C.a or m.b.a ?

Page no : 2

@*CS Siddharth Bumb. * (B.Com, CA Final, CS ) (5270 Points)
Replied 26 June 2012

there is no comparison between CA and MBA... you only knows which is best....

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

KRISHNAPRASAD IYER (B.Com , CA Final) (657 Points)
Replied 26 June 2012

Originally posted by : CA PRAVEEN SINGH
	IT IS DIFFICULT TO SAY ANYTHING THAT WHICH IS BETTER.... TOTALLY BASELESS DISCUSSION.... ITS DEPEND ON PERSON TO PERSON.

Nilanjan Chowdhury (114 Points)
Replied 26 June 2012

CA AND CA STUDENT ALWAYS ASK WHETHER CA OR ANY OTHER COURSE IS BETTER.BASICALLY CA LACKS CONFIDENCE.THEY ARE ENJOYING THE SUPPORT OF GOVERNMENT WHERE PEPOPLE FROM OTHER PROFESSION DOES NOT ENJOY SUCH IMMUNITY. YOU PULL OUT THE CA ACT, 1949.,THE WILL LOSE EVERYTHING THEN WE WILL SEE HOW THER COMPETE WITH OTHERS. YOU INTERVIEW ANY IIM STUDENT. THEY ARE FAR SUPERIOR THAN ANY CA ON EARTH. THEY WILL NOT COMPARE WITH ANY PROFESSION.

bharat s kella (assitant manager) (56 Points)
Replied 26 June 2012

dont ever reply to this type of persons quetions who is degrading our profession

1 Like

Rahul Sharma (----------) (8192 Points)
Replied 26 June 2012

Basically, MBA is  a Post Graduate Course. CA is a 
professional course. Difference is MBA will have classroom 
teaching, whereas CA is a self learning course through a 
professional body constituted under an Act of Parliament.

Technically, MBA is all about how to manage things and men.

CA is all about Finance, Accounts & Auditing.

A Chartered Accountant is authorised to review/audit the 
financial accounts of an Organisation and to give his 
opinion. i.e, A Chartered Accountant opinion is legally 
valid for various purposes in particular to the 
organisation's financial data.

MBA's will have decision making power in the management.

Both are different in their educational curriculam.

according to the growth prospects both are the important 
for the oragaization. because they play the different role 
in the organization. they have different working areas. 
where the ca keeps good commands in accounting there the 
mba posses the business growth oriented skills. because the 
mba holder can be good represntator than ca. because mba is 
good representative of company and it self by using good 
communication skills.
     
but the ca is expert in accounting areas. mba can't be 
prepare the proper balance sheet. so, my point of view both 
are the expert own their fields.

3 Like

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Rahul Sharma (----------) (8192 Points)
Replied 26 June 2012

for better know about MBA log on To www.mbaclubindia.com