Go Ad-Free on CAclubindia with Daily Mobile Updates. Subscribe Now!

Audit CA Final

Ria Saraf (CA final student) (110 Points)

20 July 2010

I have alloted 20 days for audit. I have books by Surbhi Bansal and Paduka as well..pls suggest and guide me as to how should i study for it and which book shud i follow...thanks

Reply
Follow
Share

4 Replies

CA Ayush Agarwal (Kolkata-Pune-Mumbai) (27186 Points)
Replied 20 July 2010

I Think Instead Of Following Surbhi Bansal & Padhuka & ICAI Mat.

Just refer VK Agrawal

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA-CWA RAVI (CA-CWA in industry) (5464 Points)
Replied 20 July 2010

surbhi bansal and padhuka is the best combination

refer text of surbhi bansal

and do practical problems of rtp and past papers from padhuka

i have vk aggarwal but it does not cover whole syllabus if u compare with surbhi bansal or padhuka u will find the same also it is very dry and written in a paragraph manner instead of tabular presentation which is there in surbhi bansal

v k aggawal does not contain rtp's question but padhuka does

lastly the vk aggarwal contains all past questions at one place at the end of the book the answer of which have not been reviesed keeping in view the amendments to SA and ca act 1949

so for these reasons i gave up studying from vk aggarwal and followwiing text of surbhi bansal mam and practical problems of padhuka

if it look fine for u follow the same

all the best

( if anybody has and idea how to score above 70 in idt please share

plz do nt refer me books like dipak gupta or banger . i knw these are good books

i want to knw the strategy for scoring good in the said paper

thanx in advance )

2 Like

(Guest)

Originally posted by : RAVI KHANAL
	surbhi bansal and padhuka is the best combination refer text of surbhi bansal and do practical problems of rtp and past papers from padhuka i have vk aggarwal but it does not cover whole syllabus if u compare with surbhi bansal or padhuka u will find the same also it is very dry and written in a paragraph manner instead of tabular presentation which is there in surbhi bansal v k aggawal does not contain rtp's question but padhuka does lastly the vk aggarwal contains all past questions at one place at the end of the book the answer of which have not been reviesed keeping in view the amendments to SA and ca act 1949 so for these reasons i gave up studying from vk aggarwal and followwiing text of surbhi bansal mam and practical problems of padhuka if it look fine for u follow the same all the best ( if anybody has and idea how to score above 70 in idt please share plz do nt refer me books like dipak gupta or banger . i knw these are good books i want to knw the strategy for scoring good in the said paper thanx in advance )

Good suggestion,keep it up..is surbhi bansals text book on auditing available or where can we get latest notes from ,pls provide the source..pls suggest for SA's as well ,as padhukas don cover sa's.wat combination to go for in case of sa's?

Balaji Sarangarajan (MBA & (CA Final)) (1131 Points)
Replied 20 July 2010

Originally posted by : RAVI KHANAL
	surbhi bansal and padhuka is the best combination refer text of surbhi bansal and do practical problems of rtp and past papers from padhuka i have vk aggarwal but it does not cover whole syllabus if u compare with surbhi bansal or padhuka u will find the same also it is very dry and written in a paragraph manner instead of tabular presentation which is there in surbhi bansal v k aggawal does not contain rtp's question but padhuka does lastly the vk aggarwal contains all past questions at one place at the end of the book the answer of which have not been reviesed keeping in view the amendments to SA and ca act 1949 so for these reasons i gave up studying from vk aggarwal and followwiing text of surbhi bansal mam and practical problems of padhuka if it look fine for u follow the same all the best ( if anybody has and idea how to score above 70 in idt please share plz do nt refer me books like dipak gupta or banger . i knw these are good books i want to knw the strategy for scoring good in the said paper thanx in advance )

very good suggestion

i am using vashist & saxena for costing and manoharan for DT can any one suggest the strategy to adopted for securing a good and pass marks in the papers.

also can any one suggest me whether to go for one group or both groups along with the strategy.

since my case is i am working and my daily available time is 3 to 4 hrs. and i have not even touched any of the papers in group one.

I belong to old syllabus

the books i follow are:

a/c vijay kumar

audit - surbhi bhansal & padhukas

law - munish bandhari

mafa - murali

cost - vashist & saxena

mics - compilation (also i have padhukas)

dt - manoharan

idt - bangar