in IIM only entrance is difficult , after that everything is easy.

Whereas in CA entrance is easy after that life become miserable.

friends,

ca is a correspondance type course .Here students takes class according to his budget.I.E students unevenly spread here and there.

this is the reson why every student has separate approach towards study .ca students highly lacks in creativity par duniya creativityvity ki bhooki hai .ye quality soft skill proggrame se di jati hai .jo icai me seriosly hota nahi.orientation hame boring aur bakwaas lagti hai.

rahi bat degree ki to co. use kha nahi profit ki jagah.see steve jobs  no special degree but his co. hires thosand of such iim and ca type people.bhai attitude ki kadra hai yaha par log 10 bar revision ki bat to karta hai par logic ke sath 1 bar bhi nahi padta .

logic +creativity+attitude +atmphere to groom=>1 crore pakage

icai +student has to do effort to achieve this........................................

thanks

Money is not everything my dear friends... We have chosen CA not by chance, but by Choice because we like that profession. Each field has its uniqueness... A CA may not earn as much of an IIM passout, but knowledge wise, a CA is always equipped 100%.

In one sentence CA BAAP H MBA KA. Although MBA Smarter than CA But CA works smarter than MBA in any Industry. CAs can do all type of works related to Finance, can work INDEPENDENTLY  they can make his own bill towards providing proffesional services after deducting Tds U/S 194J.

What abt MBA??? only smartness and communication skills not matter in any org.
 what about work??? u have no power to work independently and raise ur bills towards ur clients

Aur jaha tak baat rahi salary ki PLSSSSS PLSS dont compare It with MBA . CA kya kya kar sakta iska tumhe andaza bhi nahi hoga mere pyara bhaiyo

thanks

Initially while goin thru some very interesting responses I had resisted myself from posting anything...

But Neeraj here just got me going...

First of all @ Neeraj - LOL, all i wud say is grow up...

Guys out here have a preconceived notion dat MBA's are generally smart ass people who don't know anything and just have their "smartness and communication skill"

Neeraj u really think that those hiring MBA's and trust me a lot of CA's are in the panel as well are dumb people who cant see if a guy has any core competency or not...its hillarious if u do...

U asked what a MBA can do, to put it in one line I'd say, MBA starts working where the CA's stop.

MBA"s  specialises and can go in Finance, Marketing, IT, HR...Apart from the statutory privileges which a CA enjoys MBA has taken over in every other field, and I hate to say it but i dont see any CA in Marketing/HR/IT...

Work independently - Not even worth commenting( haven't u heard of fresh MBA's becoming enterpreneurs) and yes MBA can also raise a bill and deduct TDS from their clients...dude do u really have any idea what u r saying...

Now the last part Salary, Only deserving people get paid well be it a CA or MBA, Getting a CA degree is no guarantee of a gud salary...over here what is a gud salary is also debatable but I wont go in details...

There are 200000 new MBA's compared to roughly 20000 CA's every year in the country, so a comparison between both the professions is completely meaningless.

Neeraj I wish u read this comment and share your enlightened views:)

U see the difference between CA and an MBA(except top 15 collegel passouts) , i just like the difference between IRRFAN KHAN and SAIF ALI KHAN, the former is ahardcore true ACTOR, and the latter is chiku type actor. SO now u get mr.mba .. I ain't sayin that CA is better earning profession than mba but you see we the CA students give up our bloddy 5 hard years of our lives and burnig our asses, juggling with office to studies (and mind it we dont PLAY with laptops creating lullababy's ppt files)... we earn the respect of being called CA'S because the one who does mba(from non top colleges) knew that he dont have BALLS to cope up with one world's frustrating and life eater course... DUDE YOU GROW UP... before singing an anthem for MBA you should know that going through PRINCIPLES OF MANAGEMENT or say "YOUR SPECIALIALITY" HR/MKTING AND EVEN say FINANCE, is lot fun while studying it in a ppt file, whereas studying the core LOGICAL sections of INDIRECT TAXES OR DIRECT TAXES requires concentration of a MONK. CA is not about DEDUCTING TDS, its about giving AN OPINION ON A BALANCE SHEET, do u even know how to read a balance sheet???? unfortunately u cant create a ppt for a balance sheet and niether its about having COMMUNICATION like SHAKESPEARE... only one line i liked in above post ..."comparison between both the professions is completely meaningless."... PEACE - V -

Hi Gaurav

All, i have to say is, if a MBA makes more or equal to a CA just by making ppts(what u call it lullbaby"s ppt files, incredible sense of humour man :) then they really are smart ass guys...I don see d point working your ass off for CA.

