Srinivas (accountant) (222 Points)
21 January 2013Hi All:
I missed exemption in Indirect tax paper(final) by 1 mark, i got 59 marks. i am confident that i would have got 1 more mark extra to be eligble for exemption.
now my clarification, any chance if i apply for revaluaiton that i will get exemption in IDT with 60 marks.
did this similar instance happen in past to any one of you.
please suggest.
Srinivas
Kiran Patil
(Accounts Manager)
(121 Points)
Replied 21 January 2013
Dear Srinivas,
Its very difficult situation that i can understand because i also had 59 in IDT in May 2012 exam, rechecking is now very strict and very less chances of that but u may should still apply. And as early as possible forget this thing because it affects on our next attempt studies,
in my case i had also demanded Paper certified copy under RTI, but in paper had only 53 marks & in markshtt 59 marks,
some where given 1 marks & then rewrite as zero ....
its very bad part of checking when some one not get exemption by 1 mark..
let take it as part of hard luck ...
And i once again saying u forget this as early possible ,, THIS IS MY EXPERIENCE
MY nov. 12 marks total very short than that of May 2012 ...
Kiran
CA Dimple Thacker
(It's Never Too Late)
(506 Points)
Replied 21 January 2013
Kiran how to apply for answersheet under RTI act?
Kiran Patil
(Accounts Manager)
(121 Points)
Replied 21 January 2013
Procedure has mentioned on www.icai.org site for verificaiton of marks & also Inspection / certified copies of answersheet under RTI
kIRAN
CA Dimple Thacker
(It's Never Too Late)
(506 Points)
Replied 21 January 2013
But can we apply for certified copies of Nov 11 exam?
karthikeyan.v
(Chartered Accountant)
(523 Points)
Replied 21 January 2013
dear srinivas
go in for retotalling, there is every possibility for getting exemption,
regards
karthi
karthikeyan.v
(Chartered Accountant)
(523 Points)
Replied 21 January 2013
dear srinivas,
i cleared my final in retotalling during in May 12, if u r confident then go for retotalling
regards
karthi
Srinivas
(accountant)
(222 Points)
Replied 21 January 2013
thansk for all your responses, i will go ahead with revaluation.
thanks & regards
Srinivas
CA Tripurari Kumar Thakur
(Accounts Excutives)
(144 Points)
Replied 22 January 2013
dear friends plz tell me abt the fee to apply for revaluatuon per paper..
Abrar
(CA Final)
(61 Points)
Replied 22 January 2013
i lost my 2nd group by 7 marks..and worst case i got idt 59..i hope recounting gains me 1 mark..
Atul Kumar
(working employee)
(153 Points)
Replied 22 January 2013
Dear Srinivas
You must go for Revaluation because same case happend with me in PE-2 i got 58 mark in tax and because of Revalution i got exemption thanks to god in next attemept cleared my Group because of Exemption.
Sathish M
(Management Accountant)
(40581 Points)
Replied 23 January 2013
Friends a small clarification on this issue, there is no provision for re-valuation of the answer paper by ICAI but it is only re-verification (re-totaling).
On the query regarding obtaining certified copy of answer, time limit to obtain answer books, details of payment of fees, physical verification of answer book etc. please ensure you go through ICAI's Notification on Procedure for Verification of Answer Books of Chartered Accountants-Final, PCE, IPCE / ATE / IPCE Units, Examinations-May 2012 and CPT-June 2012. - (12-07-2012).
Link is https://www.icai.org/new_post.html?post_id=8645
Thanks
Sathish
Srinivas
(accountant)
(222 Points)
Replied 25 January 2013
Thanks Atul:
i will surely go for verification and test my luck.
Thanks
Srinivas
CAclubindia
