Save Rs 499. Go Ad-Free with CAclubindia Pro for 2 Full Years. Subscribe Now!

Income from other sources

453 views 3 replies

Deepak Arora

CA-Final

398 Points Posted on 27 July 2012

Hello,

I am a salaried person, invested some amount in under construction property.

The broker refunded me Rs.90K after deducting TDS Rs.10K out of money given by me to him towards his brokerage etc.

He says he got the rebate. Now I am confused how should I treat this amount into my return and how to get that tax amount from the department.

Please reply on priority basis.

Thanks in advance.

Regards

Deepak Arora

Replies (3)

CA. Subhash Dangi

Chartered Accountant

1784 Points Posted on 27 July 2012

Under which section the broker deducted the TDS?

Whether the broker issued Form 16A for the same.

U have not mentioned the nature of transaction and about rebate.

Deepak Arora

CA-Final

398 Points Posted on 27 July 2012

Hello,

He deducted Rs.10K under brokerage. And issued Form 16A too for the same.

Actually I given him some amount towards initial deposit out of which he refund me Rs.90K by saying its a rebate to you and deducted tax on this @ 10%.

Its not cleared to me too properly.

Is there any way to save this amount.

Regards

Deepak Arora

CA. Subhash Dangi

Chartered Accountant

1784 Points Posted on 27 July 2012

First of all it is not an income which was refunded by the broker.

It is not clear that the amount refunded is what u invested.

If refund is pertains to your investment, then file your IT return stating your salary income only. Claim the refund Rs. 10K by filling the TDS details of Form 16A.