Ad Free CAclubindia and Daily Updates on your Mobile. Subscribe Now!

Incorpotation of nidhi co & credit co-op soc

CS Sandip Rahane (CS & Legal ) (368 Points)

16 December 2014

If a person having clients around 500-700 who want to invest their money for saving & return. Which will be the good form for investment?

Because he wants to go for incorporation Nidhi Company or Credit Co-op Society.

What are the benefits of the both/ pros & cons.& which would be the better option.

THanks.

Reply
Follow
Share

2 Replies

Arpit Shah (Accountant) (21438 Points)
Replied 16 December 2014

Starting a Nidhi Company

The word “Nidhi” in Nidhi Company comes from a root word traditionally meaning “treasure”. In its more recent context in the Indian financial sector it refers to any mutual benefit society notified by the Central / Union Government as a Nidhi Company. They are created primarily for the motive of cultivating the habit of thrift and savings among their members.

The companies doing Nidhi business, viz. borrowing from members and lending to members only, are known under different names such as Nidhi, Permanent Fund, Benefit Funds, Mutual Benefit Funds and Mutual Benefit Company. Nidhis are more popular in South India and are highly localized single office institutions. They are mutual benefit societies, because their dealings are restricted only to the members; and membership is limited to individuals. The principal source of funds is the contribution from the members. The loans are given to the members at relatively reasonable rates for purposes such as house construction or repairs and are generally secured. The deposits mobilized by Nidhis are not much when compared to the organized banking sector.

Regulatory framework

Nidhi’s are Companies Registered under the Companies Act

Nidhi’s are companies registered under section 620A of the Companies Act, 1956 (Section 406 of the new Companies Bill 2012, as passed by Lok Sabha) and is regulated by Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA). Even though Nidhis are regulated by the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956, they are exempted from certain provisions of the Act, as applicable to other companies, due to limiting their operations within members.

The Central Government vide Notification No.5/7/2000-CL.V dated 23rd March 2000 constituted a Committee to examine the various aspects of the functioning of Nidhi Companies.There was no Government Notification defining the word ‘Nidhi’. Taking into consideration the manner of functioning of Nidhis and the recommendations of the Shri P.Sabanayagam Committee in its report and also to prevent unscrupulous persons using the word ‘Nidhi’ in their name without being incorporated by Department of Company Affairs (DCA) and yet doing Nidhi business, the Committee suggested the following definition for Nidhis:

“Nidhi is a company formed with the exclusive object of cultivating the habit of thrift, savings and functioning for the mutual benefit of members by receiving deposits only from individuals enrolled as members and by lending only to individuals, also enrolled as members, and which functions as per Notification and Guidelines prescribed by the DCA. The word Nidhi shall not form part of the name of any company, firm or individual engaged in borrowing and lending money without incorporation by DCA and such contravention will attract penal action.” A part of this definition is appearing in the new Companies Bill 2012 at Section 406.

Also under the ambit of Reserve Bank of India

Nidhis are also included in the definition of Non-Banking Finance Companies or NBFC’s which operate mainly in the unorganized money market. However, since 1997, NBFCs have been brought increasingly under the regulatory ambit of the Indian Central Bank, RBI. Non-banking financial entities partially or wholly regulated by the RBI include:

NBFCs comprising equipment leasing (EL), hire purchase finance (HP), loan (LC), investment (1C) (including primary dealers (PDs)) and residuary non-banking (RNBC) companies.
mutual benefit financial company (MBFC), i.e. nidhi company.
mutual benefit company (MBC), i.e. potential nidhi company i.e., A company which is working on the lines of a Nidhi company but has not yet been so declared by the Central Government;has minimum net owned fund(NOF) of Rs.10 lakh, has applied to the RBI for certificate of registration and also to Department of Company Affairs (DCA) for being notified as Nidhi company and has not contravened directions/ regulations of RBI/DCA.
miscellaneous non-banking company (MNBC), i.e. chit fund company.

Since Nidhis come under one class of NBFCs, RBI is empowered to issue directions to them in matters relating to their deposit acceptance activities. However, in recognition of the fact that these Nidhis deal with their shareholder-members only, RBI has exempted the notified Nidhis from the core provisions of the RBI Act and other directions applicable to NBFCs. As on date (February 2013) RBI does not have any specified regulatory framework for Nidhis.

