I m planning to buy audit book for self study but confused between padhuka & surbhi bansal. please suggest which is the better one.
12 Replies
Haran
(Practice)
(382 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012
i would suggest surabhi bansal book,do practical problems from latest practice manual.
but i follow kamalgarg book,except caro all other topics are well covered in that book,especially standards are awesome and language is easy to understand.
but caro i felt very short.
surabhi bansal is crisp and you have to add some more points in exams,i felt presentation of answer is not proper.
padhuka i would not suggest as it is monotonous and language is not appealing,it will drive you to sleep.
now it is up to you.
see all the 3 books and decide.
one caution never go for v.k.agarwal book.lots of mistakes in that.
rahul
(Chartered Accountant)
(5572 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012
Surbi bandal is not good for practical topics , if you buy surbhi bansal you must refer ths along with padhuka.. One more book is available in the market which is quite balanced - srinivasan anand g by taxmann. You can try this book.
monu
(nil)
(276 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012
kaml garg is better than surbhi bansal also recommended by icai
CA Manoj Kumar
(Fresher)
(32 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012
V.K. Agarwal book is best bcoz of coverage of all topics in a proper manner
Ashish Sablok
(B.Com(H),CA Final)
(132 Points)
Replied 20 March 2012
i studied Surbhi Bansal in Inte and found it short and precise which makes understnding concept a little difficult, so feeling a little 'not confident' about Surbhi Bansal. can you provide me detail about padhuka
Ankur
(CA Final Student)
(999 Points)
Replied 21 March 2012
i was not very impressed with Paduka, go for Surbhi bansal or srinivasan anang g
CMA KNVV Sri Vidya - Sri Kanth
(C.A.Final (New) ICWAI FINAL (New))
(11269 Points)
Replied 21 March 2012
Padhuka is very good .. coz the wordings are same as CA Intitute MAterial
All the best
Ashish Sablok
(B.Com(H),CA Final)
(132 Points)
Replied 21 March 2012
I guess i should buy Surbhi Bansal
NIKITA JAIN
(CA FINAL)
(140 Points)
Replied 23 March 2012
Ashish, me too searching for book of audit;i have surbhi bansal book but its given in short. I am not satisfied with that book. i am planning to purchase book by kamal garg.
Budding Professional
(B.Com, CA & CS FINAL)
(1686 Points)
Replied 25 March 2012
surbhi bansal is pretty brief and u will always have to search for more contentn to add to that and in a few chapters, some topics are not discussed at all. I also got surbhi bansal and got it replaced by Padhukas.
Padhukas language is better than Surbhi Bansal's. And also Padhuka's book has questions from past exams and RTP which gives it an advantage.
Surbhi Bansal's book is notes only and Padhuka is a complete reference (in questions answers format)
Recent Topics
- Missing invoice in gst
- GST on consultancy
- Linking adhaar to UAN without employer
- WHETHER ITC REVERSAL TH. GSTR 3B OR DRC03
- Advance Tax For Freelancers
- Is fvu 8.8 version available ?
- Interest and penalty on advance tax shortfall
- Joint Account with 3 legal heirs.......
- TCS adjustment
- GST audit and scrutiny
Related Threads
CAclubindia
