Avoid injustice to ca students

Old Course 2046 views 13 replies

qarni

student

1220 Points Joined September 2007

I salute ICAI

I honour ICAI

I am with ICAI

Respected and very ... respected Icai students , Members , Committe and others

I request to one and all to think about the injustice to ca students ?

How think once? By changing the schemes frequently ?

The institute think that they are maintaining standard by changing schemes but it is not maintaining standards , but it is the members and students cant understand why they they are doing like that?

students are scared about the changing of schemes?

final and cpt students are benifited to some extend not full bit PE-2 students became victims mainly to this. Because there duration to join articles and to attempt final , OH!!!!! very very long long vast............

ICAI should think on this.

We hope ICAI thinks on this issue because it is making justice to whole economy by its service and justice....

Replies (13)

CA. Amit Daga

Finance Controller CA. CS. CFA. CIFRS.

9017 Points Joined October 2007

Quarni i can understand your situation... but yar "Parivartan sansar ka niyam hai"

Irshad

Article

1426 Points Joined September 2007

But then the new scheme is disadvantageous to PE2 students

Guest

439380 Points Joined August 2012

Hi I was a PE II student only and i didnot clear my exams in may 2007 so i immediately joined PCC scheme. this was useful to me as my articles is getting counted.

Irshad

Article

1426 Points Joined September 2007

PE-2 students can migrate to PCC and start doing articleship.Is it possible???Please put light on this.

srinivas

humble devotee of saraswati

885 Points Joined January 2008

dear friend you will come out as a better CA when the institute changes its scheme of curriculum to be on par with the changing world. why don''t you throw light on this? whatever the institute does, it will be in the best interests of its members and students in the long run.

Mridul

Financial Advisor

225 Points Joined October 2007

Totally agree with you Quarni. Amit Sir ji, we got screwed by that parivartan, why us?

Rajan Gupta

C.A. final student

277 Points Joined December 2007

This is total injustice to the students of Pe-2. We must raise voice against the institute. People regd. in the old scheme must continue with old CA Final syllabus only. There is no point in studying new subjects all over again.

pRaSoOn

Articled assistant

500 Points Joined February 2008

Rajan to excited ho gaya...yaar there was no other option left wid the insti....As a matter of fact, there wer 200000 ca's required just in India by 2010,...while there were only 125000 by the end of 2006....you tell me how insti. could raise the no. unless a flexible scheme was intorduced...

pRaSoOn

Articled assistant

500 Points Joined February 2008

Although dat's a diff issue dat modifications wer absolute theoretical and proved to be wrong big time all for cpt students,pe-2 students(I WAS ONE OF THE UNLUCKY LOT) and obviously c.a.'s....

pRaSoOn

Articled assistant

500 Points Joined February 2008

Ca's suffered bcoz though they wer getting articles for 1000 bucks....but what value addition could they make...cmmon nobody can expect a 12th cleared student to tackle audit or tax situation of companies and even individual...i m talkin bout general students...not the CHACHA CHOUDHARI type genius...

Guest

439380 Points Joined August 2012

Don't pity 12th cleared students.They are Smart.The only problem is that CAs overlook the potential of these 12th pass.They treat them as kids and don't let them learn much work.I repeatedly asked my CA if i can contribute to filing the returns of Companies in the month of oct 07.He made me sit for the whole month while other articles who are graduates or pe2 pass were floded with more work than they can handle.Since i asked if i could contribute he handed me some returns on 31st oct and asked me to go and submit these forms.I was shocked.

Guest

439380 Points Joined August 2012

about the change of scheme,we pcc students have more topics in our syllabus.But these topics were not much relevant.For e.g.,in accounts,the should have added chapters about stock and share dealings etc. which are very relevant these days but the ICAI added average due date and other such topics which adds to the syllabus with no benefit to students.Prasoon,I m sorry man.I was frustrated at that time and misinterpreted your staement.I just came back from office.