RBI Guidelines for Nidhi Company

The RBI guidelines provide that a Nidhi company notified under section 620-A of the Companies Act is classified at present as “Mutual Benefit Financial Company” by RBI and regulated by the Bank for its deposit taking activities and by DCA for its operational matters as also the deployment of funds. These Companies enjoy exemption from core provisions of the RBI Act viz. requirement of registration, maintenance of liquid assets and creation of reserve fund, and RBI Directions except those relating to interest rate on deposits, prohibition from paying brokerage on deposits, ban on advertisements and the requirement of submission of certain Returns. Such companies, however, are allowed to deal with their shareholders only, for the purpose of accepting deposits and making loans. There are a number of companies functioning on the lines of Nidhi companies but not yet notified by DCA. As RBI Directions to classify them as loan companies had disallowed them the special dispensation available to Notified Nidhi companies, the Bank and the Government received representations from a large number of such companies and their associations. Government decided to give them a special dispensation and notified that applications of companies incorporated on or before January 9, 1997 shall be considered for notifying as Nidhi Company under section 620-A of the Companies Act, 1956 only if they have minimum NOF of Rs.10 lakh or more. These companies shall be required to have net owned fund of Rs.25 lakh by December 31, 2002 like companies already declared as Nidhis. Government has also clarified that NOF shall have the same meaning as assigned to it in the RBI Act, 1934. Thus a new class of companies has been created i.e. the potential Nidhi companies. To distinguish them from the notified Nidhi companies (Mutual Benefit Financial Companies) the term Mutual Benefit Companies (MBC) is being used. Since the notified nidhi companies are exempted from the provisions of Section 45-IA (Compulsory Registration with RBI), Section 45-IB (Maintenance of Liquid Assets) and Section 45-IC (Creation of Reserve Fund), it has been decided on the lines of Government advice to exempt the MBCs in existence as on January 9, 1997 and having NOF of Rs.10 lakh from the above mentioned provisions of the Act in terms of powers vested with the Bank under Section 45 NC of the Act and also from those provisions of NBFC Directions on Acceptance of Public Deposits and Prudential Norms which do not apply to notified nidhi companies.

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Arpit Shah (Accountant) (21438 Points)
Replied 16 December 2014

In India, cooperative societies were regarded as ideal instruments to motivate the people to come together and help themselves in the process of eliminating the unscrupulous middlemen making huge profit at the expense of the society. The Cooperative Credit Societies Act, 1904 enabled formation of cooperatives for supplying to farmers cheap credit and protect them from exploitation in the hands of moneylenders. The Cooperative Societies Act, 1912 expanded the sphere of cooperation and provided for supervision by central organization. A cooperative society, which has its object the promotion of the economic interests of its members in accordance with the co-operative principles may be registered with limited or unlimited liability by filing application accompanied by copy of its byelaws and signed by at least 10 adult members of the same locality, class, caste, tribe or occupation (Sec.4 to 9).

The controlling provisions include Registrar’s power of holding inquiry into the constitution, working and financial conditions of the society, inspection of books of indebted society, dissolution of the defunct society, cancellation of registration of society whose membership falls below 10, and winding up of the society through liquidator (Sec. 35, 36, 39, 40 and 42). The legislation is in force even today inUnionTerritoriesand is invoked by the Central Government.

A co-operative society has been formed behind the following broad objectives.

To render services to its members instead of making profits.
It encourages a state mutual help in the place of competition.
It assures a state of self-help in the place of dependence.
It develops a state of moral solidarity in the place of unfair business activities.

Advantages:

Unlike other retailers, cooperative stores supply quality goods. Consumers are thus saved from adulteration and other malpractices.
As consumers are the owners and managers of such stores, genuine requirements of the majority of consumers can be met. In other words, goods required by a majority of the customers are always dealt by such stores.
Cooperative societies are an important form of democratic business enterprise because of its diffused ownership. As a result, no single group can secure control over the organisation.

Disadvantages:

It caters to the needs of small and medium-income groups.
There is too much dependence on the honesty, integrity and loyalty of members and workers.
There is lack of proper sales promotion drives by the sales force of these stores.
Management of such stores usually rests in the hands of amateurs. Professional managers cannot be hired due to lack of funds.

Documents required for a Co- Operate Society:

Model bye-laws (4 copies)
Enquiry Performa
List of promoter members.
Copy of promotional meeting resolution resolving name of the society, value of share money, admission fees, liabilities, total number of members of managing committee, annual submission fees etc.