is common man is benefited by union buget 09-10..an analysis

Ratan Deep Saxena (Asstt Manager (Accounts & Finance))   (2998 Points)

19 September 2009  

 

Is Common man benefited by Union Budget 2009-10?

Meager Effect on tax:

 

 

The Union Budget 2009 is an anti middle man Budget. Salary income earners upto Rs.10 Lakhs will have a maximum benefit of Rs.1,030 whereas the higher income group earners having income of above Rs.10 Lakhs will be benefited by an minimum amount of Rs.21,012 (because of removal of Surcharge) and maximum by few lakhs rupees.

Fringe Benefit Tax:

The following are taxed as perquisites in the hands of employee – (a) Shares allotted under ESOP Scheme, (b) Contribution in excess of Rs.One Lakh on Super Annuation fund and (c) any other Fringe benefit notified by the government like the Car, Credit Card, Free Club Membership, Gift, Free Accommodation, Free Transportation, Free Lunch will be taxed in the hands of employee similar to what was prevailing upto Financial Year 2004–05.

Fringe Benefit Tax abolished for Corporates and Firms is a big Tsunami hit for salaried people. The burden is shifted to employee from employer by amending Section 17 of Income Tax Act, 1961.

It seems like the Budget is Corporate Friendly and Enemy to Salaried Class!!!

More tax burden for VRS Employee:

Effect on Small Business Men:

Retail trader – Present Declare Income – [Rs.40 Lakhs × 5%] –

Rs.2.00 Lakhs

Until Financial Year 2008–09, VRS Compensation received upto Rs.5 Lakhs eligible for Full Exemption and beyond Rs.5 Lakhs liable for income tax, but the assessee can claim tax relief u/s 89(1) on the basis of last three years average rate of tax. As per the proposed law, the employee Relief).Upto Financial Year 2008–09, For Civil Construction Contractor having Gross Receipts upto Rs.40 Lakhs the income will be calculated at rate of 8% and small Retail Traders upto a Gross Receipt of Rs.40 Lakhs, his income will be calculated at rate of 5%. But, under the proposed law from the Financial Year 2010–11 an assessee engaged in any business, whose Gross Turnover or Gross Receipts does not exceed Rs.40 Lakhs liable to declare an income of  Gross Turnover or Gross Receipts.

Tax Effect: Rs.5,150

Retail trader – Proposed Law Declare Income – [Rs.40 Lakhs × 8%] –

Rs.3.20 Lakhs

Tax Effect: Rs.20,600

The Basic exemption limit for individual increased by Rs.10,000 but presumptive income increased by Rs.1.20 lakhs. Hence, there is no real tax benefit for small business men.

The above persons are not liable for Advance Tax. It is not a great benefit because individual will declare an income at the rate of 8% that is maximum of Rs.3,20,000 and claim 80C deduction of Rs.1,00,000, the balance net income of Rs, 2,20,000 the tax liability works out to Rs.6,180 (approx).From the above these small business men are not required to pay the advance tax as the limit for advance tax payment enhanced to Rs.10,000 from the present Rs.5,000.

 

Is this budget anti–budget to carrier of goods?

(A) Small Vehicle Owners Affected –

Small Vehicle Owner –

Present

Declare a Maximum Income of [Rs.3,500 pm × 10

Vehicles × 12 months] –

Tax Effect: Rs. 40,170/–

Rs.4.20 Lakhs

Small Vehicle Owner –

Proposed Law

Declare a Maximum Income of [Rs.5,000 pm × 10

Vehicles × 12 months] –

Tax Effect: Rs 86,520/–

Rs.6.00 Lakhs

Thus, for every lorry you are owning you have to declare Rs.18,000 income more p.a.

(B) Effect on Other Goods Vehicle Owner:

Other Vehicle Owner –

Present

Declare a Maximum Income of [Rs.3,150 pm × 10

Vehicles × 12 months] –

Tax Effect: R. 31,520/–

Rs.3.78 Lakhs

Other Vehicle Owner –

Proposed Law

Declare a Maximum Income of [Rs.4,500 pm × 10

Vehicles × 12 months] –

Tax Effect: R. 67,980/–

Rs.5.4 Lakhs

Thus, for every other goods vehicle you are owning you have to declare Rs.16,200 income more p.a.

Stop Gifting…!! Is this the rule of Union Budget, 2009

Under the present law, the

Fortunately, the above gifts from relative or on marriage or by will or inheritance or contemplation of death or from local authority or educational or medical institution u/s 10(23C) is not taxable.

gift made in money for a sum exceeding Rs.50,000 only liable to income tax. But, as per the proposed law the gift made in Money or Immovable Property or any property like Shares and Securities, Jewellery, Archeological Collections or Drawings or Painting, Sculptures or any work of Art of the value in excess of Rs.50,000, the whole value shall be chargeable to tax.

Benefit for the Dependant and not for YOU!!!!

Previously a deduction of Rs.75,000 was given in respect of taking care of any of your Dependant relative suffering from severe disability the same was increased to Rs.1,00,000. But if the person himself is suffering, you are eligible only for the deduction of Rs.75,000 (No increase).

One Bright Star in the dark sky!! –

So, what is the moral of the Story?

Only welcome move for small individuals is the expansion of the scope of Section 80E giving deduction in respect of interest paid on education loan. Previously the deduction is given only in respect of loan taken for pursuing higher education like, Engineering,Medical and post graduation in Management, but now the scope is extended to cover  EDUCATION BEYOND SENIOR SECONDARY SCHOOLSFrom the income tax view point, fund your child education by borrowing money rather than funding from your own kitty as the government may waive the loan borrowed for educational purposes in future.

TDS Rate reduced –

individual contractors. (b) Hiring / Renting of Plant and Machinery TDS Rate reduced from 10% to

2%. (c) Letting out immovable properties, including furniture and fittings, TDS is reduced from 15% to 10% and in respect of Corporates and Firms the same is reduced from 20% to 10%.

(a) TDS Rate reduced from 2% to 1% w.e.f 1st April, 2009 in respect of

Do get your PAN quickly if don’t have one –

If you fail to give PAN to your deductor your income amount will be liable to deduction of tax at a Maximum rate of 20%. No Form 15G or 15H shall be given to bank or any Company by an individual or senior citizen without PAN.

Wealth Tax Limit:

The basic exemption on wealth tax increased from Rs.15 Lakhs to Rs.30 Lakhs. This has a net tax effect of Rs.15,000. This increase in basic exemption made after 16 Years. In this 16 years real estate market increased by 6 times and gold price increased by 3.5 times. Increase in basic exemption of wealth tax by one time is not a great boon.

 

Individual gains nothing beyond Rs.1,030 p.a, that is on an average Rs.3.00 per day in a year.