sudhir (Chartered Accountant) (26 Points)
22 July 2016I'm a statutory auditor of private limited company, we have to comment over internal financial control this time, Is there is any way out that we can rather give full annexure of IFC alongwith Audit report we just simply add a comment over IFC in our audit report, I dont want to comment over IFC on this company, should be on safer side.
Thanks.
CA Saurabh Singh
(Practising Chartered )
(974 Points)
Replied 23 July 2016
Hello Sudhir,
Its a compliance of Stat auditor to see whether the company has complyed with internal audit requirement or whether internal audit has been carried out effectively.
Hence you need to go through the report and commnet on the same
CA Kishore D
(Management Consultant | Trainer)
(324 Points)
Replied 23 July 2016
Sudhir,
Let me summarize the Guidance Note and what it says with regard to your question.
Internal Financial Control has two components:
1. Internal Controls over Financial Reporting (ICOFR) This is applicable to all companies
2. Internal Financial Controls (IFC) - This is applicable, currently, only to listed companies.
Therefore, in your case ICOFR is applicable, since it is a private limited company. The Companies Act, 2013 requires two items in this regard:
a. Entity Level Controls
b. Process Level Controls.
As an auditor, you need to comment on both (a) and (b), with regard to existence, and adequacy of both.
Hope this helps.
CA Amrita Chattopadhyay
(Audit & Assurance)
(13459 Points)
Replied 25 July 2016
You have to follow the audit report form prescribed in the guidance notes of the Internal Financial Control and report accordingly. As per the response provided by CA Kishore, you also need to address the basic ITGC control.
CAclubindia
