Go Ad-Free on CAclubindia with Daily Mobile Updates. Subscribe Now!

CA Final old syllabus Paper 7DT Book by Bangar

CA CS Surbhi Sharma (Professional) (233 Points)

07 December 2017

Dear Sir
I shortlisted these book for DT paper May 201i exam, kindly help me

For self study
1.TN Manoharan Book - Snowhite Publication
2. Bangar Book compreshensive
3. Durgesh Singh - Bharat Publication

How is Bangar compiler instead of ICAI PM (ICAI not likely to issue PM for May 2018 DT exam)

How is compact book by Bhanwar Borana along with his compiler?

Provide your valuable suggestion

Reply
Follow
Share

8 Replies

Kapil Kumar Singh Adv (Student) (572 Points)
Replied 07 December 2017

Hello Surbhi,

In my opinion for DT please choose any one of the following books --

Vinod Gupta Sir's Notes OR

Bhanvar Borana 's Comapct .

AND most essential keep Income Tax Bare Act along with you.

Because studying law without Bare Act is Not Good Practice .

My personal choice would be VG Sir's Booklets because i am also studying from them.

Thanks

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Fan of Nm (411 Points)
Replied 11 December 2017

VG Summary book is best. Then Bhanvar Borana's Compact. You can go with TN as well.

Practice from PM. Because it boost your confidence. Doesn't matter what you read Q's from. Go for PM for topics that haven't amended. Most likely New PM will come in January last or Feb first week.

But
Durgesh is flop. Bangar for DT is not recommended by most (Though it is similar to IDT ).

Fan of Nm (411 Points)
Replied 11 December 2017

Whatever you read from make sure you revise on the last day of exam.

Because it doesn't matter which book you read from, If last day you couldn't complete IMP topics.
P

CA CS Surbhi Sharma (Professional) (233 Points)
Replied 11 December 2017

Thank you very much
VG Summary omits cerain small topics, BB also omits cerain provision but it is good during exam time and revision. TN Manoharan main book is best but vast i.e. around 1200 pages. Durgesh sir capsule book, i have heard but it was his 2nd edition for Nov 2017. Bangar i was considering as it iscaround 800 pages and covers as per icai contents in smooth manner like his IDT book

1 Like

Amol (Accounting) (434 Points)
Replied 12 December 2017

For DT comprehensive book, how about

1. Ahuja Gupta

2.Mehul Thakker

3. Ravi Chhawachharia

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA CS Surbhi Sharma (Professional) (233 Points)
Replied 12 December 2017

Priority
1. Bangar Book for smooth study and learning
2. TN Manoharan as it is more student oriented
3. Ahuja and gupta by bharat publication
these books cover syllabus as per icai i mean at least 90%.
along with BB compact
other books regular edition not available and not stable.

Karan Batra (42 Points)
Replied 23 December 2017

Currently only two new books are available and i think bangar is much better option now it has been updated .

Bangar new edition : https://www.lionkart.com/p/direct-tax-law-and-practice-by-dr.-yogendra-bangar-dr.-vandana-bangar/

Durgesh Singh - Bharat Publication New edition : https://www.lionkart.com/p/capsule-studies-on-direct-tax-laws--old-and-new-syllabus--by-ca-durgesh-singh/

Thanks

Best of luck