BTW my earlier post was completely unbiased as I am neutral to both the professions...

Get a life beyond Balance sheet bro...

Regarding the expertise in subject CA's are far superior to MBA,  but MBA's are scoring on Inter Personal skills,  presentation skills, negotiation skills etc., 

If CA's got expertise in that area,  then that CA have more market value than an IIM MBA(except few rank holders).

@ Chandan - you are right dude, they might b smart ( I specefically gave a self explainatory example of IRRFAN KHAN and SAIF ALI KHAN ( saif is no doubt smart, by face than Irrfan) and for more clearity take one more, A car with a nice engine but body like AMBASSADOR is what I call is "US", and a car with engine of a nano but body of a jaugar is JAGUAR SERIES "MBA"...

rest, I dun think I wud like to reply more on this useless topic nemore, I guess people are free to have their opinion, but what matters is where you place your opinion, goto mbaclubindia.com or something like that, there u might get people TRYING (HARD) to prove CA's as useless .. :)

PEACE - V -

@ Gaurav...Lol, i din even had to try hard here:)

U know whats funny and a bit ironical, u put in scathing comments and at last u write Peace...atleast b sure what u want...

well, its clear how hard u are trying and how hard ur not !!!

I mean specefically craeting a profile on website dedicated for a purpose or say specefic group of people and then giving derogatory comments for the profession, affcourse u din tried hard, now smile :) ...

And, about PEACE... I write this 'coz I try to make a point without hurting anyone's sentiments, but EWW... somebody always get itchy.

ONCE AGAIN, srsly dude, I guess u remain ONLINE FOREVER, but ur bad I dont have so much time,I mean we cant PRETEND we are busy .. :)

so try to understand the meanig of PEACE... and GET WELL SOON...... BRO ...  :D

@ Gaurav,

Till now i was abstaining from personal comments but u have earned it...

'Specifically' (learn the spelling, i know CA is taking quite a toll on you)

"specefically craeting a profile on website dedicated for a purpose or say specefic group of people and then giving derogatory comments for the profession" ( where did u get this notion from) this is a social platform for all professionals, just that its called caclubindia, it doesn mean u have a copyright :) BTW i am more active on this platform than u, u r actually a kid who wants attention!!! Have u heard of a "troll', dont bother just google it :)

OMG just too many mistakes to correct :) whr did u learn ur eng from?

I have never ever wrote any thing which is derogatory for any of the profession but its quite obvious dat u don understand a thing (quite evident from ur comments also, wont blame u though, just as u said. ...EWW... somebody always get itchy)

And what double standards do u have dude, u come up wid this silly idea of writing Peace n settling it all and then u expect no one to respond...Amazing :) BTW ve searched a lot but cudn find the point u wre trying to make, all i cud see is crap:P

"I guess u remain ONLINE FOREVER, but ur bad I dont have so much time"

Yeah i do coz my work needs me to remain online...My Bad- lol ( U ve lost it man :)

Seriously where did u get all these false notions about urself (and yes its about you and not the profession)

"I mean we cant PRETEND we are busy"

Quite obviously, (Like I had said b4, Get a life beyond balance sheet bro)

I think u need some conditioning...get well soon..

Just in case u missed, i was smiling all along :)

I NEED AN MBA FOR RUNNING MY BUSINESS BUT A "CA" TO TEACH THEM HOW TO RUN THE BUSINESS" Wise Words By : RATAN TATA

ok i agree "MBA" r concidred better than CA according to some "MBA" ONLY  bt people SIGNATURE to CA ka hi AUTOGRAPH ki tarah chalta hai and "MBA" ka signature,signature hi reh jata hai............................