Ad Free CAclubindia and Daily Updates on your Mobile. Subscribe Now!

IDT Final

Aparna (CA Qualified) (122 Points)

12 May 2011

Please suggest me best book for IDT.

Thanks

Reply
Follow
Share

7 Replies

CA KETAN INANI (sharp & tannan(article trainee) Always Ready to help) (251 Points)
Replied 12 May 2011

bangar,sodani of aadhyas academy jaipur and its compiler which covers previous year papers of CA and CS final and questioned asked in RTPs.

ketan inani

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

(Guest)

BANGAR IS BEST . BUT YOU CAN ALSO SEE PADHUKA

Prajyot Pandit (Divisional Manager- Finance) (184 Points)
Replied 12 May 2011

hey, i honestly think that there is such concept like BEST BOOK of any subject. speciallly for IDT . ther are may groups who follow books according to need, some prefer BANGAR as its in Q &A format, SOme prefer AJAY JAIN, SOME prefer NS govindan while some go for K VAitheeswaran bookk.

you hav to decide for urself that wich book suits ur style of reading. for example, take bangar, its in question answer format, good for those who can mug up or like evry explanation in technical language, but that book lacks practical approach n those who like to study conceptually find it really hard to cope up with that authers book (both DT n IDT)

I always preferred DIPPAK GUPTA's modules as they are written from practical approach, n are better then evry other book on th esubject for those who want to Visualise n understand the technical subject like IDT. note that they are not as useful to the first time readers of IDT.

Conclusion: if u joined class of IDT n want to refer some book to gain practical knowledge of what exacly happens the go for dippak gupta's modules.

if u didnt join tutions n want to self study the go for either of NS govindan or K Vaitheeswaran

if u just wnna paas subject by Scoring good marks n keep specific approach then go for bangar

Aparna (CA Qualified) (122 Points)
Replied 12 May 2011

Thanks Prajyot....Ur comment really helped me

(Guest)

Well i my self bought NS Givindan as am doin self study.Its the best to make ur concepts very sound.the book has maintained the flow of sections unlike bangar.No doubt Vaitheaswaran & Datey are also very good Books .only thing which Distinguises N.s. Govindan's IDT from the latter two is ,this book tries to interact with the student & language is completely simplified.

But only limitation of the book is there are very limited practical questions.Apart from this the book is worth buying.

Am on research which book is ideal for practical questions...Wanted to knw abt datey's work book.If some could provide some insights with regard to same ,it would be helpful.

Regards.

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA.ViVeK M ACA (ACCOUNTS DEPARTMENT) (28544 Points)
Replied 12 May 2011

Three reference book is better

1. K vaidheeswaran

2. Yogendra Bangar

3. Deepak Gupta

Please find this link for all the useful information of your reference book......

Click here for more information

Sriram (CA FINAL) (126 Points)
Replied 12 May 2011

@ CA. Vivek M : Sorry sir, but in the interest of the students I have to tell u this.... K Vaidheeswaran book is not properly amended in Service Tax which was published for May 2011 exam... So on than basis I wont reommend that book... Bangar is good book, also can refer NS Govindan or Padhkas depending on how u like to study... Bangar & Padhkas is Q&A type & NS Govindan is Section wise...