Apply for verification or not?
Anshul (CA) (98 Points)
29 January 2013Anshul (CA) (98 Points)
29 January 2013
CA MANISH AGRAWAL
(Practice)
(539 Points)
Replied 29 January 2013
As per rules there would never be decrase in marks even it clearly show that marks is given wrongly.
But is always adviceable to not do any verfication if pass in that group,be satisfied my bro.
Sathish M
(Management Accountant)
(40581 Points)
Replied 29 January 2013
Anshul,
What is the marks you are short in group 1 after taking into account the surplus of 9 marks from your second group?
myforum2015
(NA)
(21 Points)
Replied 29 January 2013
Originally posted by : CA MANISH AGRAWAL | ||
As per rules there would never be decrase in marks even it clearly show that marks is given wrongly. But is always adviceable to not do any verfication if pass in that group,be satisfied my bro. |
I am fully agree with CA MANISH
i am not always right but i never wrong
--------------------------------------------------------
Anshul
(CA)
(98 Points)
Replied 29 January 2013
Originally posted by : Sathish M | ||
Anshul, What is the marks you are short in group 1 after taking into account the surplus of 9 marks from your second group? |
I have not yet given the group 1st.In the recent exams,i gave only the 2nd group.
Hence there is no question of being short in aggregate.
Anshul
(CA)
(98 Points)
Replied 29 January 2013
Originally posted by : CA MANISH AGRAWAL | ||
As per rules there would never be decrase in marks even it clearly show that marks is given wrongly. But is always adviceable to not do any verfication if pass in that group,be satisfied my bro. |
Thanks for suggestion sir.But can you pls show that provision which shows that there can't be further reduction in marks.
Bcz some students are saying contrary to you,as they say that still possible reduction of marks can be there.
CA Vikas Agrawal
(Practice)
(363 Points)
Replied 29 January 2013
just go throuh faqs on verification... reduction is possible
Sathish M
(Management Accountant)
(40581 Points)
Replied 29 January 2013
PSPSPS
(Practicing)
(1344 Points)
Replied 29 January 2013
Rather I can suggest to Anshul that You call for the Certified Copies, Where ICAI does not have any powers to do any reverification also as It is not asked by the Candidate/ Applicant & also when you get the papers you will for yourself get to see where there are Less Marks awarded, & Incase if there was any Total Mistake showing Less marks in Marks Sheet then what is awarded in the Paper & question wise then Probably you can tell ICAI about that else even Not tell ICAI as You have already Passed the Group, But by doing this atleast the doubt of Less marks in your Mind will get Just crystally Cleared with a Documentary evidence of paper copise in your Hand.
I am also doing the same, As I have also clread G2 but dont know how, so am rather more curious to see the Papers where I got the Marks to clear the Papers & the group 2 (Except DT where i had expected 60+ ( Got 52 ) & IDT expected 50 - 52 Max ( Got 59 ) AMA expected 34 - 36 Max ( Got 48 ) & ISCA expected 35 - Max to Max 40 ( But Got 43 ) Somehow with the Grace of God & High Luck on my side Cleared G2 with 202 marks in second attempt & Now waiting for G1 in May 2013.
Friends How is G1 easier then G2 or Tougher then G2, As i have not studied G1 but Both attempts I gave only G & cleared in 2nd Attempt, So am really worried & frightned for G1 how Tough it is as compared to G2, is G1 Comparitavely easy & Managable, Pls Tell me the Honest Opinions & experiences.
CA Tushar Singhania
(Asst. Manager Accts & Fin.)
(402 Points)
Replied 30 January 2013
Listen, more often than not marks are reduced, I would seriously suggest that if you aren't 100% sure that your marks will increase, please dont even think of re-verification. I dont know from where another member got the fact that rules state that reduction of marks is not allowed, i have seen amongst a lot of my freinds that upto 10 marks have been reduced
Santosh Shetty
(IPCC, Asst Manager)
(200 Points)
Replied 30 January 2013
Agree with CA Tushar Singhania. Don't go for re-verification unless you are short by some marks in 1st group.
CA Mansi Kotecha
(Keep Smiling !!)
(6890 Points)
Replied 30 January 2013
I would say..Be Happy that u cleared !!