Ad Free CAclubindia and Daily Updates on your Mobile. Subscribe Now!

Answer Sheet of Rank Holders

A.K.Banik (Tax Consultant) (1596 Points)

05 April 2011

Can any Publisher Publish the Answer Sheer of Rank holders of CA exams ?

I think, the Answer Sheet will be helpful for students and all types of misunderstanding regarding presentation of Answer will be removed.

Please share your valuable opinion.

Reply
Follow
Share

19 Replies

Vikas Marele (CA in Service) (1144 Points)
Replied 05 April 2011

I dnt think ICAI shares the answer sheets of students with anyone............!

1 Like

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Kavita Maddala (Article) (24 Points)
Replied 05 April 2011

I also think that the same cannot be published.

Amit kumar mondal (Audit Assistant) (72 Points)
Replied 05 April 2011

I also think that if icai will publish that handwrriten answer sheets of RANK HOLDER ,we are all compare to ourself AND IMPROVE WEEKPOINT

Vikas Marele (CA in Service) (1144 Points)
Replied 05 April 2011

I dnt think amit it is a good idea b'coz it can create a big problem. Than students will start comparision between there answers sheets with other & raised clarification from the institue. & 2nd thing ICAI are issuing suggested & compilers for students. If u go through with compilers then u can improve alots & score good marks.

(Guest)

'' The Suggested Answers published do not constitute the basis for evaluation of the students answers in the examinations..The answers are prepared by the faculty of the board of studies..with a view to assist the students in their education"

this is written in every suggested answers and compilers...

So it is just helpful to know the answers..we can know the presentation required in the examination to score more marks..then how would we know the presentaion sir..?

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

A.K.Banik (Tax Consultant) (1596 Points)
Replied 05 April 2011

Sasanka - Your point is Right .We need to know what is the Professional Approach , which ICAI wants from students .

SIVASIVA (FCA, Future CA) (4935 Points)
Replied 05 April 2011

Originally posted by : Kavita Maddala
	I also think that the same cannot be published.

Arniv Sharda (CA Final) (3006 Points)
Replied 06 April 2011

yup it cannot be published but it should be published as it would help others a lot

cheers

Bhavik Nathwani (Asst. Accountant) (40 Points)
Replied 06 April 2011

First of all, I am also student of IPCC, group 1. I also think that ICAI should publish that answersheet for guide us. But as Mr. Akash said that ICAI expect professional approach from us. So if they disclose answersheet of such rankholders. pattern and format of presantion of our answers may be fixed. Our innovative mind stopped worked and follow the fixed manner....................and last but not list after becoming CA may be our monopoly brake................

(Guest)

ICAI wud never display the answer sheet to its students cos there is no such format to write any kin d of answers...

ICAI jus needs the answers rite, it doesnt matter the format of answers...

if u need any specific format of answers than look out for the sugggested answers as the present the std format for the answers....and writing the same format in the exam gives u full marks..

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Jeevan (Consultant) (38 Points)
Replied 06 April 2011

This will be a good step by ICAI to publish the answer sheets of rankholders to all.

YASH JAIN (ARTICLE) (554 Points)
Replied 06 April 2011

Akash U have raised a very good and logical issue. First of all we all as CA students strive our best to give best presentation in CA exams with hopes of passing out with good marks, but forget about passing majority of us get poor marks. We then analyse ourselves the result of which does not come out in positive way. I think If ICAI can give papers of rankholders at least we would be motivated to present paper in that manner and thereby raise our benchmark...................Because out of lakhs of students only 1 student fullfills the criteria of presenting the paper as per ICAI way and he get rank 1. So i think ICAI should come out with books showing papers of Rankholder.

A.K.Banik (Tax Consultant) (1596 Points)
Replied 06 April 2011

Originally posted by : Bhavik Nathwani
	First of all, I am also student of IPCC, group 1. I also think that ICAI should publish that answersheet for guide us. But as Mr. Akash said that ICAI expect professional approach from us. So if they disclose answersheet of such rankholders. pattern and format of presantion of our answers may be fixed. Our innovative mind stopped worked and follow the fixed manner....................and last but not list after becoming CA may be our monopoly brake................

Dear Bhavik .

You know that in each tern ICAI comes out with new question sets which test the practical approach of Students . Now , a student , who gets Rank or High Marks , tackle the situation in smart way . What i mean to say that , we must follow there Though process . I do not want to imitate there mere solution , but want to get the idea to tackle situation under a pressure Cooker situation of 3 hours .

Bhavik Nathwani (Asst. Accountant) (40 Points)
Replied 06 April 2011

Ok.... Aakash i m with u that institute shall give an answersheet of rankholders. ......but please yar pressure Cooker jaise word use karke meri band mat baja.....b'coz i'm already afraid