Come and join to help our freinds

Originally posted by : kavitha
	Lots of non- professionals are posting their queries in our forum and in search of points we are simply answering their question without thinking the consequences. "

Madam, do you mean that non-professionals without CA degree do not have any worth. Please note that apart from Degree, knowledge gained from work experience also counts. 

I you are so much worried about your CA community; just request the CA admin to register only those who have CA membership number. Then the so called non-professional will not get registered themself, nor can post their query or view the "Expert Comments" of CA's.

Sharing your knowledge with those who need, will not reduce you knowledge you will only gain. If your teachers think just like you, then I don't think there will be many CA's passing out.

Try to think boardly and if possible help other. God Bless you.

Anandan

Hey Kavitha!!

First of all thanks to you 4 taking initiative, kudos to you.

Your doubt is that we are facing recession & many people clearing CA is not getting enough job.

My view is that by not giving answers on question asked in this forum will not generate additional avenues for CA.

I have seen many questions are asked by CA's too. So shall we take it other way that they have this stupid knowledge!

Answer is NO, because our area of span is so vast that CA practicing in finance may not be having knowledge of Labour Welfare Fund or he might not have heard about so. So we can not be judgemental on the basis of question asked.

Yes job crunch is big problem in front of CA, however there is many vacancies in Big & small cities compared to town & i have seldom head CA moving out for job from their native place.

Even if question is asked here by non CA, i am sure that his lineal boss will be definitely CA. He/she must be working under CA at junior post & for getting clarification only question is posted.

Moreover by answering question our knowledging is growing & getting sharpened!!

Of total population of more than 100 crore only 500 to 600 people appears online. So by noway this forum is keeping any CA jobless, however they will agree that they have gained knowledge.

Other people may have different views.

Anandan Sir,

Just get concentrate what i am emphasising. no disgrace meant

may be in that way we may increase a small oppurtunity to who cleared ca or semi qualified. we all know how much trauma we go through in studying, doing articleship( some may enjoy like me) and after finsihing CA if u dont find a job, then what ??

no disgrace meant. just dont deviate from my concern. everybody has their own views, i respect that. people are always broad minded

Thanks for Your views @ VaibhavJ Anandan

Dear kavitha........ I m not agree wid ur First & Second suggestion...........

As we should help others selflessly.................  Either in any form...........

thrugh dis platform we r helping others in solving dere queries ................

"JITNA GYAN BATOGE ,UTNA GYAN BADHEGA"

& i m also agree wid  Vaibhav ji  ..............

non professional means anyone who dont have any knowledge of accounts or whatever!!!

i didnot convey my message clearly i think. anyway as it my first post , i'll work on my presentation skills.

I am not selfish, not narrow minded and i dont have any issues with anyone.

first of all  thanks to Kavitha mam for posting this topic... & ur concern to help CA friends...

But to do a successful venture we should not adopt negative approach, in the sense that  We CCI members whether professional or non-professional share our knowledge in this platfform called Caclubindia only for mutual benefits...just helping each other

i truly agree with vibrant reply of Vaibhav ji

Dhanya Sreedhar

positive mindset feedback atlast!!! Not blaming anyone, i like that. you just put right words at right place except NO in one palce. Thank You