Friends
whether the question of amg that came in the paper was correct or not
none of my friends got its balance sheet tallied
kindly reply
cheers
Arniv Sharda (CA Final) (3006 Points)
12 May 2012Friends
whether the question of amg that came in the paper was correct or not
none of my friends got its balance sheet tallied
kindly reply
cheers
CA Pallav Singhania
(IT System Auditor)
(33262 Points)
Replied 12 May 2012
Intrinsic value for both companies....13
Balance sheet 1 lac short...that will be capital reserve
Piyush Tanwar
(Assistant Manager - Accounts)
(1432 Points)
Replied 12 May 2012
yaar ase thode na hum capital reserve dalenge.... thre s sme mistke i think
Arniv Sharda
(CA Final)
(3006 Points)
Replied 12 May 2012
agreed with piyush
aryan bhai intrinsic value toh 13 thi par balance sheet tally nai ho rahi thi
by the PC net assets se nikalni thi ya payment method se
cheers
Vikas Gupta
(CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT)
(16295 Points)
Replied 12 May 2012
intrinsic value = 13
Balance Sheet
Capital = 943300 GoodWill = Nil
General Res= 101000 Building = 385000
Capital Res= 20990 Stock = 166500
Profit & Loss= 66000 Cash at bank = 207590
S.Crs = 102600 Drs = 459800
Prel exp = 15000
Total 1233890 1233890
Calc of Capital Res
Vasudha Ltd Good Will = 50000
Vaishall Ltd Good Will = 50000
Capital Res = -120990 (50000+175000+172900+75000+109590-58200-403300)
Total Cap Res Net 20990
Vikas Gupta
(CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT)
(16295 Points)
Replied 12 May 2012
So friends there is no mistake
Arniv Sharda
(CA Final)
(3006 Points)
Replied 12 May 2012
bhai S and V
mujhe toh yeh galat lag raha hai
cheers
Piyush Tanwar
(Assistant Manager - Accounts)
(1432 Points)
Replied 13 May 2012
of course net assets method s niklegi.... bcz... purchase consideration to after net assets of vaishali niklane k bad hi pta chelgi... to isme to capital reserve ka swal hi ni uthta
prateek
(cpt done)
(34 Points)
Replied 13 May 2012
Bhaiyo goodwill bhi question me de rakhi thi jo balance sheet me ayegi and securities premium kahan gya
preliminary expense poore write off honge dono companies ke
Piyush Tanwar
(Assistant Manager - Accounts)
(1432 Points)
Replied 13 May 2012
ya agree with prateek... preliminary expenses should b w/o from the equityshareholders A/c.... and ya goodwill b ayegi at revised rate
CA...
(Others)
(119 Points)
Replied 13 May 2012
Vikas Gupta
(CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT)
(16295 Points)
Replied 14 May 2012
| Originally posted by : piyush tanwar | ||
 |
of course net assets method s niklegi.... bcz... purchase consideration to after net assets of vaishali niklane k bad hi pta chelgi... to isme to capital reserve ka swal hi ni uthta |
 |
Friends first of all hum PC intrinsic Value se calculate kar rahe hai so goodwill and capital reserve aayega..agar net assest value se karte to nahi aata...
Vasudha Ltd ke koi goodwill and fixed assets ke value change nahi karni hai..wo humko siraf intrinsic value calculate karne mai help karege..Koi be Accounting Standard humko goodwill upword revalue apni book mai karna allow nahi karta..and as per AS-26 only purchase goodwill he record kar sakte hai..revalue nahi kar sakte..as per AS-14 Amalgamation ke time hum vasudha ke fixed asset be revalue nahi kar sakte..unless specily provide na keya ho..agar aisa likha ho "Vashuda Ltd should record Fixed assets on revalued amount" then amalgamation se phale usko revalue karta hota hai..but aisa kuch be nahi hai..
goodwill and capital reserve both ek sath nahi aate..so dono company ke goodwill and capital reseve net karne hai
Preliminary exp..vaishali ltd nahi nahi aayege and vasudha ke bare mai kuch be nahi so isko writeoff karne ke koi need nahi hai..but tum agar write off karoge to uska ek note dena hoga because qus nahi bol raha writeoff karne ke leya
Prateek ji...security premium bech mai kaha se aa gaya...issue to face value per hue hai...
Landmark Judgments: Important Provisions of the EPF & ESI Act interpreted by the Honorable Supreme Court of India
CAclubindia
