mikey (article assisstant) (76 Points)
22 January 2010Dear friends,
I m bit confused in preparation for CA Final (Old Course) in the subject of Indirect Tax. The confusing part is that I am not able to judge the best book available for IDT. Whether I should choose Bangar OR Ajai jain's Notes OR V S Datey??
Please everyone come forward to help me on this issue.
Regards
Aditya
(C.S, CA )
(177 Points)
Replied 22 January 2010
i would suggest you to go 4 ajay jain notes. His notes are best in business
Vidit Mittal
(C.A.Finalist)
(40 Points)
Replied 22 January 2010
If u have not more time then ajai jain is better BUT as per d requirement of Ques asked in last 2attempts ajai jain notes r not sufficient so better to take V S Datey bcoz u can find answers of all Q in this book. GOOD LUCK
CA.B.Vaidhyanathan
(Sr)
(50 Points)
Replied 22 January 2010
i used bhangar and i wud say they are the best in the business.the way of presentation is so gud and most of my frnds use that only
mikey
(article assisstant)
(76 Points)
Replied 22 January 2010
Friends, thanx for ur response. But I have some problems.
1) I purchased the present edition of BANGAR 2-3 days before and while comparing it with the previous edition of BANGAR book which I got from my friend, I came to know that lots of previous years solved questions are absent from the present edtion. May be this is because the publisher launched a COMPILER BY BANGAR FOR IDT from this attempt. There are some illustrations alse which are missing. So, if the absence of these previous year solved questions and illustrations doen not affects the book I will stick woth this book otherwise I have to get it change in few days for a better one.
2) Whether the book as lenghty as DATEY can be revised in a day before exam??
3) I havn't read the NOTES from MR. AJAY JAIN but as my friend Vidit Mittal said above that as per the requirement of questions of last 2 attempts the notes are insufficient.
Friends, kindly advice on these issues.
Thanx in anticipation.
Regards.
CA.B.Vaidhyanathan
(Sr)
(50 Points)
Replied 24 January 2010
2) Whether the book as lenghty as DATEY can be revised in a day before exam??
i don't think so.He's singhaniya for IDT . I think Bhangar is more than enough
the language is simple the case law coverage is extensive . Most of the concepts are well defined, and ots of illustrations wherever required
my only compaint with the book is the quality of paper used and the quality of binding
mikey
(article assisstant)
(76 Points)
Replied 26 January 2010
Vaidhyaaca, my friend,
U r right, that in previous edition the quality of paper used was bad and there were lots of illustrations but in this edition as compared to the previous one, the quality of the paper used is good but lots of illustrations and previous year solved exam questions are missing. I compared the previous edition which I have got from one of my friend with the present edition which I purchased recently. Please dear, advice me in this regard after checking this edition.
Thanx in anticipation.
Regards
CA.B.Vaidhyanathan
(Sr)
(50 Points)
Replied 26 January 2010
I'm gonnna buy this soon and will check and tell u as soon as possible.
But in my opinion it is the best possible book available for the subject in exam point of view
The case laws mentioned there are more than enough and nothing more is required
mikey
(article assisstant)
(76 Points)
Replied 27 January 2010
Thanx for helping me dear.
I will wait for ur response my friend.
Regards
CA CWA Yugandar PR
(Manager)
(139 Points)
Replied 09 February 2010
i got bangar's IDT book for may2010 Exam but it was missing with lot of illustrations and past exams problems and the publisher issued new complier for IDT and the complier also OUT OF Stock, i dont know what to do now and plz can any one send me the softcopy of such complier to yugandar.pr @ gmail.com
it will be helpful to me
thanks
CAclubindia
