.



 
On Sun, May 22, 2011 at 4:43 PM, mrinal daxini <mrinaldaxini @ yahoo.com> wrote:





 
 

Respected Sir,

Re:- CA FINAL(CORPORATE AND ALLIED LAWS) –WINDING UP QUESTIONS WERE OUT OF SYLLABUS

 

I would like to bring to your kind notice that I had appeared in CA FINAL MAY , 2011 in which Questions nos.3(b) and 6(a) of Corporate and Allied Laws paper  were out of syllabus.In the students journal of February 2011,pg -25 it was given that only para 9.4 of winding up is relevant for the students appearing for  may,2011.But the questions asked in the examination  were not from the para 9.4 but from the other parts of the chapter. Attached please find the said journal for your ready reference and kind perusal.

I would request you to kindly justify the students who have attempted this questions.

Thanking You,

 

MRINAL DAXINI

 


 22 Replies

CA. Praveen Gupta (CA ) (346 Points)
Replied 23 May 2011

Is this realy happend

1 Like


(Guest)

lucky fellow those who have tried to attempt this


CA ADITYA SHARMA (CA IN PRACTICE ) (16719 Points)
Replied 23 May 2011

Originally posted by : Rikin Patel

lucky fellow those who have tried to attempt this
 

CA Parth Jain (CA) (185 Points)
Replied 23 May 2011

Ya it's really happened........total 16 marks question were out of syllabus........we can't challenge ICAI......... i don't hope ny bonus marks frm them....i appered, although wrote right answer bt not expecting ny bonus marks .....it's our ICAI........how can u expect bonus 16 marks from icai ?



(Guest)

hey friends m going to read munish  bhandari (handbook)+ practise manual 4 law..

.in audit surbhi bansal book + practise manual .

in sfm - dr  j b gupta.

is it enough.coz i want to concentrate on practicle subject....???



CA Parth Jain (CA) (185 Points)
Replied 23 May 2011

Dear Rikin

        Read whatever book u want.....bt read only tht book which u can revised on 1 day before your exm.......sinse if u revised 5 times before the exms bt u r not revisnig d day before ur exm thn all ur hard work may waste...it's my personal experience...so Hand book of Munish Bhandari is best and Surbhi Bansal for audit is also best option....i too read frm Surbhi Bhansal.....bt some lessons are too conjusted so u can xrox Padhuka for those lessons....Institute material is also good for practice

2 Like


(Guest)

ya m looking in audit to use padukas for prof ethic, company audit.....is there any other topic..??? 

m more tensed abt sfm  coz m not finding right book...j b gupta i havent seen   but planning to buy after seeing his notes,,,,coz sdbala skips many topics


CA Parth Jain (CA) (185 Points)
Replied 23 May 2011

No need for refer Padhuka for company audit.....u can read it frm surbhi.some more topics which are abt only 2-3 pages in surbhi....they r only need to xrox from padhuka....ya u can refer prof ethics practicle sums frm padhuka

for smf i studied frm bala only........it's gd yaar take it man...bt for derivatives u have to take print out frm shridhar or some other book........Bala is enough....don't  consider May 11 sfm paper while making decision abt sfm book.....coz dis tym of paper was out of level.......abhi tak pata ni chala muje ki kaunse topics se kaunsa question pucha.

1 Like


(Guest)

but sdbala skips many topis as people commented



(Guest)

i have already bought paduka, ansridhar....but my funda is not clear m very good in theory paper  but in practicles m not so....many of my friends advised j d gupta or sdbala.....i  will have to decide very soon...please help me..coz jb gupta coveers entire syllabus i n systematic manner



charanteja.nsr (ACMA and BCOM) (818 Points)
Replied 23 May 2011

FOR CA FINAL LAW WOLUD U PREFER PADUKA ? EVERY ONE SAYING MUNISH BAHDHARI IS THERE ANY LACKING IN PADUKA LAW BOOK ... PLZ REPLY

1 Like


(Guest)

i personally feel paduka for law is better then munish bhandari.......i haveused paduka in pcc for law got 63.....no doubt m. bhandari has specialised in this area but paduka exam orientation in excellent   after readind it,,, u wount find any thing ut of it......but u have to revise it atleast 3 times....in ca theory paper its important how u present answer......so in final m goig with small bookas with leaset pages....

.please  advise me on sfm... above post



(Guest)

use munish bhandari.its the best for law


charanteja.nsr (ACMA and BCOM) (818 Points)
Replied 23 May 2011

i think u bought  an.sridar sir ... definitely it is a good book for self study ... my seniors suggested pattabiram sfm book also ... i dont abot others ... i use my sfm sir phanis notes(superwhizz ,vijayawada) i rely completely on notes provided by him ... hezz is awesome ...

1 Like



Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Join CCI Pro


Subscribe to the latest topics :

Search Forum: