Hi
The Total income (Rs. 200000+ Rs 50000) Rs. 250000
CA Pavithra S
(Chartered Accountant)
(92 Points)
Replied 23 December 2009
Hi
The Total income (Rs. 200000+ Rs 50000) Rs. 250000
CMA RAVI GUPTA
(MT in VPL)
(493 Points)
Replied 24 December 2009
yaar balance income 140000 kaise ho sakti hai.
Total Income (20000+50000)= 250000
Balance income= 250000-(30000+20000+10000 )=190000 hogi na yaar na ki 140000
I could not understand that how did u get balance income as 140000 yaar, pls clerify it.................
CMA RAVI GUPTA
(MT in VPL)
(493 Points)
Replied 24 December 2009
vikram bhai pls provide full solution that how did u reach 9785
Yeshwanth
(Chartered Accountant)
(145 Points)
Replied 24 December 2009
Business Income (Assumed) – Rs. 140000 @ Normal Rates
LTCG – Rs. 30000 @ 20%(Sec. 112)
STCG - Rs. 10000 @ 15%(Sec. 111A)
Lotteries - Rs. 20000 @ 30% (Sec. 115BB)
Total Rs. 200000
Now tax computation as follows:
Since agricultural income exceeds Rs. 5000 and non agricultural income exceeds basic exemption limit (180000) the tax will be calculated as follows:
Step 1: Tax on (Agril income + Non agricultural Income)
LTCG – Rs. 6000 [30000*20%]
STCG – Rs. 1500 [10000*15%]
Lotteries – Rs. 6000 [20000*30%]
For remaining Income [250000-60000] 190000 tax is 1800 [(190000-180000)*10%]
Hence the tax liability is 15300 [6000+1500+6000+1800]
Step2:Tax on [Agril income+basic exemption limit]
50000+180000 = 230000
So tax on above is 5000 [ (230000-180000) * 10%]
Step3: Step 1 – Step 2
Total tax is 10300
Cess @ 3% 309
Tax liability is 10609
Correct me if i am wrong.....
Ranjith
(Article)
(37 Points)
Replied 25 December 2009
k i made a pretty descent blunder takin the TDS rate to 33% while its just 30.9%
but hey i dunno why every1 is practically makin this mistake of calculating ltcg and stcg.
has any1 read the whole of Sec 111A & 112.
coz it does state that the tax has to be calculated only if it exceeds the slab rate and if it does it has to be calculated on the amt in excess of this slab rate.
And so here's wht i feel how the tax is to be calculated
Total Income (20000+50000)= 250000
Tax on income
Tax on the agricultural income at the normal rate 1st slab tax rate ie 50000 @ 10% - 5000
Tax on LTCG on Rs 20000(the amt excess to the slab rate 200000-180000) @ 20% - 4000
therefore Total Tax = Rs. 9000
NOW,
LEss : REbate on agriclutural income
Basic Exemption -180000
Add: AGri income-50000
Total -230000 -Rs. 5000
Balance Tax - 4000
add: Education cess 3% - 120
Total Tax payable = 4120
Less: TDS on winnings(30.9%) - 6180
Balance tax Refund is RS. 2060.
Note: i'm still repeating the point tht ltcg and stcp are to be calcultated at their flat rates only if they exceed the slab rates and 2 the extent they do...!!!!
Ranjith
Vikram Gagneja
(a/c)
(108 Points)
Replied 28 December 2009
his total income is Rs.200000
add agriculture income 50000
total income including agriculture income = 250000
tax on above
on long term capital gain of Rs.30000 @ 20% 6000.00
on winning from lottery of Rs.20000 @ 30% 6000.00
on short term capital gain coverd u/s 111A of Rs.10000 @ 15% 1500.00
tax on balance Rs.190000(250000-30000-20000-10000) 1000.00
total tax 14500
less rebate for agriculture income 5000
tax payable 9500
add: education cess and secondary and higher education cess 285
total tax payable 9785
because on winning from lottery tds is deducted @ 30.9% or 33.99% so the tds is to be consider for calculating tax
CA. Anshul Bajaj
(Taxation Head)
(173 Points)
Replied 31 December 2009
Agreed My Answer war wrong i forgot the Indirect taxation proviaions of Agricultural Income Thanks Guys!!