CA Tushar Lakhanpal (CA) (416 Points)
Replied 13 February 2010

i also want to know bout the refrence books to be used for finals new course ??

and upto what extent we can depend on modules??

CA. Ravinder kumar (PROFESSIONAL) (67 Points)
Replied 13 February 2010

Hiiii Friends

First of all i want to say that please don,t leave the module fully. because some concept who include in module, sometimes not include in refrence books.only see concept in module but study or understand from refrence books. best refrence books given below used by my side.

Audit : V.K. Agrawal & (for quick study - kamal garg)

Law : Munish Bhandari (for Complete reading : Main Book & for summary : Hand Book)

MICS : Dinesh Madan & ICAI Module

DT : Paduka (Best coz u can understand easily by urself without ny classes)

IDT : Banger (u'll get everything watever comes in exams but not creates pictorial view in mind)

A/c n MAFA : must solve all ques of Compiler (u'll get even same ques in exam)

Law, MICS, n DT u can do by urself... n also some chapters of A/c & MAFA.

u must read atleast 1AS nd 1SA daily...

if u need ny help den u can contact me...

All the best

Ravinder Kumar

2 Like

koolleo87 (1268 Points)
Replied 13 February 2010

ONly tax module is stupid. Rest all are very very decent....

CA. Ravinder kumar (PROFESSIONAL) (67 Points)
Replied 13 February 2010

hii Friend

of Course U r Right

But Don't Leave Only see the all Provisions or Concept Given by Institute.

Because Exams are also Prepared by Institute.

Ok dear

Regards

Ravinder Kumar

CA SURENDRA KUMAR RAKHECHA (Practising CA at Surat) (26263 Points)
Replied 13 February 2010

(humour)

PREVIOUSLY AUDITOR WAS KNOWN AS 'WATCH DOG'

Mr. Hariharan, still you agree with this ?

Observing a photo of "WATCH DOG'" with your profile I have presumed this.

CA SURENDRA KUMAR RAKHECHA (Practising CA at Surat) (26263 Points)
Replied 13 February 2010

Mr. Hariharan,

I am really impressed with your presentation i.e. the way you have raised the issue of books or modules - for examination purpose.

The disucssion about the modules and books is very relevant.

Discussion should go on.....

(Guest)

Plz discuss more on this topic...and let everyone know the fact..

Anurag (service) (378 Points)
Replied 13 February 2010

hi i thank u all for ur prompt response on the above mentioned topic.

i think the discussion must go on since squarely blaming module is not the way out.

yes there are certain modules which r useless ,e.g tax module due to assessment year problems.

but i think other modules r good.i dont think people call module the bible just for no reason.

also responses by professionals like ca surendra kumar are heartening to see as even professionals can help out the younger student community

also thank mr.ravindra kumar for his valuable inputs.

this is the speciality of this site when misconceptions r cleared and students and professionals both interact and make this course a really enjoyable one.

thank u guys keep sharing

may god bless all

Sumit (CA-Final) (78 Points)
Replied 13 February 2010

How is V.K.Singhania's Book for Direct Taxes???

I prepared PCC from it and think that it's the ultimate practice material. . .

Plz give ur views & suggestions!!!

CA SURENDRA KUMAR RAKHECHA (Practising CA at Surat) (26263 Points)
Replied 14 February 2010

Originally posted by : hariharan

HI FRIENDS
I HAVE READ MANY THREADS ON THIS SITE COMPLAINING THAT THE MODULE ISSUED BY ICAI FOR FINAL (N) COURSE IS NOT UPTO THE MARK.WHAT DO ALL MY FRIENDS HERE MEAN BY NOT UPTO THE MARK??
SINCE I BOUGHT MY MODULE YESTERDAY ITSELF AND HAVE NOT JOINED ANY COACHING TILL DATE PL TELL AS TO FOR WHICH SUBJECTS THE MODULES R NOT GOOD?
I JUST GLANCED THROUGH SOME OF THE MODULES AND FOUND OUT THAT CORPORATE LAWS MODULE,COSTING MODULE,MICS MODULE AND ACCOUNTS MODULE R QUIET GOOD AND SUFFICENT.
THE PROBLEM LIES WITH TAXES MODULE AND FM MODULE WHICH MAY NOT BE RELEVANT.
PL SUGGEST WHY THE MODULE SHOULD BE COMPLETELY AVOIDED AND IF NOT THEN WHICH MODULES R GOOD ENOUGH SO THAT REFERENCE BOOKS MAY NOT BE PURCHASED SINCE ICAI DRAFTS MODULE FOR ALL STUDENTS I.E EVEN FOR STUDENTS WHO RESIDE IN RURAL AREAS WHERE REFERENCE BOOKS MAY NOT BE AVAILABLE THAT EASILY.
IN THE LATEST RESULTS PUBLISEHD BY ICAI FOR FINAL AND PCC, STUDENTS FROM RURAL AND SEMI-RURAL AREAS HAVE DONE EXCEEDINGLY WELL AS COMPARED TO STUDENTS FROM CITIES LIKE BOMBAY,DELHI,CACLUTTA AND MADRAS.
AND I AM SURE THAT THESE PEOPLE MUST HAVE SURELY REFERRED THE MODULE.
KINDLY HELP OUT REGARDING THIS AND SUGGEST GOOD BOOKS FOR FINAL CA NEW COURSE WHEREVER REQUIRED
REGARDS

Mr. Hariharan you are right to say that Institute's moduels are good one but majority of students have misconcpetion that 1. without coaching it is not possible to qualify 2. institute's modules are useless 3. short-cut method should be adopted to qualify 4. by using certain notes only; exam can be passed.

