Option 1 is applicable. Option two is wrong.. Who can make only exempted supplies and they get any URD supplies and Notified RCM supplies they can pay tax under RCM basis... But, can't take credit....
first of all both are not options. first supply decide whether you have to pay GST on outward supply and answer is no.
Second supply decide whether you have to pay GST on inward supply subject to reverse charge and answer is yes you have to pay GST under Sec 9(3). Let me check how to take "refund" as my entire outward supply is exempt supply as pointed out by Raja P M.