Rashmi (CS) (90 Points)
03 February 2011Dear members,
I wish to know whether the annual return of company is valid if it is signed only by Chairman & Managing director.
Or it has to be compulsorily signed by the CS as well. If yes whether any declaration is required?
Kindly give your views.
Regards
- Rashmi
Sudhir Garg
(Service)
(236 Points)
Replied 03 February 2011
Dear Rashmi
For unlisted company, AR is required to be signed by director or Secretary. If no CS then by two directors one of which must be MD if company is having. Means Director+CS or if no CS, then Director+Director (MD if company is having).
in case of listed company, in addition to above, certificate of PCS is also required.
Regards- Sudhir
Jaideep
(Service)
(1368 Points)
Replied 03 February 2011
Hi,
Annual Return to be signed by a Managing Director and Manager/ Secretary or by two Directors where there is no MD,manager or secretary. In the case of a company whose shares are listed on a recognised stock exchange, the certificates shall also be signed by a secretary in whole time practice.
I hope you got It....
By MD and CS
or Dir and DIR
for Listed Company in addition to above PCS
Rashmi
(CS)
(90 Points)
Replied 03 February 2011
Thanks Sudhir.
That implies 2 directors i.e. MD + Director (In case of no CS) would serve the purpose.
No certificate is required to be given by them?
What if the company has a CS but due to unavoidable circumstances
his/her signatures can't be obtained. Two directors can still sign instead?
Jaideep
(Service)
(1368 Points)
Replied 03 February 2011
Yes two directors are sufficient if there is no CS or MD. Even if there is CS, Two director can sign.
Sudhir Garg
(Service)
(236 Points)
Replied 03 February 2011
I hope AR supported with clarificatory note both signed by "MD+Director" would be OKAY.
Other views are welcomed.
Regards- Sudhir
Jayashree S Iyer
(Company Secretary)
(3224 Points)
Replied 04 February 2011
I disagree with Jaideep.
If the company has a Wholetime Company Secretary then the signature of the CS is required.
If CS signature could not be obtained, then compliance certificate from a PCS is to be obtained and attached as we do in the case of companies having a paid up share capital of >10 lacs but <5 crores and not engaging a Wholetime CS.
Other experts please share your views on the subject.
CS Nitin Jaiswal
(Company Secretary)
(283 Points)
Replied 04 February 2011
No, pcs signature required Only if the company is listed with any stock exchange , hence signature of two directors are sufficient.
And further for the compliance certificate limit of 10lakhs--5 cr. should be considered
Further if the Paid up cap of the company id more than 5 cr. then it compulsory requied to signed by a CS in employment.
Rashmi
(CS)
(90 Points)
Replied 04 February 2011
| Originally posted by : CS Nitin Jaiswal | ||
 |
if the Paid up capital of the company is more than 5 cr. then it compulsory requied to signed by a CS in employment. |
 |
The paid-up capital is more than 5crores, unlisted company and a whole time CS in employment
But sign of CS can not be possibly obtained (out of reach). This is confusing now.
Jaideep
(Service)
(1368 Points)
Replied 04 February 2011
Well, still in my opinion, Signature of two directors are sufficient,
Regards
kota srinvias
(Director)
(24 Points)
Replied 26 November 2013
pls let me know: If a pvt ltd company has MD and two dirctors and no secretary or manager. now the MD is abroad. Whether the Annual return can be signed by the available two diectors? pls respond asap.
thanks
kota
CAclubindia
