ethics and ca

Articleship 1410 views 6 replies

I am searching for a CA firm for artcleship. But, many of my friends and relatives are advising me not to persue Chartered Accountancy as they say that it is a ganda kaam( it involves doing dirty work). How far is it true? I have heard that the job involves manupulating accounts to serve the client, giving certificates that you know are false, etc.Which is the statement that you think best describes the situation.

1) The job of a chartered accountant is dirty. My friends and relativesare right.

2) It is area specific i.e some areas such astax/audit/valuation/internal audit involve doing more/less dirty work as compared to others.

3) It is firm specific i.e some firms do more dirty work and some firms are clean.

4) It is client specific i.e some audits may be clean while some companies being dirty, dirty work has to be done by firms also.

5) Ethics is a subjective term. A person may consider giving advice to evade taxes to clients as unethical while another person may not consider it ethical.

6) Manipulations/doing dirty work is everywhere, whatever profession you choose. It is not limited to CA.

Of course, there are no clear answers to these questions. So, what do you feel should I do - join artcleship or persue some other course in future such as MBA, assuming dummy articleship is not an option. If you feelthat this question is inapproprate for a forum like this, I am sorry.

Awaiting replies!
 

Replies (6)

 Hi,Vishal !!!

According to me, it depends on us when the question of following laws, rules, ethics etc. arises. When one person does something wrong it does not mean that the whole community is bad or wrong. I am not saying this because i am a student of this course, but i am saying this because i have trust on myself. I am sure that if ,in future i will become a Chartered Accountant i will not do such kind of activities which you have mentioned above.

 

I am niether forcing you to join the course nor insulting you but if you think that by joining this course you will become ethicless than you are absolutely wrong. It entirely depends on yourself. So whatever decision you take please believe in yourself and also have trust on this profession which is one of the most renowned profession not only in India but also entire World.And also it is not that  anybody could become a Ca . This course  requires lots of hardwork, patience and lots of motivation.Hence whoever has achieved this degree are not ordinary persons like others.

Please do remember this.

 

Bye and ALL THE BEST.............

top 50 ca firms in delhi

I agree with Darshu.It is on ourself to do or not to do something.Hope you would have got the answer.

Originally posted by :Darshu
"

Hi Darshu!

Thanks for  your detailed reply.

If it is a few chartered accountants doing such things as you say I have no issues at all. My only apprehension is with all/majority(90%+) CA's doing these things. 

"


 

heyyyyyyyyyy!

dont u have any sense???? dont you have any values?? let me tell u ll never achieve in life anything u go with such an attitude! u are asking whether  the profession is a dirty one or not. what the hell u think of u? mind ur words wen u are in a social place . Be it internet or physical place. u just dont hav right for such stupidity. and when it comes to justification no one need explanation for it.

Heard of Ashok leyland? its Chairman& MD Mr.Seshasayee is a CA. watch NDTV ? NDTV 's proud owner Mr. Prannoy Roy is also a CA. the list is bigger like Kumar mangalam Birla etc .

I dono in which place u live. but jus give a visit to  the CA institute at ur place. you ll know what it is......................

 

 

Originally posted by :Guest
" top 50 ca firms in delhi "


 


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register