Many students say exams point of view Sekar is best than manoharan related to presentation or case laws and misc. what are ur views. Sekar book has less practical problems...
19 Replies
CA. Raghav Goyal
(CA Practice)
(150 Points)
Replied 11 January 2011
N wat do u think about vinod gupta's modules??!!
they are much more exam oriented...
Madroamer
(-)
(168 Points)
Replied 11 January 2011
couldn get a glimpse of VG sir book. but saw Ahuja book. its purely theoritical presentation no practical problems i found at each chapter end or in middle.
Manmohan ACA, CS
(Chartered Accountant )
(14243 Points)
Replied 12 January 2011
Vinod Gupta books are Best with lots and lots of practical problem after that better go for Girish Ahuja book
T. N. Manoharan does not contain entire syllabus which can come in examination !!
CA MAULIK
(C.A)
(937 Points)
Replied 12 January 2011
There are many mistakes in MANOHARAN,,for the past papers QUE ,,refer PADUKA...otherwise for incometax act preparation,,do GIRISH AHUJA...
prerna
(student)
(91 Points)
Replied 12 January 2011
go for v.gupta with ur eyes closed , bestest book in ca syllabus
George
(Chartered Accountant)
(649 Points)
Replied 12 January 2011
Both are good . It depends on your way of studying .Shekars book is in question answer format with past RTP's and Exams covered and Manoharans book is easy to read and understand like reading a story (What I felt). For me I have cleared both PE-II and Final second group when I shifted from Shekar to Manoharan. But I know a lot of people endorsing Shekars book also.
For me I felt the presentation in Manoharans book more comfortable and also the concise presentation for revision at the end was very helpful for me to revise almost the whole book very easily and quickly ( The same thing is there in Shekars book also , but in different format ) .
GURU PRANESH
(FCA(FUTURE CA))
(459 Points)
Replied 12 January 2011
| Originally posted by : George | ||
 |
Both are good . It depends on your way of studying .Shekars book is in question answer format with past RTP's and Exams covered and Manoharans book is easy to read and understand like reading a story (What I felt). For me I have cleared both PE-II and Final second group when I shifted from Shekar to Manoharan. But I know a lot of people endorsing Shekars book also. For me I felt the presentation in Manoharans book more comfortable and also the concise presentation for revision at the end was very helpful for me to revise almost the whole book very easily and quickly ( The same thing is there in Shekars book also , but in different format ) . |
 |
CA-CWA RAVI
(CA-CWA in industry)
(5464 Points)
Replied 12 January 2011
sorry i dont knw
i read vinod gupta sir's module
but suffered during exams as around 35 marks were not from what he taught us
Justin Raj.s
(CA Final)
(55 Points)
Replied 12 January 2011
Friends,
In my opinion Sekhar Sir's Book has some basic mistakes. It is not at the CA Final Level. For example some basic mistakes under Section 28, 44AD etc. Manoharan Sir's book has no mistakes but it not covered entire syllabus and has lack of concept clarity. The best book that will lead to success both in exam and practice is - Dr.Vinod . K. Singhania & Kapil Singhania - Direct Tax Law & Practice-
Just test, you will like the subject.
Justin Raj.s
(CA Final)
(55 Points)
Replied 12 January 2011
Friends,
In my opinion Sekhar Sir's Book has some basic mistakes. It is not at the CA Final Level. For example some basic mistakes under Section 28, 44AD etc. Manoharan Sir's book has no mistakes but it not covered entire syllabus and has lack of concept clarity. The best book that will lead to success both in exam and practice is - Dr.Vinod . K. Singhania & Kapil Singhania - Direct Tax Law & Practice-
Just test, you will like the subject.
A.Deepa
(CA )
(195 Points)
Replied 12 January 2011
In my view T.N.Manoharan book is the best book. I prepared tax for both PEII & CA-Final without any coaching classes by simply adopting this book. I cleared my tax subjects with more marks which helped in the aggregate scoring. The concepts with simple examples. it is easily understandable. At the end of each chapter, a question that has asked in the previous exams with answers was attached. After studying the concepts and principles thoroughly, we can try to solve the problem asked in the prevous exams which is attached. This helps to know about the pulse of the question setter. it is even best for self study without coaching.
CA Biswaranjan
(job)
(149 Points)
Replied 12 January 2011
In my opinion T N manoharan is better, it is easy to understand and exam oriented also.
Recent Topics
- Regarding Perquisite Tax on ESOP - Unlisted Compan
- Casual Taxable Person under GST
- Extended Date of GSTR-1 for the month of July 2020
- NRO Interest - Taxed at source and in Foreign Coun
- Clarity needed on effective date
- Income Tax Refund Deadline Shortened to Five Years
- Rectification Applications for Past GST Demands
- GST Invoices Series
- FILING OF ITR AY 20-21
- CLAIMING OF UNCLAIMED RCM
Related Threads
CAclubindia
