Go AD-Free with CAclubindia Pro and get a FREE CCI Coffee Mug. Subscribe Now!

Change in marks

Jay Maru (finance) (47 Points)

06 August 2013

ICAI never revises marks on verification. They play with students emotions.They are fooling us.

Is there anyone who has experienced change in past three years???

Reply
Follow
Share

23 Replies

CA SANJAY TALWAR (Job) (222 Points)
Replied 06 August 2013

SIR,

TODAY I GOT VERIFICATION RESULT ... NO CHANGE

No Discrepancy in the marks

:-(

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Venu Madhav (Student) (30 Points)
Replied 06 August 2013

Can you please post a screenshort of the page...

Even I am awaiting my verification results.....

Also when did you apply for verification?

AKSHAY GOEL (NOT YET) (27 Points)
Replied 06 August 2013

sanjay on which date u aplied fr verification online ????

Punit Govil (CA FINAL(1st grp passed) CS FINAL M.COM) (228 Points)
Replied 06 August 2013

@ Mr. Jay...are u new one on the internet???? dnt u use the net continously??? 2 or 3 attempt before, ICAI used to update the all d names of the students whose marks were changed during verification process....dnt u seen?? there r many students who got their marks changed...even my friend became CA after verification in Nov 2010.....last time in Nov 12 one student updated on this portal that he has got change in the marks...dnt u seen ?? hw can u blame by observing some cases or without asking from any responsible person???

pavel (student) (465 Points)
Replied 06 August 2013

hey punit cool yrr...it is not necessary dat the thing u know others also know abt it....understnd the expression on others yrr...jay has said wad he felt abt it and even i had also given my papers for revaluation bt the same marks has been pasted...any person on his place can be angered and also once in a blue moon day it happend ki markes are changed..

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Punit Govil (CA FINAL(1st grp passed) CS FINAL M.COM) (228 Points)
Replied 06 August 2013

@ Pavel... u r right pavel ...in articleship u me nd everybody faced worst situations also on audit work....many type of people we faced...nw at this stage we (as we claim that we r auditors) should not use the language which MAY not be good untill we have searched out everything with proof....m i wrong??? the sentence used by Mr Jay is...ICAI never revises marks on verification. They play with students emotions.They are fooling us. Is there anyone who has experienced change in past three years???

u jst read once again it...he is saying 3 YEARS means at least Nov 2010 to till date...okey...now u tell me plz that ...when ICAI continuously updated total list who got their marks changed on its website without any password till nov. 2011, then hw mr. Jay is claiming loke this???? ...game , folish etc etc etc...it means he has not searched out any thing and never tried to ask from the very seniors or most concerned persons...

CA SANJAY TALWAR (Job) (222 Points)
Replied 07 August 2013

@ Akshay : on 18th July morning

Jay Maru (finance) (47 Points)
Replied 07 August 2013

@ Punit : oh boss there might be only few handfull of cases of change in marks...that too out of mere pressure bcoz they receive more than 45k applications for verification charging rs.100 only for retotalling & if they dont revise marks of few students they wont be able to make such quick bucks in future ...

I dont need your permision to voice my opinion .... dont behave lyk a icai hired puppet...and who r u to question my integrity...

TARUN MATHUR (Articled Assistant) (71 Points)
Replied 07 August 2013

Nowadays Institute is hiring Seperate Valuers for Total Checking and verification etc. So going for re totalling or verification is a waste of time. Start your preparations the next day you receive your result

Punit Govil (CA FINAL(1st grp passed) CS FINAL M.COM) (228 Points)
Replied 07 August 2013

bs yahi to fark he ...aap hamesha absurd language use krte hein...kal tak toh icai krti hi nahi thi aapke hisab se...aaj aap bhi few cases pr aagaye..hahaha...i m not hired...bt i know many things coz i searched out( aapki tarah sirf voice ni uthai)......u know why there r rare cases of positive reverification??? i tell u...MR. TARUN MATHUR is absolutely right....they have hired many CA only for retotalling who perform their duty immediately after checking of ur copy even before the valuer depatches copy to back to ICAI...it was started 2 or 3 attempts before when there were no. of cases of mistakes on the part of ICAI...when such a major steps have been taken by them den it is obvious that the cases like this will be fewer now....aaapke awaz uthane se kya hoga??...agar itna hi gussa he to apni copy inspection ko kyun nahi mangavate aap??? pata chal jayega....u jst call for ur copy, i m 100% sure ki ICAI ne aapke 2-4 no. increase krk hi diye honge...... apko pata he me aisa kyun keh raha hun??? coz mene karib 50 cases dekhe copy inspection k or aapko jankr khushi hogi ki un 50 ki 50 copies me no. increase krk diye gaye the jo aapke results me the...apko pata kya he abhi? chale hein absurd language krne...client k sath bhi aise hi bolte the kya articleship me....or han awaz tb uthayein jb proof ho aapke pass....jb aap process se vakif hein nahi ...puchte kisi se hein nahi..toh aapna gussa yahan kyun uttar rahe hein...???..mind ur language..

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Punit Govil (CA FINAL(1st grp passed) CS FINAL M.COM) (228 Points)
Replied 07 August 2013

me chahun to abhi aapke satisfaction k liye even apni copy yahan upload kr sakta hun...bt its illegal to upload....even i got my marks increased in my results...accounts me copy me 40 the bt result me 53....samjhe kuch aap...aaap bhi manva hi lo...voice apne aap niche aajayegi...have a nice day..