Discuss and Download CA Final Exam question paper Nov 2013

Page no : 7

Kalpesh Chauhan, (Tax Assistant (Accounting Technician CA FINAL CS PROF. PROG. B.Com)) (8311 Points)
Replied 13 November 2013

Originally posted by : Aniket Naik
	In my view it was easy but as usual LENGHTY

x y z n std costing was very tricky

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Prasad Jadhav (..) (63 Points)
Replied 14 November 2013

what was the answer for assignment problem ????

1 Like

CHANDA SINGH (CA) (123 Points)
Replied 14 November 2013

If Gandhiji would have ever thought about doing.. "c.a."!!!!:- . . He would have definitely added a 4th monkey wid hands on its forehead... ;-( :-O :-P

3 Like

Richa ( ) (377 Points)
Replied 14 November 2013

If Gandhiji would have ever thought about doing.. "c.a."!!!!:- . . He would have definitely added a 4th monkey wid hands on its forehead... ;-( :-O :-P Hahaha.....lol

Kalpesh Chauhan, (Tax Assistant (Accounting Technician CA FINAL CS PROF. PROG. B.Com)) (8311 Points)
Replied 14 November 2013

Assignment question was very tough question on 2nd part .

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Kalpesh Chauhan, (Tax Assistant (Accounting Technician CA FINAL CS PROF. PROG. B.Com)) (8311 Points)
Replied 14 November 2013

How was costing paper ? Why No one is sharing ?

Bhav Bhuti Sharma (Towards Professionalism ) (823 Points)
Replied 14 November 2013

Exams ki wajah se caclubindia par aane ka time nahi hai but fb ka time hai m sab waha par he discuss karte hai https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=10151786979657151&id=107396132150&refid=17&ref=stream

courageous Aries ( ) (263 Points)
Replied 14 November 2013

Originally posted by : Prasad Jadhav
	what was the answer for assignment problem ????

courageous Aries ( ) (263 Points)
Replied 14 November 2013

Originally posted by : Prasad Jadhav
	what was the answer for assignment problem ????

Dear Friend The Answer for first part is no, it is not necessary that if two elements of row after row and coulmn reduction are zero, originally items were zero. Consider the following matrix after row reduction
a11 a12 a13 a14

a21 a22 a23 a24

a31 a32 a33 a34

a41 a42 a43 a44
if in above matrix if say a11 and a13 elemnts are minimum for respective column then two elemnts shall be zero.. and it is not necesaary that they both were equal For second part consider the above matrix and draw the optimumal solution, we are given two , just persorm the addnl steps of geting remaning two answer

Deepika Bohra (NA) (33 Points)
Replied 14 November 2013

Q6(a) in case of SFM was totally correct, it was based on Gordon model. As, many of us know growth rate = retention ratio* rate of return g= b*r Gordon's formula = D1 / ke-g OR EPS1(1-b)/ke-br OR Current yr EPS*(1+br)(1-b)/ke-br Any of above formula could have worked.... Question was correct by every means,just needed good use of mind.

1 Like

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Deepika Bohra (NA) (33 Points)
Replied 14 November 2013

Same kind of question are given in most of books, , but ICAI twisted it to include rate of return instead of growth rate :). Don't let ICAI trick you people. Since most people are used to solving this question by growth rate, a little application of mind could have helped instead of thinking that Q was wrong. Anything can happen in exam of this level, instead of blaming the institute prepare well. Good luck for next paper....

1 Like

Manoj Garg (Final student) (150 Points)
Replied 14 November 2013

well done deepika nice thinking

CA Abhinav (Chartered Accountant) (496 Points)
Replied 15 November 2013

@ Deepika Bohra If you think question is correct then solve the part 6(b) using the ke of 6(a). Also guideline answer given by Sir sanjay saraf confirms that there is typographical error in 6(a) question which is also supported by Sir Nagendra Shah post in CAclubIndia. Below are the relevant links for your reference.

/forum/detailed-analysis-of-sfm-nov-13-paper-by-ca-nagendra-270282.asp#.UoWPfuI4bDw

/forum/sfm-november-13-solutions-by-sanjay-saraf-sir-270383.asp#.UoWOkeI4bDw

HIMANSHU SHARMA (STUDENT) (117 Points)
Replied 15 November 2013

SFM: COMBINATION OF ONE QUESTION REPEAT ION & OTHER FRESH QUESTION ...BUT OVERALL GOOD PAPER AUDIT: EASY PAPER,LOTS OF REPEATION, OTHER NEWLY QUESTION WILL BE EASILY UNDERSTANDABLE LAW: EASY REPEATION PAPER, SUGGEST: MUNISHBANDARI & PRACTICEMODULE.