swarup Datta (Asst Manager Accounts) (175 Points)
29 July 2010Is it necessary to take tuition to pass CA final GR-I in May'2011 ? If there are sufficient books for CA final Gr-I ( New syllabus), please suggest completely so that it would serve the purpose and no tuitions required.
Please help me , because i am very confused what to do? Shall i leave job to take tution ? Because in any case i have to pass CA final GR-I ( new syllabus) in May'2011
Swarup datta
Ankur Garg
(Company Secretary and Compliance Officer)
(114773 Points)
Replied 29 July 2010
Yes you can clear the exam through self study. Refer my article at below mentioned link:
MUST CHECK: SELF STUDY VS. COACHING CLASSES
BOOKS FOR CA FINAL
You may go for the following options regarding books for ca final:
For Accounts: M.P. Vijay kumar or Shukla & Grawal along with Module And Compilation and for AS part go for D.S. Rawat
For CA Final AS preparation---Dolphi Desouza is good.
For Audit: Prakhar Sharma/Paduka/ V.K Agrawal
Note: (MP Vijay Kumar can be used for AS reference)
For Corp Law: Munish Bhandari
For Mafa: Module and Notes of Tarun Mahajan. You may also refer A.N Sridhar.
For Direct Taxes: TN Manoharan (Theory part), Circular, Notification, Amendments, case laws. Also refer Vinod Gupta Modules.
For IDT: Vandana Bangur
For MICS: Module and Dinesh Madan
For Costing: Saxena and vashist or Ravi M Kishore with module
Also refer Scanners and Suggested Answer issued by ICAI for previous year exams and revised them properly.
For some good notes explore CAClubindia forum and share file section. You may also use search facility of club.
Also explore some CA books at the link below:
Best Regards
bhavik mehta
(C.A.)
(526 Points)
Replied 29 July 2010
i think if u r able to do accounts & cost at ur own then no requirement .
as i think, in both the other theories , ultimately we only have to read & understand.
& there are good books for that.
but still i suggest if possible , u just take tutions of practicles , it will help you in many ways...
swarup Datta
(Asst Manager Accounts)
(175 Points)
Replied 29 July 2010
Dear mehta,
My query was that is it possible to pass Ca final GR-I in new syllabus without tuition. Do you have any such example he/she passed Ca final GR-I without exam.
Since i am in job so unless it is highly required that without Coaching it is really very difficult to pass Ca final then i would do coaching otherwise if it can be done with self study i would go for self study.
I want a definite answer whether without tution it is very difficult to pass Ca final ?Swarup datta
swarup Datta
(Asst Manager Accounts)
(175 Points)
Replied 29 July 2010
Dear mehta,
My query was that is it possible to pass Ca final GR-I in new syllabus without tuition. Do you have any such example he/she passed Ca final GR-I without exam.
Since i am in job so unless it is highly required that without Coaching it is really very difficult to pass Ca final then i would do coaching otherwise if it can be done with self study i would go for self study.
I want a definite answer whether without tution it is very difficult to pass Ca final ?Swarup datta
CA Ravi Sisodia
(CA,CS,CMA)
(32226 Points)
Replied 29 July 2010
bhavik mehta
(C.A.)
(526 Points)
Replied 02 August 2010
my frnd,
i think your decision is not based on some other experience or history,
you may create history or you may be the exceptional one of general thing.
but for your satisfaction, yes, i have currently two senior frnds who have passed without classes but if they require they ask guidence from other CA( CA teachers).
& about books, i am also not fully knowledgble ya but you can go for books & notes of some good classes like J.K.Shah & Professtional Acedemy & alll.
Rineesh Raghavan
(MD)
(108 Points)
Replied 02 August 2010
Hi Swaroop
The decision is entirely yours. If you have time at your disposal, and you are reasonably aware of the basics, self study is adequate. If you are short of time, or you are not exposed to self study at early stages of your education, classroom education would be recommended. What takes approximately 2 hour to read and understand may be taught in around 30 minutes of oral communication. Thats the general equation.
Do a quick math, and find how much time you need. My idea would be around 200 to 250 hours for Accounts and MAFA each. Another 150 odd for Auditing and Law.
Rineesh
Analysis of 20 GST Notices (including 2 Appeals) and Practise on Drafting(with recording)
GSTR 9 and 9C for FY 23-24 as amended by Notification 12/2024 dated 10th July 2024(with recording)
CAclubindia
