A learner (Corporate Accounts ) (345 Points)
03 December 2010Dear All,
Please suggest me accounting treatment for advance received against capital asset and forfeited by Co.
Is it revenue in nature and should be shown in extraordinary income?
or is it a capital receipt and should be part of capital reserve?
Would be grateful, if you can please share facts, guidance notes etc. in support of your view, as mere views without logic will be of little help to me..
Many many thanks for your prompt replies.
Thanks & Regards,
CA Deepesh Ruhela
(Keen to Learn)
(3271 Points)
Replied 04 December 2010
it is capital receipt because its against capital asset & its not ordinary activity. therefore it should transfer to Capital Reserve.
CA Tarkeshwar
(job)
(77 Points)
Replied 07 December 2010
dear friend
there is no standards and guidance notes relevant to your query, the logical answer is as follow
If capital asset is fixed assets, it can not be the revenue income , but the extra-ordinary income. the advance received might be for sale of capital capital and subsequently neither transfer of capital asset take place nor refund of advance, so the entries is for writting off the advance in the statement of profot and loss account by passing the following entries
Advance from Mr. .................A/c .........................Dr.
To Profit or loss a/c
(Being forfeiture of amount received in advance for sale of capital asset)
and should be shown as extraordinary income
If the person is engaged in the business of hire-purchase sale, this income may be in nature of operating activities
Rajesh
(Articled Clerk)
(50 Points)
Replied 09 December 2010
According to me, the income should form a part of capital reserve firstly as it is of a non recurring nature and secondly the income is much similar to that of a sale of capital asset in a very short span of time
A learner
(Corporate Accounts )
(345 Points)
Replied 12 December 2010
Thanks to all for posting and sharing the views..
I Would request experts to please throw some light as two diferent opinions are there and consensus is difficult to reach..
Regards
CAclubindia
