Advanced Management Accounting Paper

Page no : 5

Rajat (CA Final) (156 Points)
Replied 17 May 2011

Q7 b) Entertain U is bit tricky & most of the students are getting different different answers

According to me the answer should be (I may be wrong)

Assured Revenue = (9600 + 39600 + 10800 + 9000) = 69000

Committed Cost    = (71000 + 14000 + 7400 + 6600) = 99000

So the cost to be recovered for break even                    = 30000

**** 6600 cost  = Snacks for assured 330 guest

 

Option 1 (Tickets to be sold in ratio of 1:3:1 to recover 30,000)

Since 20 Rs is variable cost for snacks,net benefit will be 300, 200 & 100

Thus by selling    VIP = 30 tickets /  Mid = 90 tickets / Last = 30 tickets

Company will recover 30,000 and will breakeven.

Category wise occupancy at break even

VIP = 90

Mid = 270

Last = 120

 

Option II (Tickets to be sold in ration of 2:2:5 to recover 30,000)

Again, since 20 Rs is variable cost for snacks,net benefit will be 300, 200 & 100

To follow & maintain the ratio allotment to be done in 3 steps

I allotment in ratio = VIP 30 / Mid 30 / Last 75 (1st row fully sold)

II allotment in ratio = VIP 0 / Mid 6   / Last 15 (3rd row fully sold)

III allotwent in ratio = VIP 0 / Mid 24 / Last 0

 

To recover 30,000 addtional ticket sold = VIP 30 / Mid 60 / Last 90

Category wise occupancy at break even

VIP = 90

Mid = 240

Last = 180

1 Like

Rajat (CA Final) (156 Points)
Replied 17 May 2011

Q1 a) Seems no has posted the answer on this till now

My Answer

Productwise Sales Margin Price Variance :  A = 4000 (F)   /   B = 15000 (A)

Productwise Sales Margin Mix Variance    :  A = 4800 (F)   /   B =   2400 (A)


CA Lokesh Pokharna (CA (Ahmedabad Bhilwara Chittorgarh))   (4128 Points)
Replied 17 May 2011

@ RAJAT YES 7B ANSWER OF FIRST PARTWOULD BE VIP-90 MIDLE 270 & LOWER 120 MINE R SAME ........TOTAL REVENUE TO BE RECOVERED = 71000+14000+7400-9000+(30*20)=84000

NOW REVENUE (1:3:1) 

VIP = (90-30*300)=18000

MIDDLE 270*200=54000

LOWER  120*100=12000 TOTAL 18000+54000+12000=84000 THIS THE BEP...


MaNThaN Shah (Student) (315 Points)
Replied 18 May 2011

Q.1(c) committed costs are i,iii,v Q.3(a) assignment step-II as under T1-7,5,5,0,3 T2-9,6,3,0,6 T3-7,3,0,0,4 T4-0,0,2,0,0 other ans. Of Q3.a) Correctly given by rajat Q.3b) i m nt sure if anyone knw ans then plz post here. Q.3.c) total contn of x,y,z are 8000,6000 and 4500 respectively. As co. Can produce only one product so opp.cost for X is 6000 (higher of other two) same way for Y, 8000 and for z also 8000.

MaNThaN Shah (Student) (315 Points)
Replied 19 May 2011

Ans of Q.1(a) sales margin price variance for product A is 16000A and for B is 30000F


sumit (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (479 Points)
Replied 19 May 2011

expecting a bit lenient marking in costing as paper was tricky as compared to laste attempt as well as lengthy also.


CA SAHIL MITTAL (JOB) (240 Points)
Replied 20 May 2011

Originally posted by : Rajat

Q6 c) Maruti Agency will do better in opting for advance version

Incremental Benefit = 15,00,000 (5000 x 30 x 10 months)

Incremental Cost = 10,60,576 (3,55,000 + 1,70,400 + 5,35,176 material wastage)

Net Benefit = 4,39,424

 

Q7 a) Prediction of 5 days of Demand

Day1 = 5 / Day2 = 6 / Day3 = 7 / Day4 = 6 / Day5 = 8

So Average no of cars rented per day = 6.40 car

Rental lost over 5 days = 3 rentals (1 on 3rd day & 2 on 5th day)

Dont Agree with 7(a).. i got 5.80 . . . you have maximum 6 cars..so on day 3 and 5 only 6 car will be rented.

average= (5+6+6+6+6)/5= 5.80


MaNThaN Shah (Student) (315 Points)
Replied 25 May 2011

Ans of Question No.4(d)?

CA SAHIL MITTAL (JOB) (240 Points)
Replied 26 May 2011

VAM is better.. it involves more systematic process of calculating penalties instead of arbitrarily assigning anywhere.. Solution of VAM is much closer to optimal solution.



Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Join CCI Pro


Subscribe to the latest topics :

Search Forum: