Expectation from Nov 17 CA results

Page no : 3

CA Abbasali H. Bhaisaheb (Working as A FACULY FOR CA STUDENTS) (1127 Points)
Replied 15 January 2018

I think DT or costing should have gracing...Costing was though easier but too lenthy... DT was again unexpected...isca me 3 mark ka kya karenge bhai

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

NIKHIL (article trainee) (204 Points)
Replied 15 January 2018

I think Anurag predictions will be correct..
last time he mentioned idt 5-6 marks...
is anyone got that grace marks

samraj (5) (95 Points)
Replied 15 January 2018

Guys no point in discussing about how much icai should give or not..it is not in our hands now...only till giving exam was in our hands..not beyond that...jo honewala hai wo to hoga hi so no pointing discussing about what icai should do...Instead let's invest this time in reading something that will add value to our professional career...

3 Like

NIKHIL (article trainee) (204 Points)
Replied 15 January 2018

I want to know whether it is reliable

1 Like

CA Abbasali H. Bhaisaheb (Working as A FACULY FOR CA STUDENTS) (1127 Points)
Replied 15 January 2018

I don't know its reliability but i can say that 3 marks de ke koi vadi bat ni kari Institute ne

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

NIKHIL (article trainee) (204 Points)
Replied 15 January 2018

not play with emotions of people

1 Like

CA Abbasali H. Bhaisaheb (Working as A FACULY FOR CA STUDENTS) (1127 Points)
Replied 15 January 2018

I won't reply now this is completely blunder... I mean double digits group 2 plus better than last time is not at all possible simply by adding 3 marks... Haaah see u all after results.

Anmol Davesar (Chartered Accountant) (818 Points)
Replied 15 January 2018

Abbasali bhai tera sahi hogya tu isiliye keh ra hai ISCA mein kyun dedia 3. Mere liye toh 3marks Gift hai

2 Like

Aritra Majumdar (B.Com(H),CA) (2420 Points)
Replied 15 January 2018

Sachin - I have to say your preparation must have been rock solid so you said dt paper was easy.

For me dt was a very mixed exam- Case laws were good, tds/tcs and other theory questions related to assessments and returns were also good.

But transfer pricing, 80-ia and 10aa were really disappointing. 16 marks question 2 was partially good...

Hoping for reasonable marks in dt.

samraj (5) (95 Points)
Replied 15 January 2018

Guys ye sab discussion karke Kya achieve karenge hum sab...no point in discussing so long on all this...17th ko jo hoga wohi hoga..apne baat Karne se ya serious discussion se kuch nahi badlega...I understand the result anxiety..even m facing the same..but ab baat karke koi meaning nahi...Instead I was suggest 2 din hai ..njoy to the fullest

1 Like

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Aritra Majumdar (B.Com(H),CA) (2420 Points)
Replied 15 January 2018

Nikhil- Yes I know a friend who got grace marks in idt last time, he got 4 marks as grace...showed me his certified copy.

1 Like

samraj (5) (95 Points)
Replied 15 January 2018

1 Like

NIKHIL (article trainee) (204 Points)
Replied 15 January 2018

@ aritra that's good to hear

(Guest)

Anurag sir jo bhi updates dete hai wo 100% true hote hai. It is possible to have double digit result for 2nd group and ISCA 3 marks will be really a big thing for those who just failed in ISCA at 37 marks.

I dont know why all you are discussing about how much grace marks should ICAI give to a subject. Friedns we are not Central Concil members, we are students and we cant decide it, nor there is any point in discussing about what ICAI should do. Right now ICAI is like GOD to us. Whatever we are getting is gift to us.