Most of the students are NOT READY to study in depth because of time constraint.

But, to get success; you have to plan your studies from day one.

From caclubsite; I have seen only you who has raised very good topic immediately after receiving Modules.

I discussed this matter in length but majority of students are not READY TO ACCEPT THAT MODULES ARE GOOD......... although I WROTE WITH EVIDENCE OF ONE STUDENT WHO GOT 3RD RANK IN CA FINAL IN MAY,09 WITH THE HELP OF MODULES AND COMPILATION and he was my articled clerk.

FOR DT AND IDT; definitely you have to refer books because these subjects require updation in line with the latest cast laws.

2 Like

CA SURENDRA KUMAR RAKHECHA (Practising CA at Surat) (26263 Points)
Replied 14 February 2010

From my previous post; it should be presumed that you need not require reference books. You should have at least one reference book of each subject but base should be Modules.

Further; if you read regularly the Institute's journal and other relevant materials either from newspapers or magazines; then it will help you to form your own judgment about the subject because it is necessary to qualify CA that you are in a position to say something about the subject in your own language.

CAs are required to REPORT ON THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS.

So on the subject; what is your opinion; if it is clear; than it is EASY TO PASS CA. It means not only you should cover the subject but your concepts should also be clear e.g. when you read Law subject; your focus should also be there on REASONING why there are such provisions in the law.

Otherwise all the students do labour; but no wages are paid by the Institute !

1 Like

CA SURENDRA KUMAR RAKHECHA (Practising CA at Surat) (26263 Points)
Replied 14 February 2010

I have written some articles and discussion on CA PROFESSION.

The link of which is as under :

/forum/bird-eye-view-of-ca-final-result-dont-miss-it-64199.asp?offset=13

/articles/one-shot-success-in-ca-4051.asp

/articles/second-shot-success-in-ca-4172.asp

/articles/six-months-in-waste-now-invest--4490.asp

Anurag (service) (378 Points)
Replied 14 February 2010

hello ca surendra sir,

once again thank u for appreciating me.it is nice to know that u insist on module and self study.whenever i think of my parents having to pay 50000 odd rupees to join coaching i feel disheartened and think have i made a mistake to join this course especially at a time when my and many of my firend's parents over here who think about retirement have to think of paying such a heafty fee and that too without any clear assurance of clearing the exams.

thank u very very much sir and again i must compliment that u took some time out of ur busy schedule to comment on this.

hopefully i may clear may 2011 fianl attempt after taking tips which have been forwared by u and also ur articled clerk's example is heartening

thanks sir

1 Like

CA SURENDRA KUMAR RAKHECHA (Practising CA at Surat) (26263 Points)
Replied 14 February 2010

It's OK.

But don't forget to update yourself from latest available materials.

The sources are :

1. ICAI Journal (must read without fail : for whole of the life )!

2. caclubindia

3. group-discussion about the subjects

4. Institute's site

(If you don't join coaching; start your studies immediately and mark typical points to discuss with your friends specially who undertake coaching. In this way; you can get your querries solved).

Wish you all the success in your life.

1 Like

CA FINAL NEW COURSE MODULE

21 Replies

Online classes for CA CS CMA. Professional courses for GST, Tally, Others & Books

Mr. Hariharan,

I am really impressed with your presentation i.e. the way you have raised the issue of books or modules - for examination purpose.

The disucssion about the modules and books is very relevant.

Discussion should go on.....

Plz discuss more on this topic...and let everyone know the fact..

Most of the students are NOT READY to study in depth because of time constraint.

But, to get success; you have to plan your studies from day one.

From caclubsite; I have seen only you who has raised very good topic immediately after receiving Modules.

I discussed this matter in length but majority of students are not READY TO ACCEPT THAT MODULES ARE GOOD......... although I WROTE WITH EVIDENCE OF ONE STUDENT WHO GOT 3RD RANK IN CA FINAL IN MAY,09 WITH THE HELP OF MODULES AND COMPILATION and he was my articled clerk.

FOR DT AND IDT; definitely you have to refer books because these subjects require updation in line with the latest cast laws.

From my previous post; it should be presumed that you need not require reference books. You should have at least one reference book of each subject but base should be Modules.

CAs are required to REPORT ON THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS.

So on the subject; what is your opinion; if it is clear; than it is EASY TO PASS CA. It means not only you should cover the subject but your concepts should also be clear e.g. when you read Law subject; your focus should also be there on REASONING why there are such provisions in the law.

Otherwise all the students do labour; but no wages are paid by the Institute !

I have written some articles and discussion on CA PROFESSION.

The link of which is as under :

It's OK.

But don't forget to update yourself from latest available materials.

The sources are :

1. ICAI Journal (must read without fail : for whole of the life )!

2. caclubindia

3. group-discussion about the subjects

4. Institute's site

Wish you all the success in your life.

Leave a reply

Recent Topics

Related Threads

Popular Discussion

Trending Online Classes

Subscribe to the latest topics :

Search Forum: