BOTH THE QUESTIONS FROM WINDING UP WERE OUT OF SYLLABUS.AS INSTITUTE DECLARED THAT ONLY 9.4 FROM YHE INSTITUTE MAT IS IN SYLLABUS>EVERYBODY SHOULD START SENDING MAILS TO PRESIDENT AND BOARD OF STUDIES.PLEASE
9 Replies
CA Ravi Khandelwal
(Business)
(752 Points)
Replied 19 May 2011
Yes, Mrinal is right. 16 marks paper was out of syllabus. Both the questions were not from paragraph 9.4.
CA Ravi Khandelwal
(Business)
(752 Points)
Replied 19 May 2011
Send mail to director of Board of Studies at vijaykapur @ icai.org
or file this matter with e-sahayta
MRINAL DAXINI
(CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT)
(128 Points)
Replied 19 May 2011
MERA REQUEST HAIN AP LOG SABH MATTER KO POST KARE AUR BATE KAM KARE AUR INSTITUTE KO MAIL AND PHONE ZYADA KARE.
rachit jain
(chartered accountant )
(635 Points)
Replied 19 May 2011
hey but as per icai notification dated 22-2-2011 there were no deletion from the corp and allied law syllabus. plz go through this link
MaNThaN Shah
(Student)
(315 Points)
Replied 19 May 2011
In costing paper also theory of benchmarking is not in new syllabus. . Check out new study material, nowhere it is gvn .institute askd frm old syllabus.
Dhaval Desai
(7/152 Swaminityanand Society Near Andheri station Andheri(E))
(92 Points)
Replied 22 May 2011
Frnds i have received the correspondense from the icai that they will take adequate measures for this mistake.
I m attaching both my request to icai & ther final reply for ur assurance.
THIS IS MY EMAIL WHICH I SENT THEM---------------------
Respected Sir/Madam,
As per the notice/announcement issued by the Board of Studies(ICAI) for NOV 2010 & MAY 2011 exams following were the provisions applicable for Winding up(Chapter no.9 of study material)
[EXTRACT OF THE ANNOUNCEMENT]
Applicability of relevant Amendments/Circulars/Notifications/Regulations etc. relating to Corporate and Allied Laws for May 2011, Examination:
Companies [relating to Winding Up]
[Students have been advised to study only the general provisions of winding up as covered under Paragraph 9.4 of chapter 9 of the study material]
If we refer the ICAI study material for law regarding chapter no.9 (para 9.4)----then only general provisions are applicable i.e section 528 to 560. BUT THE QUESTIONS WHICH APPEARED IN MAY 2011 LAW PAPERS WERE BASED ON FOLLOWING PROVISIONS
QUESTION NO.2(b)--- IT WAS BASED ON SECTION 428 (CONTRIBUTORIES)-------8 MARKS
QUESTION NO.6(a)--- IT WAS BASED ON SECTION 433(e),434 & 439(5)---------------8 MARKS
SO I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW IN SUCH SITUATION WHAT WILL THE STEPS Board of Studies(ICAI) WUD TAKE?? SO THAT STUDENTS ARE NOT KEPT AT A DISADVANTAGEOUS POSITION.
HOPE TO GET SOME POSITIVE RESPONSE.
This mail is sent in the interest of all the CA Final students appeared in May 2011 exams.
Thanks & regards
DHAVAL DESAI (WRO 0257467)
REPLY FROM ICAI
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: megha
Date: Wed, May 18, 2011 at 3:07 PM
Subject: RE: Inapplicable provisions of winding up asked for 16 marks in CA Final(Law paper) May 2011 exams.
To: Dhaval Desai
Dear student,
We have already taken note of this matter and necessary due diligence will be followed during evaluation process.
Regards,
CS. Megha Goel,
Board of Studies,
ICAI.
AS WE DONT GET PAPERS TO CHECK BUT HOPE FOR THE BEST.
DHAVAL DESAI
SBA MOHAMMED AZHARUDEEN
(Traineee - Finance)
(23 Points)
Replied 24 May 2011
Hi frndz.. from my point of view, nothing is out of syllabus.. contributory is what we learnt in PCC Accounts and Bench marking is what we learnt in PCC Strategic Management... so they are expecting CA final students to remember all those things we learnt earlier..
Recent Topics
- Misplace society Bye law
- Submit ommited invoice of previous year
- Need your valueble insight
- GSTR-9 Invoices
- Agricultural Business Loss
- Reporting in gstr9 of ITC of Previous year reverse
- Tax on Reimbursement of House Rent
- MAHARASHTRA CHARITY COMMISSIONER WEBSITE
- Explanation 3 to section 11(1) read with section 4
- Ammendment in Partnership On Death of Partner and
Related Threads
CAclubindia
