Moyyad Zapawala (Chartered Accountant) (425 Points)
23 November 2011Hello Friends please suggest me which is good book for Audit in CA final. Suggest those books from which I can study SA and other topics in one book. I have Vinod Kumar Agrawal's book but, it is short.
Please friends guid me I am going to appear in May 2012 exams
Thanks & Regards
Karan Gupta
(CA FINAL STUDENT)
(414 Points)
Replied 23 November 2011
SURBHI BANSAL MADAM BOOK OR PADHUKA PUBLICATION
CA Ayush Agarwal
(Kolkata-Pune-Mumbai)
(27186 Points)
Replied 23 November 2011
For SA - VK Agrawal
Rest - Surbh Bansal
CA Hemang Shah
(PRACTICE)
(658 Points)
Replied 23 November 2011
chirag
(CA Final)
(320 Points)
Replied 24 November 2011
Hi Hemang ,
I was copy of Dr.Urvish Shah Audit Book for CA Final , My attempt is in may 2012. Give me your contact no, I am at Anand, Gujarat I will collect it if you are at ahmedabad.
Ankur
(CA Final Student)
(999 Points)
Replied 24 November 2011
Rajasekaran.K
(articled Company secretary)
(173 Points)
Replied 24 November 2011
It is better to go for Surbhi Bhansal's book....Sharp, to the point, precise and covers the entire syllabus !!!!
rahul ramesh pawar
(CA Final Student)
(103 Points)
Replied 24 November 2011
FOR LAW only refer to AMIT KARIA's CORPORATE & ALLIED LAWS by Bharat Publications - CA FINAL
Very precise n nice presentation of sections.
DIRECTORS :
The huge directors chapters has been divided into three distinct chapters, which is not in any other book. One chapter is Basics, second managerial remuneration n third powers of board. It becomes very easy to understand and remember the concepts rather than one full chapter containing mix of all provisions together.
FEMA:
Even in FEMA, the meaning of some important concepts like TDR, Call back & others has been specially givn. A list of important section numbers is also given. Examples are also very nice.
SECRETARIAL PRACTICE:
The writing of minutes and notices has been explained step by step, helping the reader to easily grasp the same.
OTHERS:
Tricks for remembering section numbers.
A list of important case laws n section numbers
Tips for answering practical problems
All the best
Ajay Balasubramanian
(ACA)
(114 Points)
Replied 24 November 2011
I am surprised that noone has advised for KAMAL GARG....
?????????
Piyush Sancheti
(HEAD TAXATION CHEMICAL MFG CO)
(307 Points)
Replied 24 November 2011
Bro,
Kis book me se padh rahe ho, its not matter, kya aur kaise padh rahe ho, its fact.
tumhe jis book me se accha lage wo book tum refer kar sakte ho, but dont try to choose option like is book me short hai aur is book ki language tough hai, U r a CA student yar, & at Final stage, u should have ur own strength to take decision, & tum jo bhi decision lo use phirse mat badlana. means jo bhi book select karna hai wohi last tak use karo.
& as my personal opinion : OUR INSTITUTE MODULE IS PREPRARED VERY CAREFULLY, ITS COVER ALL THINGS. IF U R INTERESTED IN MODULE, THEN MUST READ MODULE.... * MODULE IS BEST*
& remember one thing:- other books r written from original source i.e module, so module is BEST.
CHOICE IS YOUR.
WISH U GOOD LUCK FOR EXAM.
i m also appearing for same attempt so i also follow this.
mayank agarwal
(CA fianlist BCOM(H) CS student )
(577 Points)
Replied 24 November 2011
i think VK agarwal is more than sufficient . & you can refer to study material of institute too , for study in depth .
Binay Jaiswal
(Student)
(27 Points)
Replied 24 November 2011
As per my my opinion now most of the questions are practical so go for a book in which you can get practical problems and their solution. if you choose Surbhi Bansal mam's book then you will not found practical problems and past exam questions.
so please decide by your self and share if any......
CAclubindia
