Yes thats what I replied , if the Receptient GTA is not partnership firm & Company , then It's Exempted (Refer Notification 32/2017 CT (R)
Exemption to GTA Services
Page no : 2
Pankaj Rawat
(GST Practitioner)
(55052 Points)
Replied 03 May 2020
And Moreover as per queriest , the Recepeint GTA (PQR) is URD hence It's Exempted subject to condition that Recepeint GTA is not a company or partnership firm
CA Altamush Zafar
(GST Consultant)
(15971 Points)
Replied 03 May 2020
Now what you are is saying is correct as there is no GTA to GTA blanket exemption
RAJA P M
("Do the Right Thing...!!!")
(128091 Points)
Replied 03 May 2020
Yes... I agreed to Mr Pankaj Rawat Ji view...
Pankaj Rawat
(GST Practitioner)
(55052 Points)
Replied 03 May 2020
Dear Altamush
It's understandable that One GTA is providing services to Another Services is transportation of goods (hiring of transport )
It's understandable that One GTA is providing services to Another Services is transportation of goods (hiring of transport )
Pankaj Rawat
(GST Practitioner)
(55052 Points)
Replied 03 May 2020
And Moreover as per queriest , the Recepeint GTA (PQR) is URD hence It's Exempted subject to condition that Recepeint GTA is not a company or partnership firm
CA Altamush Zafar
(GST Consultant)
(15971 Points)
Replied 03 May 2020
No, not necessarily. It can also be of nature of subcontracting.
There is a thin line of difference between transportation service and hiring service but there is a difference. Moreover it's not only GTA who gives trucks on hire. Generally people who give trucks on hire are specifically in that business and they don't provide transportation services.
CA Altamush Zafar
(GST Consultant)
(15971 Points)
Replied 03 May 2020
@ RAJA P M
Mr Pankaj has also accepted my view. I would advise you read the law carefully and then answer and stop misguiding querists.
CA Altamush Zafar
(GST Consultant)
(15971 Points)
Replied 03 May 2020
Yes it is subject to it as I already explained in my first reply but it is not a blanket exemption at any rate.
RAJA P M
("Do the Right Thing...!!!")
(128091 Points)
Replied 04 May 2020
@ Zafar,
I know who is misguide. You keep Your views and Guidance. No need to me Also I know how can read the law careeefully... No need any advice from You
CA Altamush Zafar
(GST Consultant)
(15971 Points)
Replied 04 May 2020
Doesn't look like it and I have seen you since 2017.
Although I am not here to personally bash you. But I would say one thing DON'T ANSWER IF YOU DON'T KNOW THE ANSWER BEACUSE THEN YOU MISGUIDE PEOPLE WITH THOSE WRONG ANSWERS
GOOD LUCK
RAJA P M
("Do the Right Thing...!!!")
(128091 Points)
Replied 04 May 2020
Kk kk very very tanks... same to you dear...
god bless you.
god bless you.
Pankaj Rawat
(GST Practitioner)
(55052 Points)
Replied 04 May 2020
@ Zafar
When one GTA is giving service to another GTA , then he is hiring his vehicle , he is not giving transportation service to GTA , it's customer ,who is Availing the service of Transportation of Goods.
If you read the Notification 12/2017 CT (R)
Service's by way of giving on hire-
(a).....
(b) to GTA , means transportation of goods.
So from above it's specifically mentioned the "by way of giving hire"
means either GTA or transporter who is giving his vehicle on hiring basis to GTA (for transportation of Goods) is Exempted services .
So it's advisable before raising finger go through the wording of Notification carefully.
When one GTA is giving service to another GTA , then he is hiring his vehicle , he is not giving transportation service to GTA , it's customer ,who is Availing the service of Transportation of Goods.
If you read the Notification 12/2017 CT (R)
Service's by way of giving on hire-
(a).....
(b) to GTA , means transportation of goods.
So from above it's specifically mentioned the "by way of giving hire"
means either GTA or transporter who is giving his vehicle on hiring basis to GTA (for transportation of Goods) is Exempted services .
So it's advisable before raising finger go through the wording of Notification carefully.
RAJA P M
("Do the Right Thing...!!!")
(128091 Points)
Replied 04 May 2020
Dear Mr Pankaj Rawat Ji.,
What about the AAR to the applicant of Saravana Perumal by Karnataka GST authority...
What about the AAR to the applicant of Saravana Perumal by Karnataka GST authority...
Recent Topics
- Nznxnc call me at the end of the day of the
- Cp chod doob zoom vo book book
- Nsje snswk fjw ed le ene djff ne enje ejdd rejje
- Hxjcif the day I have been in touch with me and
- Iska djd djrbdsjebshe sir ur rei ejr reinr the jr
- GST registration for medical shop in Karnataka
- Hsshs me know if you are free number of the
- Chu Kang and the situation of the situation and I
- How to reverse wrong transaction payment in phonep
- Paytm wrong transaction
Related Threads
CAclubindia
