girish (article) (567 Points)
29 July 2010I request CCI to have an exlusive interview with examiners to know where exactly the students are lacking in presenting their answers and guide us with some important things. Hope CCI will consider this matter with utmost care.
Note : I don't think there might be pressure of Code of Conduct on ICAI member
its of no use of having conversation with Toppers of CA exams !
[ Regret to say this but true fact lies in it ]
Expecting CCI members views on this matter
CA CS Himanshu Khandelwal
(SAP FICO Consultant)
(705 Points)
Replied 29 July 2010
At the back of the suggested answers the views of the examiners checking the papers with respect to each of the questions are given and the problems or defects in the answer of the students are also being mentioned in their view......
girish
(article)
(567 Points)
Replied 29 July 2010
| Originally posted by : Himanshu | ||
 |
At the back of the suggested answers the views of the examiners checking the papers with respect to each of the questions are given and the problems or defects in the answer of the students are also being mentioned in their view...... |
 |
Do you think that information is sufficient enough to cater the needs of students ?
CA CS Himanshu Khandelwal
(SAP FICO Consultant)
(705 Points)
Replied 29 July 2010
Yes i do think so......
Robin
(AUDITOR)
(854 Points)
Replied 29 July 2010
| Originally posted by : Himanshu | ||
|
|
At the back of the suggested answers the views of the examiners checking the papers with respect to each of the questions are given and the problems or defects in the answer of the students are also being mentioned in their view...... |
|
Think with broad mindedly ! its not enough as its a view mentioned on particular questions in each exams.
Better CCI shall have long discussion with ICAI examiners
CA CS Himanshu Khandelwal
(SAP FICO Consultant)
(705 Points)
Replied 29 July 2010
@ Robin
If ur doing CA....
And in that i dont think that any1 need baby step like step by step-each problem framed....
the general view is being given by examiners checking the papers and they cant provide the specific view that u want....
so be practically rather than thinking that any 1 can provide u step by sep ans to ur questions
And i do agree that the discussions to be done with them bt not for highliting the problems bt for providing the solutions....
Robin
(AUDITOR)
(854 Points)
Replied 29 July 2010
Ofcourse the discussion has to be done with them. But your point was completely looking off-track
Robin
(AUDITOR)
(854 Points)
Replied 29 July 2010
| Originally posted by : Himanshu | ||
|
|
@ Robin If ur doing CA.... And in that i dont think that any1 need baby step like step by step-each problem framed.... the general view is being given by examiners checking the papers and they cant provide the specific view that u want.... so be practically rather than thinking that any 1 can provide u step by sep ans to ur questions And i do agree that the discussions to be done with them bt not for highliting the problems bt for providing the solutions.... |
|
Ofcourse the discussion has to be done with them. But your point was completely looking off-track
CA CS Himanshu Khandelwal
(SAP FICO Consultant)
(705 Points)
Replied 30 July 2010
Ofcourse the discussion has to be done with them. But your point was completely looking off-track
I didnt agree with u.....
CA-CWA RAVI
(CA-CWA in industry)
(5464 Points)
Replied 30 July 2010
read the student newsletter regularly
the BOS keep shouting wat it requires
" refer to study materials of ICAI ''
read the lates august 2010 students journal the same has again pointed by Director BOS shri vinod jain
CA CS Himanshu Khandelwal
(SAP FICO Consultant)
(705 Points)
Replied 30 July 2010
Agree with Ravi....
Robin
(AUDITOR)
(854 Points)
Replied 30 July 2010
yesssssss agreed but the intention of this post seems to be giving a hint that examiners interview especially from CCI is of honour for everyone of CCI member
CAclubindia
