Hi All,
i want to ask this question to all CA's, CS's and CWA's professinals and students
which is the best option doing CA or CS comparing all terms??????
13 Replies
NITISH
(Employee & Student)
(242 Points)
Replied 28 September 2010
In ranking Terms :
1. CA
2. CS
3. CWA
Ashish M
(Chartered Accountant)
(2731 Points)
Replied 28 September 2010
All depends upon r ablity and interest.
In C.A., u wud be touching upon almost all areas CS adn CWA are touching upon...
CS mainly concerned with company and other laws.... so there u will be doing more of theory like laws and less practicle..
in CWA, it is mix of theory adn practicle.. practicle in the form of cost accounts....
As for job prospects, CA/CS/CWA stands in this order .....
Pardeep
(Audit Executive)
(51 Points)
Replied 01 October 2010
CS and CWA r best courses
but CA is better
becoz
CA COURSE IS BETTER THAN THE BEST
CMA. PRAVEEN V CA FINAL
(cost accountant)
(1402 Points)
Replied 02 October 2010
AS COMPARED TO ALL TERMS, FIRST PREFERENCE IS CA.... IT IS BEST IF YOU GO FOR CA... IN CASE OF TIME FACTOR CS WOULD BE THE BEST.... GO FOR EITHER CA OR CS.ALL THE BEST ....
Abhinav Prabhudan
(Student)
(88 Points)
Replied 06 October 2010
in order taking all the aspects - CA > CWA > CS.
but if taking interest as the only aspect than CA = CWA = CS. coz if u don't like accounts n audit then u can never become a good CA or if u don't like laws then u can't become a good CS.
CA is not father of all other courses. all three courses r like brother to each other. CAs r ahead only coz they hv more statutory powers which gives them an edge in practicing. but tht does not make it a father of other courses.
mukul mehra
(B.com MBA-HR ADLL CS-Final LLb TCP)
(591 Points)
Replied 06 October 2010
i disagree with people who are saying CA is best or CS is best either of the courses have their own importance otherwise govt would not have create such two bodies. they both have their importance in their relevant fields its ur choice of interest what u choose so go ahead choose ur path best of luck
(Guest)
If U complete CA that equals both knowledge of CS And CWA.
In a word CA = CS + CWA.
if u see, CA covers all papers which are in both CS & CWA. if u consider CS there are only papers regarding mainly Law and if u consider CWA there are papers regaring mainly COST accountancy.
But it is not the case of CA it covers all fields.......
Abhinav Prabhudan
(Student)
(88 Points)
Replied 07 October 2010
@ above
have u ever seen syllabus of CWA or CS??? i doubt not at all.. coz if u hd then u can never say things like this tht CA = CWA + CS.. in which world r u living??? just come out of this illusion. only having 1 paper of cost tht too of 50% at inter n tht only 1 paper at final level does not make CA cover all papers of CWA.. phir toh CWA also has 1 paper of financial accounts at inter n tht is of 100 marks n 1 paper of advanced financial accounts at final..
n regarding CS.. phir wahi baat.. sirf ek law ka paper at inter n then 1 law ka paper at final does not cover the entire course of CS.. really i can't believe one can say lame things like this n tht too a professional student of CA.. CS is just more than wht u think of it..
CA students always lives in this illusion.. not ur fault at all.. ICAI added these papers to create this illusion n it really worked for ICAI.. n CAs r ahead only coz of the more statutory powers they enjoy.. just make cost audit mandatory n then see who is ahead of who..
neways i always respected all the 3 courses coz i know the importance of all the 3.. but i can never tolerate posts like this.. just grow up n see the real world
SHAIKH MOHAMED MUSHTAQUE MOOSA
(SR OFFICER ACCOUNTS)
(21 Points)
Replied 18 July 2012
I COMPLETELY AGREE WITH MR.ABHINAV COMMENTS...........I DONT KNOW WHAT CAs STUDENT THINKING ABOUT OTHER COURSE I.E. CS / CWA....ITS NOT THER MISTAKE BECOZ THEY DOSNT KNOW ABOUT THE SYLLABUS OF CS & CWA ...............ALL ARE EQUALLY IMPORTANCE COURSE ..........GO FOR ANY COURSE U WILL GET GOOD OPPORTUNITIES IN FUTURE..........
LAST BUT NOT LEAST INSTITUTE OF CS/CWA/CA IS A STATUTORY BODY UNDER THE ACT OF PARLIMENT.....IT MEANS EACH INSTITUTE HAVING SOME QUALITY AND DEFINITLY THATS THE REASON TO ESTABLISH ALL.
IF CA= CS+CWA MY COMMENTS IS ------------ CA IS THE FIRST INSTITUTE ...SO WHY THER IS NEED TO OPEN CS INSTITUTE THEN AFTER CWA.......... IT SIMPLY MEANS CAs ARE NOT CAPABLE TO HANDLE SOMETHING... THEN GOVERNMENT REALISE TO ESTABLISH CS & CWA INSTITUTE...........
MY FREINDS ALL 3 ARE EQUALLY IMP PROFESSIONAL COURSE....THEY ARE EXPERT IN ACCOUNT/FINANCE/LAW AREAS... SEE THE SYLLABUS OF CS CWA..............OK
SHAIKH MOHD MUSHTAQUE
Rechtsan
({ffft)
(383 Points)
Replied 19 July 2012
Do something in which you would be best and not a course which everyone considers it to be best.
ALL THE BEST.! !
Renu Renu
(job)
(4 Points)
Replied 01 March 2016
CS have highest designation in a company direct at board room than a Account manager. many experience CS earn 30-40 lakh per annum. CA course just have old goodwill for making new student idiot. which far away from achul situation of mostly CA. mostly CA struggle for good salary even job. and practice need long wait for fruit. ( few exception available). if a small village boy become IAS then every one thing we can also be like him but that is not realistic for every one in reality
Recent Topics
- Political party donation under 80 GGC
- Self assessment tax paid during scrunity 143(2)
- Need inputs for my MBA Project (Accountant tools)
- GTA UNREGISTERED DEALERS
- GST ON IMPORT OF LEGAL SERIVCES
- JOB WORK OR SUPPLY OF GOODS
- Need ITAT appeal drafting services
- Section 10(14) exemptions
- UPI Transaction May Stop If Your App Does Not Foll
- ACCOUNTING ENTRY UNDER GST SECTION 17(5)(H)
Related Threads
Trending Online Classes
-
25 Hours GST Scrutiny of Return and Notice Handling(With Recording)
Industry Expert04 February 2025
CAclubindia
