Ad Free CAclubindia and Daily Updates on your Mobile. Subscribe Now!

I made rti about answer sheet checking......but

CA HIRAL PATEL (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (536 Points)

23 January 2014

To all ca student , i want to know that i have made rti application ... " To, Institute of Chartered Accountants of India,(Delhi) please provide full procedure/manner regarding checking of answer sheet of ca exams paper. where answer sheet is going for checking and which place for decided for checking of answer sheet. Which person is eligible for checking of answer sheet. Is any cross verify whether any other person who is not eligible for this is also checking the same. Is any difference in marks between our actual answer sheet and mark sheet given. Is there are any manipulation with our marks i.e any grace or cutting. * Concerned CPIO Nodal Officer Supporting document (only pdf upto 1 MB) Supporting document not provided" has any one also done this rti...........and any risk on this ....???????

Reply
Follow
Share

27 Replies

CA Konfused (Chartered Accountant & CFA Level 1) (302 Points)
Replied 23 January 2014

Why you need a RTI...........Now you can see your answer sheets........so simply make an application for your answer sheet

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA HIRAL PATEL (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (536 Points)
Replied 23 January 2014

yes i know....to get certified copy directly from icai i can get...but if u read then it is for procedure that how they checking our answer sheet, how is the eligible person, where is our answer sheet is checking, etc.....so not for my answer sheet but for procedure which is done icai at the time checking answer sheet...............i have directly pointed out icai about this matter.....

this is my 3rd rti to icai................

CA Konfused (Chartered Accountant & CFA Level 1) (302 Points)
Replied 23 January 2014

You know what..........our answet sheets are checked by Bcom...students.........rather than knowing who checks the paper evaluate your answer sheet and after that also you have a feeling that you deserved more.........file a complaint..........but i am sure you will find out that you got more than you deserved....this is what was my expierience.........we students miss out on man points .....which gets cleared when we see our own answers.

Anil Sankar V (CA) (1877 Points)
Replied 23 January 2014

Ya..CA KONFUSED IS RITE.hiral patel , got to work hard and prove to be CA.THERE IS NO OTHER WAY TO GAIN RATHER THAN HARD WORK.U MAKE MISTAKES CORRECT THEM.

CA HIRAL PATEL (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (536 Points)
Replied 23 January 2014

ya dude...even i m think that i m first student of icai who receive answer sheet first.....i got my answer sheet after 2 rti application.................................................but my answer sheet is like the same if they verify or not verify...just tick against each qu. and put 1 2 4 0 0 1 2 3...like that....no reading no comments...........................bakwasssss checking..........

even our paper check in local train i have mail to icai also with evidence...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rtO_WQSkj58

1 Like

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA HIRAL PATEL (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (536 Points)
Replied 23 January 2014

yes, dude....definatly...................the only way.........to become ca is now a days smart work................with hard work...

CA Konfused (Chartered Accountant & CFA Level 1) (302 Points)
Replied 23 January 2014

What do you mean by now-a-days............earlier people used to pass without hardwork.

CA HIRAL PATEL (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (536 Points)
Replied 23 January 2014

No , my meaning is ab result 1-5% aaega to smart work bhi jyda karna padega...baki hard work to sab ca student karte he.................................

(Guest)

There would be no reply for this RTI filed. What you are demanding? place where answersheets are checked, it needs to be protected ICAI cant reveal who checks the papers.

What you can demand under RTI is the thing which matters you in your personal concern.

1) You can demand your certified copies

2) you can file appeal to prove that ICAI's checking was grossly incorrect

3) You can put the matter before judicial authorities.

you cant demand the information which is confidential like who sets the paper and who checks answersheet and the place where they are checked. you can get info which is public. example you can demand ICAI to provide detailed analysis of students appeared in final exam state wise or region wise.

Reference:

Right to Information Act, 2005--Section 6--Information on reasons for passing judicial order-- Legality--Held--An applicant can get any information which is already in existence and accessible to public authority under law--But cannot ask any information as to why such opinion, advice etc. have been passed especially in matters pertaining to judicial decisions--Answers to those could not have been with the public authority nor could he had access to the said information--Remedy for a party aggrieved there by lies in a challenge by way of appeal, revision or any other legally permissible mode--High Court rightly dismissed writ petition. [Para--5 and 8]

2 Like

(Guest)

@ HIRAL PATEL

did you received certified copy of your answersheet under RTI ?

if yes plz share the procedure.

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA HIRAL PATEL (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (536 Points)
Replied 23 January 2014

Yes dude, but many time before , i m received for ipcc in 2011.....now only way to get your answer sheet is directly from icai u can get...............per sub. for rs. 500., again i say i have not demanded my answer sheet from rti i just demand that only way they checking our procedure,

atleast we ca know that which persons are eligible for checking our answer sheet. i not say that give me the list, place list etc...just overall procedure...............................even i have demanded 2 times certified copies from icai per sub. 500/- nov 13 exam also.

(Guest)

ya hope so that ICAI wil provide this info.

there is a topic / thread for getting certified copies under RTI @ 10 rs. do you think it will work.?

CA HIRAL PATEL (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (536 Points)
Replied 23 January 2014

are i have not filed rti to icai, i have filed rti to Department of Higher Education from RTI online with 10 rs/ payment...they coordinate with icai and if icai provides then they give me other wise they say it is not as per law, so they can;t give...........same fear is come against me when i give rti in 2011 just before my 3rd ipcc attempt even my principle CA is say they don;t do, many my ca clubindia student say vo tera result me dekh lenge........you can see my 2 years above post with same comment............but i m fearless kya karenge............ca nai hone denge, bas itna...........agar us time ye socha hota to aaj ye certified copy sayad na bhi milti.....b.coz sme body say that i m first who received my answer sheet.........even i have rti in 2009 also but at that time suprim court judgement is not there but in 2011 karnataka/Kearla high court ref. judgement i have mentioned in rti application..............

shafey (Student CA Final ) (27 Points)
Replied 24 January 2014

@ Hiral patel how could u say that ab rsults 5 k niche hga har bar , president to badal jata h na feb m I thot rslts might imp in nxt attmpt, u have any refernce or source