Go Ad-Free on CAclubindia with Daily Mobile Updates. Subscribe Now!

Bank guarantee Vs Letter Of Credit

sukh (Article CA Final) (38 Points)

29 August 2008

Difference between bank guarantee & Letter of Credit .......

Reply
Follow
Share

5 Replies

Amresh Choudhary (M.Sc. (Maths) MBA LLB (DU)) (694 Points)
Replied 29 August 2008

thanks for the infomation

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA Thomas Raju Paravada (Chartered Accountant) (570 Points)
Replied 29 August 2008

good info

(Guest)

Dear Sukh

Please tell me

1. Bank Guarantee is tranferable instrument or not.

2. Can we pledge a BG against any loan.

3. What is the procedure for claim of a BG from bank

4. Enhancement of BG is possible ?

5. In LC what is the meaning of 'Irrevocable'?

6. What is Transshipment

7. What is Bill of Lading

8. What is Certificate of Origin

9. How can we negotiate an export doc from Bank.

Plz advice its URGENT

sukh (Article CA Final) (38 Points)
Replied 15 September 2008

Originally posted by :Rajesh
"	Dear Sukh Please tell me 1. Bank Guarantee is tranferable instrument or not. 2. Can we pledge a BG against any loan. 3. What is the procedure for claim of a BG from bank 4. Enhancement of BG is possible ? 5. In LC what is the meaning of 'Irrevocable'? 6. What is Transshipment 7. What is Bill of Lading 8. What is Certificate of Origin 9. How can we negotiate an export doc from Bank. Plz advice its URGENT	"

CA Rama koti Reddy (DGM ( F & A)) (50 Points)
Replied 19 January 2011

Bank Guarantees and LCs are financial instruments often used in inland or international trade when suppliers or vendors do not have established business relationships with their counterparts. The difference between the two instruments is the position of the bank relative to the buyer and seller of goods or services. The difference is as explained below.

A letter of credit is a bank’s DIRECT undertaking to the supplier (called the beneficiary) to pay. When a letter of credit is in use, the issuing bank does not wait for the buyer to default, and for the seller to invoke the undertaking.

In contrast, a guarantee is a written contract stating that IN THE EVENT the primary party (the buyer) is unable or unwilling to pay its dues to the supplier the bank, as guarantor to the transaction the BG issuer would pay (the client's debt) to the supplier.

In other words, a bank guarantee is an undertaking of a bank on behalf of its customer. But this comes into play ONLY WHEN the principal party (the buyer) has failed to pay its supplier. (Do note this key point.)

Essentially, the bank becomes a co-signer for its customer's purchases.

Hence, in a BG the initial claim is still settled primarily (i.e., first) against the bank's client, and not the bank itself. Should the client default, ONLY THEN would the bank (which has issued the BG) agree to pay for it's client's debts on behalf of its client. This is a type of contingent guarantee.

A bank guarantee, therefore, is more risky for the merchant and less risky for the bank. But this is not the case with a letter of credit (LC).

With a bank guarantee, if a client defaults the bank assumes liability. With a letter of credit, liability rests solely with the issuing bank (this being the key difference and the key advantage in an LC) which then must collect the money from its client.

Therefore, the principal character of an LC is that it is a potential claim against the bank, rather than a bank's client. An LC substitutes the bank's credit for its client's. The seller's risk is mitigated from the risk that the buyer will not pay to the risk that the BANK will be unable to pay, which is unlikely.

A letter of credit is less risky for the merchant, but more risky for a bank, though banks accept full liability in both cases.