Can anyone tell me that which is the best books for 2nd group of PCC for self study.
saurabh vohra (Service) (44 Points)
12 November 2008
Can anyone tell me that which is the best books for 2nd group of PCC for self study.
praveen
(Chartered Accountant)
(6971 Points)
Replied 12 November 2008
Buy padhukas for all subject.
It is given pointwise....
Best of luck
Praveen M R
Dear Sourabh,
Did you got Institute study material issued by ICAI. If not you purchase padhukas. Because they have exactly reproduced Institute study material.
Nowadays, if there is no work people started writing books for all subjects. The height of the comedy is that whether they know about that subject or not, they will publish book for earning money. Even if chemistry is included as a subject, padhukas will release book in their name. Because they know very well a term "copyright". i.e. right to copy institute material.
My sincere suggestion is that kindly go through the best books available in the market and dont go by the advice of praveen.
padhukas know how to insert a table for each and every question without proper explanation and with proper copying from other coaching centres workbooks
Extremely sorry if i hurted anybody. It is only in the personal experience i am telling.
All the very best.
Darshu
(CA)
(1580 Points)
Replied 12 November 2008
I am also a CA PCC Student and I am using following books and found them to be really Good.I hope this books will help u a lot.....
Darshu
(CA)
(1580 Points)
Replied 12 November 2008
Dear Rajesh,your opinions are heartily welcomed but you cannot advice someone to follow only your suggestion and not to follow others advice...
I think Praveen has also suggested the books from his personel experience only....
Geetha
(Student)
(0 Points)
Replied 12 November 2008
Sorry Praveen u r wrong.
Seen in the past that a lawyer writing books on Law, a CA writing on tax or accounts or costing etc. But u will find specialisation in their writings. Think as how same authors write books on tax, MICS, IDT, Corp law. Singhania sir, Manoharan sir, written only on tax. They have not done on MICS, IDT, MAFA etc. These people are specialists. GO to dental Dr for having tooth checked up.
Institute provides you excellent study material. These ppl in chennai, in the name called huge regn charges, they dump all their books (in the name called learning kit) to students even if they join one subject. SOmetimes, one subject regn not psble. U need to join some good for nothing class for the sake of another subject.
Dont thing i am criticising some one or institute. One of my friends narrated how shabbility he was dealt by so called popular faculty. Expected knowledge is expert. Learn it from experts and not from experts of copying material from INSTITUTE. Jai Hind Institute.
CA Chaitanya
(PRACTISING CA)
(4283 Points)
Replied 12 November 2008
Padhuka books will be good for 2nd group of PCC.
Geetha
(Student)
(0 Points)
Replied 13 November 2008
Mr. CA Chaitanya,
Your msgs are coming at all corners in the club. Wondering how its possible to do!? Is it for the T shirt?
Mr.Sourabh had asked BEST books but you are seeming not to read the reqts fully and suggest GOOD books.
I dont ve any prejudice of any coaching class but the treatment meted out to my friend is so aweful i narrated. Being a poor person is not one's choice, but his choice of one subject is not heard by them and simply collected in the name of regn charges and dumped what is not useful for him and forced him to join what is not like by him. Despite all these he joined by reading some suggestions like this forum gave, he says that ppl were made to mug up and reproduce things. This will not work for a professional course like CA.
Institute material is the best, after all these ppl copied and pasted and given tables, ref of past exams, RTPs etc. No value addition. So if a person has money, please give for charity and dont develop these ppl who are abusing students like anything. Sorry to say in open. It is a loud cry. All members understand the fate of a CA student.
Sameer Medhekar
(Student)
(4140 Points)
Replied 05 December 2008
You can Refer following Books
A/c - R L Gupta & Radhaswami, Hanif Mukharji
Audit - V K Agrawal and padhuka
Law - Module is the Best option for Corp.Law,Ethics,Communication. Refer other book for B-law
Costing FM - If possible Try to get the notes of Rakesh Agrawal sir
Tax - V K Singhania
IT SM - Module is Best
Analysis of 20 GST Notices (including 2 Appeals) and Practise on Drafting(with recording)
CAclubindia
