Go Ad-Free on CAclubindia with Daily Mobile Updates. Subscribe Now!

How was International tax paper 6 c ? for nov 19? Please give detailed analysis !

seeta (student) (74 Points)

13 November 2019

Many students are saying it was difficult and also we cant get the question paper to check for ourselves so can someone take some time out to tell me why exactly was the paper so difficult?

Reply
Follow
Share

6 Replies

Anushka kapoor (Ca) (42 Points)
Replied 13 November 2019

Today’s International tax paper was fantastic and required indepth knowledge. Students of Vinod Gupta Sir will surely get 80 plus marks!

100 percent paper was from VG Sir concepts. One will learn that old is gold. No shortcuts to success

People criticise that Vinod Gupta teaches in detail. Now no one will cricise

4 Like

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

akshay parakh (Chartered Accountant) (394 Points)
Replied 14 November 2019

Please kisi teacher ki marketing na kre.
paper was lengthy but yes it was moderate..bit of tricky ques and simple as well

2 Like

Nysha Gill (CA) (15 Points)
Replied 14 November 2019

What's there to say? The paper was lengthy and conceptual and being a student of Bhanwar Borana I was not prepared for that. That man has really played us this time. IDK what the hell he taught in his classes, but there was not even a single question in the whole paper that Borana Sir ever taught in his class. All this time, he kept mumbling about shortcuts and tricks and never taught any topic in detail. But ICAI came out with a knowledge-based paper that really tested the students to their core. Nevertheless, lesson learned. I have already started preparing for my next attempt and this time I won't make the same mistakes.

2 Like

Ankush Mishra (CA) (19 Points)
Replied 14 November 2019

Rightly said bro, Bhanwar Borana was a Bubble that has busted after November 19 International Tax Paper.

Students are realizing the truth and those who were attending his classes have left it in the middle and are going to a good teacher now.

As a teacher, it was his responsibility to teach his students in an effective manner rather than just wrapping up the syllabus as soon as possible. ICAI has surprised everyone by setting up a conceptual paper and only those who have studied each topic thoroughly were able to solve the questions. This is why it is important to have good knowledge of the concepts.

2 Like

Vishnu Shukla (2 Points)
Replied 14 November 2019

The international taxation paper was very conceptual and knowledge-centric and only those who have done in-depth study were able to write answers.
The questions were quite long and tricky like the whole case study on the famous Vodafone case, I had no good knowledge about this and thus I failed to answer this question as expected.

I took classes from Bhanwar Borana Sir and he finished this whole topic under 30 minutes and skipped a lot of details only to finish it fast. This is only one example from his class. There are numerous topics and reports that he skipped in his class and many of his students like me will have to suffer because of this.

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

shyam yadav (12 Points)
Replied 14 November 2019

I can able to attempt for 65 marks around in 4hours it was that lengthy. but I it is not too difficult 5 case studies were given but size of the case study was maintained as earlier.

2 Like