jaimin (Finance Executive) (465 Points)
13 August 2012
jaimin
(Finance Executive)
(465 Points)
Replied 13 August 2012
so rahul as per your opinion which is best ?
jaimin
(Finance Executive)
(465 Points)
Replied 13 August 2012
thanks chirag but i am talking about direct tax and i think banger sir's books is welknown for Indirect tax
Udit Gupta
(CA Final Student)
(352 Points)
Replied 13 August 2012
Go for T N Manoharan. (or Vinod K. Singhania if u have time & patience)
Padhuka is only a compilation of all suggested answers & RTPs. Also refer to Vinod Gupta's Summary Module.
CA Ashish Pathak
(Employed at Cipla Ltd.)
(2779 Points)
Replied 14 August 2012
chirag
(ca final...)
(95 Points)
Replied 14 August 2012
no jaimin.... bangar also for dt... presently he conduct dt n idt also......website to see book.... www.aadhyas.com
CA Revati Galgali
(B.com ACA DipIFR(ACCA) CS(Exe))
(1049 Points)
Replied 15 August 2012
| Originally posted by : jaimin | ||
 |
I was planning for Direct Tax subject for CA Final for Nov 2012, My Question is Paduka's book for Direct Tax is enough or not for Exam preparation, Do anybady has read thaat book how is that book, do anybady has any opinion about that book, thanking you in advance, |
 |
I used Padhuka in May 2012, it is the best, I dont know about other opinions, but there is nothing better than it, in my opinion, it also comes with a fast track referencer, which is great for Last minute revision, In DT revision is as important as reading, if not less. I strongly recommend it.
SAMIR KUMAR
(CA FINAL(GR. I CLEARED) CFA (IND))
(521 Points)
Replied 15 August 2012
| Originally posted by : Revati Galgali | ||
|
|
HI REVATI ! CAN U PLZ GIVE ME UR TIPS FOR DIRECT TAX AND BENEFITS OF USING PADHUKA. PLSSSSSSSSSSSS HELP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ACTUALLY I HV NOT TAKEN CLASSES FOR DT. ALL FRIENDS ARE SAYING TO USE VG SIR NOTES. BUT I FEAR IT TO BE TOO LENTHY. IS PADUKA BETTER OPTION FOR CONCEPTS AND PRACTICALS? WHETHER ANY OTHER BOOK LIKE PRACTICE MANNUAL WILL ALSO BE REQUIRED? PLS ADVICE A.S.P. WAITING FOR UR RESPONSE.................... THANKS IN ADVANCE. |
|
CA Revati Galgali
(B.com ACA DipIFR(ACCA) CS(Exe))
(1049 Points)
Replied 15 August 2012
| Originally posted by : SAMIR KUMAR | ||
|
|
Originally posted by : Revati Galgali I used Padhuka in May 2012, it is the best, I dont know about other opinions, but there is nothing better than it, in my opinion, it also comes with a fast track referencer, which is great for Last minute revision, In DT revision is as important as reading, if not less. I strongly recommend it. HI REVATI ! CAN U PLZ GIVE ME UR TIPS FOR DIRECT TAX AND BENEFITS OF USING PADHUKA. PLSSSSSSSSSSSS HELP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ACTUALLY I HV NOT TAKEN CLASSES FOR DT. ALL FRIENDS ARE SAYING TO USE VG SIR NOTES. BUT I FEAR IT TO BE TOO LENTHY. IS PADUKA BETTER OPTION FOR CONCEPTS AND PRACTICALS? WHETHER ANY OTHER BOOK LIKE PRACTICE MANNUAL WILL ALSO BE REQUIRED? PLS ADVICE A.S.P. WAITING FOR UR RESPONSE.................... THANKS IN ADVANCE. |
|
1. incorporates past RTP, Past question papers.
2. style of presentation is pointwise.
3. Revision is possible due to the summary of all topics known as Fast track referencer.
Paduka is really good in the above aspects, i dont see any cons in it. YES you will require Practice manual (because you can afford to give time to it, since your first group is already clear) but dont forget the case laws for May and Nov and the RTP.
CA Revati Galgali
(B.com ACA DipIFR(ACCA) CS(Exe))
(1049 Points)
Replied 15 August 2012
I have read from VG sir's notes also , though they are good, they are not practical to refer, at this point of time, its good for refering, not from exam point of view, as u said, its very lengthy and revision of the topics covered is a bit difficult. Though there is a summary module, I still would not suggest it, coz not all topics are covered in the summary, and FTR of paduka covers all topics. VG sirs notes are good, but not feasible now, thats what i feel, see if you are comfortable with the same after assessing your valuation. All the best and god bless :)
SAMIR KUMAR
(CA FINAL(GR. I CLEARED) CFA (IND))
(521 Points)
Replied 15 August 2012
THANK U VERY MUCH DEAR!
I WAS IN SERIOUS DILEMA ABOUT DT.
I AM GOING FOR PADHUKAS
Nirmit Desai
(unemployed)
(36 Points)
Replied 05 September 2012
culd any one of upload the fast track referencer for Nov 2012 of indirect taxes and (if possible) direct taxes.......i found one but tht was for may 2012....its a life saver...plzzzz plzzz do it...if u guys can....would be extremely thankful
CAclubindia
