CONVERSION OF PROPRIETORY CONCERN IN TO PARTNERSHIP FIRM-WHETHER CAPITAL GAIN WILL APPLY?
CONVERSION OF PROPRIETORY CONCERN IN TO PARTNERSHIP FIRM
Laxmi Mittal (Practice) (188 Points)
28 October 2009Laxmi Mittal (Practice) (188 Points)
28 October 2009CONVERSION OF PROPRIETORY CONCERN IN TO PARTNERSHIP FIRM-WHETHER CAPITAL GAIN WILL APPLY?
Sunil
(Trader)
(2611 Points)
Replied 29 October 2009
The non-applicability of CG is only if prop concern converted into Pvt. Ltd. Company.That too entire asset and liability of proprietor should become that of pvt. ltd.co. Proprietor should hold 51% shares for 5 years. refer to Section 47. You cannot detach only the immovable property. All balance sheet liabilities and assets (stocks etc) creditors and debtors are to be assumed by new company as on date. It has to be transferred as a going concern and 51% shares has to remain for 5 years with the proprietor. If it is diluted below this in the interim say after 3 to 4 years, the liability of CG tax is of the company as company is in possession of all properties. When you read section 45 it is clearly stated partnership firm or AOP not being a company. However, section 47 specifies company. Therefore it will have to be Pvt. Ltd. Co.
The new company has to make its MOA with the main objective being of the business what proprietorship concern does and it has to be then doing the business like manufacturing etc. Later one can make ammendments to do other businesses as well.
The ITO under whose jurisdiction proprietor was filing returns, upon transfer taking place, will not accept the individual returns of the proprietor. That has to be filed at same ITO of the Pvt. Ltd. Company. Usually, there is a notice as such put up at ITOs where individual file the return that they should file in charge of private limited company if they are director there. The ITO usually scrutinises both returns as he has to satisfy himself of continuity of concern as company and also no other enrichment to proprietor arising from the transfer. If the proprietor has taken loan from any of the other director or their family members, that is viewed adversely. They disallow this on grounds of advance money being paid for transfer of shares at a later date. Now from 1/10/2009 all this is also affected.
Raman Singla
(Accounts Services)
(167 Points)
Replied 26 January 2021
During Conversion of Proprietorship to Partnership firm... with assets and liability except which are doubtful to the new partnership firm(to the new partner) belongs to proprietorship.....What will be treatment of those Unsecured Loan and Sundry Creditors in the balance sheet of Proprietorship ???