Dis like button needed in caclub

Articleship 664 views 4 replies

rajesh

article

47 Points Joined May 2013

Dear Friends,

There is a thank button in Ca club India for showing our appreciation and we are using it

But we also need Dislike Button to show our Angry on those who does Useless replies&other irrelevant...

Expert Section:-

1)There are some people in Experts Section who always Use to Agree with Above experts,,By replying Agree with above expert even a Small Accountant Like me also can reply to all pending quries in caclubindia,,No need to be an expert for that

Kindly Note this and Please try to provide quality replies in expert Section,

2)Quality of replies Should be Noted instead of Counting the No. of Quries Answered

3)Some of quiries were answered like..(refer income tax act,and advising us to refer to specified Section in So and so act and [they use to say that all of your quries will be solved if you can refer to xxSection..] If that is possible why we should take ca club experts help we also have interenet and we can go for search and refer to that section in income tax act/companies act

Small accountants like me will expects Suggestions from learned experts (their Opinion with Supporting with Section no./circularno.)My kind request to all experts please provide quality service

4)Points race--Caclub India Should reduce the points Allotted to Expert replies (presently 3 points fir expert section reply Should reduced to 1 point

5)ca club India Should make a review in Expert Section and those who are not doing well should be suspended for some time to reply in expert section..(to safe gaurd the quality of website)

Otherwise Caclub India will Shortly Become lawers Club India where "Agree with experts are more than expert opinion"

I have left that site of course But Kindly maintain the quality in Expert replies..

Note: This is not to criticize experts who helped small Accountants like me with your valuable replies,, i just want to let you people know what are the demirits and what are the points to be noted to make our cacluub as best website ever

Kindly follow ca club Rules or Contribute for Dissatisfaction of users of caclub

Replies (4)

rajesh

article

47 Points Joined May 2013

We also Should Avoid Posting Multiple images and high resolution graphic images in Forum Section

I Noticed that Users were Appreciating More to these animated images/quotes and other unrelated stuff

I am not Telling it is useless stuff But there should be some limit on posting humor posts No one interested to post a reply under thread which was started by Some other member,,every member will open a thread and will post their images which was taken from interenet and simply posting to caclub

Gaining points is not an important task it is matter of quality that you have served to Caclub India..

Hope Admin will control such posts( say one thread can be opened every day for humor posts and all humor posts should added to that thread only and should make an arrangement in a way not to open a new thread for less important stuff)

other wise it will become habit to members to take thanks from others by posting some beatiful quotes and images from interenet

Caclub India is the Indias biggest and best forum for Accounting and fiinance professionsals one should Note that

RENU SINGH

✩ §m!ℓ!ñġ €ม€§ fℓม!ñġ ђ♪gђ✩

21627 Points Joined March 2011

I'd surely won't dislike your post.

Ganeshbabu K

Audit and Tax Advisory

48564 Points Joined May 2012

Nice report on CCI, ofcourse i cant say as you said,,because CCI is a website having member strength more than 10 lakhs members dear rajesh dont expect all members will be in same wavelength,

.CCI is the only website where you can see best answer and more views from more members...

you should gain what you can and share what you can...

But i can say it is very much important to maintain quality in experts section,other wise cci may become one of lawyers club inda where "agree with experts "will be more than those who reply.

Every expert should count how many times they have replied with a single line "agree with above expert"...maintain in a way it should not exceed 10 ,,,

I promise i never use this tags

CMA. CS. Sanjay Gupta

"PROUD TO BE AN INDIAN"

114245 Points Joined February 2009

Agree. Replies in expert section need to be analysed. Since quality of replies should be focus not the quantity. Replies which do not add any value (e.g. wrong reply, Agree, Welcome, and other irrelevant conversation) should not be counted. Many other measures need to be taken to improve the effectiveness of expert section.

Above all experts themself needs to realize the quality should not be compromised for quantity. Open queries need to be taken care off rather then already resolved queries unless the expert want to add something relevant to that query or he/she has a different opinion.