I want to do ICWA but so many people told me that ICWA has less scope than CA and he also tells me both are equally tougher ? As I am working in BPO and I do not able to give full time to any of them...... Please give me your opinion?
Why CA has better prospectus than ICWA inspite of easyness? I saw so many persons doing CA/CWA and most of them are facing difficulty in passing ICWA than CA.?
Nidhi
(Student CA Final )
(226 Points)
Replied 02 June 2013
CA is a self Proclaimed Institute & course showing itself as Tough, However CWA now a days with Introduction of new Syallabus will be & is more tough than CA but really professional act of ICWAI institute that they are not unnecessarily making a Boast of themselves like CA institute.
I know that many many CA students here would not like my opinion about CA but there is a Fact in my opinion & I have made it. Honest to themselves People will accept this fact
CA. Abhishek Kumar Maurya
(ACA)
(490 Points)
Replied 02 June 2013
I agree...but not cent %..ICAI never boasts about CA course...It always motivates students to opt for CA.....it is the common crowd which takes CA course as VERY TOUGH NUT TO CRACK....If one has to be blamed...its mentality of people....not ICAI....
Sachin Rajput
(account exe)
(593 Points)
Replied 03 June 2013
it depends on knowlege.. how much you learned during professional course.
Both course have own value.
By the way I have done MBA but when we talk about knwoelge .. i m nill 
so its not mean mba is not good ... its depend on us only.
Please choose course as per your convenience & intrest.
Best of luck..
FCA girl
(article)
(149 Points)
Replied 03 June 2013
cwa kar le bhai jaldi baan jayega plus respect bhi ho gi. moreover every psu perfer cwa than a ca.
Ganeshbabu K
(Audit and Tax Advisory)
(48564 Points)
Replied 03 June 2013
as per my opinion
KNOWLEDGE IS THE THING HERE TO CONSIDERED,
NOT ICWA, OR CA..
SO IT WILL BE OK,,IF IT IS ICWA OR CA BUT CA MEANS SOME WHAT ..UPER HAND AS NAME WISE..AND CA'S ARE EXCERSIZING MONOPOLY OVER CERTIFICATION OF BALANCESHEETS
CA Srikanth Yadav
(Chartered Accountant)
(3162 Points)
Replied 03 June 2013
Considering that you're already doing a job, CMA is a better option for you. However, if you're okay with quitting your job, then you may consider doing CA as well.
And according to me, both CA and CMA are equally rewarding professions. Well how effectively you use your qualifications will purely depend on you :)
Anyways good luck
Ankur Garg
(Company Secretary and Compliance Officer)
(114773 Points)
Replied 03 June 2013
Be Bindas and go for CWA simply because you want to pursue CWA from your heart.
Forget what others are saying……apna dil ki baat sun dost…
Further position of fresh CAs is visible to all…………………………………….
Let me tell you any good PSU will straight pick you if you could demonstrate your knowledge and attitude at the right time and right place….. 
Snehungshu Banerjee
(Accountant )
(76 Points)
Replied 03 June 2013
What is the best for u in CA, CWA or CS, it is decided by candidate.They are well & good professionally equiped courses.
The courses like ca cwa or cs is not very easy to crack like bcom level.Full completion of course and clear the the finals is very hectic job.Students are in the final like me in cwa are fully aware about this.In this stage u cant cover full syylb, question are asked idirectlt in tricky nature.So prepare mentally for this kind of study.
Lastly donot try to think abt result, it creats pressure.
FCA girl
(article)
(149 Points)
Replied 04 June 2013
Ragothaman R.
(Finance Head)
(21 Points)
Replied 04 June 2013
Hi,
A CA can do ICWA since he will not find it difficult. But a Cost Accountant will not do CA as he is content with what he has. The ICAI has been formed by an act of Parliment, hence the existence of the ICAI is unquestionable by any body in India. If you find the qualified guys, a Chartered Accountant is more knowledgeble than a Cost Accountant.
Finally, to have a conclusive and informed opinion, you please visit the C.A. Exam Center and Cost Accountants' exam center, just half an hour before the exam starts. Really you can find the pin drop silence at the C.A. Exam center when hundreds of examinees have assembled out side the exam hall. In contrast at the I.C.W.A. exam center you can find a noise condition all along till all the students enter the exam hall.
Because majority of C.A. students are serious and majority of I.C.W.A.students are casual about their exam. This I've practically seen.
Sachin Rajput
(account exe)
(593 Points)
Replied 04 June 2013
"If you find the qualified guys, a Chartered Accountant is more knowledgeble than a Cost Accountant."
I fully agree with this statement but one think i noticed that now CA quality is decrease n quantitiy increase.
Respected all CA please dont take it personaly.. but seriously Now a Days Some CA has only degree not knoweldge..
CA Srikanth Yadav
(Chartered Accountant)
(3162 Points)
Replied 04 June 2013
| Originally posted by : Sachin Rajput | ||
 |
Respected all CA please dont take it personaly.. but seriously Now a Days Some CA has only degree not knoweldge. |
 |
When you put it that way, people are bound to be offended!!!
Sachin Rajput
(account exe)
(593 Points)
Replied 04 June 2013
Dear Srikant .. but its true..
ok lets put a query here .. n you will get lots of diffrenct ans by many of CA .. why coz of lack ok knoweldge..
25 Hours GST Scrutiny of Return and Notice Handling(With Recording)
Survey, Search and Seizure under Income Tax Act 1961
CAclubindia
