Ad Free CAclubindia and Daily Updates on your Mobile. Subscribe Now!

EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED AND CS SHOULD BE OUT OF ' DTC 2013 '

PALASH (Nothing) (2000 Points)

03 October 2014

" EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED AS FAR AS DTC 2013 IS CONCERNED "

Direct Tax Code 2013 which is not yet passed and effective is making big news in Chartered Profession .

I respect all the professional bodies so please kindly don't take me wrong .
My question is that as far as SYLLABUS is concern, PATENT AREA IN CA PROFESSION is INCOME TAX , AUDIT, ACCOUNTANCY .

Does the same way is followed in the course of CS, If yes, then surely CAs monopoly would break and if no then what is the point of allowing other professionals to conduct an assignment of which they don't have in depth knowledge ??

Thanks
Regards.

Reply
Follow
Share

9 Replies

@VaibhavJ (Believe!! Live your dreams!) (33516 Points)
Replied 03 October 2014

Are all CA's are equally proficient while parting with their services?

I believe once you are professionally qualified then let it be CA, CS or CMS they are equally competent to serve in finance/tax/audit services!!

Insted we as a CA should demand role of CS & CMA in from of authorities rather then restricting...

Be positive ..

Thanks!!

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

PALASH (Nothing) (2000 Points)
Replied 03 October 2014

I hate diplomatic answer , my straight forward question to you that ",

what is the point of allowing other professionals to conduct an assignment of which they don't have in depth knowledge ?

Pls don't give any diplomatic and defensive answer , need a concrete answer ,

Grow up & Go aheadddddd

ok.

1 Like

Mihir (Wealth Manager) (5293 Points)
Replied 04 October 2014

Anything is possible here. Ground reality is very different. Lets not get stuck in arguing what is right or wrong.

I agree with Vaibhav. And instead of even making a slightest attempt to understand what he is saying, you, as usual, want to start roaring at others. Not good for you, as a professional. Nobody will ever get scared or be submissive to your aggressiveness here. So be cool and write questions/answers respectfully. Nobody cares what you like or hate or what kind of answers you have defined in your head. Here, people will express their opinion and don't care to please you by telling you what you want to hear.

So chill........

1 Like

PALASH (Nothing) (2000 Points)
Replied 04 October 2014

You have done a great mistake bcoz first of all you have to reach that level from where you can Critisize my commitments &

One thing you must remember that ' Truth is truth , No one can deny this and No one can change this " ok,

I HAVE NO INTENTION TO UNDERESTIMATE ANYBODY , ONLY INTENTION IS TO BRING OUT THE ACTUAL TRUTH IN FRONT OF EVERY ONE ,, GOT IT !!!!

So first of all , you have to change yourself , you have to improve yourself .

Grow up !!! Be a man

Regards.

Mihir (Wealth Manager) (5293 Points)
Replied 04 October 2014

Join some spiritual/religious forum if you are looking for your so-called "truth".

I do agree that I need to change. Change what? Change my thinking about you - you will always remain this same person all your life with a massive ego.

Lucky you, finally you made me agree with you!! Go party now and distribute little toffees with kids.

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

PALASH (Nothing) (2000 Points)
Replied 05 October 2014

At present You are not now in a position to critisize my comments , and i don't know whether u belong to any professional body or not but one thing i must say that you have to go for a long way .

' Be a man '

Regards

Rajagopalakrishnan R (PARTNER) (1422 Points)
Replied 05 October 2014

I think we should all refrain from attacking anyone personally here in this forum. That will make us lose focus. See here the main poser as to how a CS can diligently discharge an audit function in the context of DTC is out of focus now!!

Let's discuss ideas not "people"

Mihir (Wealth Manager) (5293 Points)
Replied 06 October 2014

I have been noticing Palash's arrogant replies to anybody sharing their opinion to his questions. Palash needs to think before spoiling anybody's day by his self-righteous arrogant statements. This time I am letting it go, although, I could have pursued this issue till he backs down in shame.

I have no need to respond to any of his questions / replies after this point.