narasimha murty (Managing partner) (54 Points)
29 January 2010It is a common practice of several small time suppliers to discount a document (generated at "goods receipt" point of a factory). The person who discounts them brings several such documents as a bunch and presents to the factory's Fin & Accounts for payment.
Can we consider such Goods Received Note as a Bill of Exchange and pass accounting entries accordingly?
shankar
(M.com, ICWAI Inter)
(28 Points)
Replied 30 January 2010
not necessary.
they are not treated as bills of exchange
Reuben
(CA->IPCC student)
(35 Points)
Replied 30 January 2010
I dont think that you can consider it as Bills Of Exchange. Its a cash purchase receipt right?
narasimha murty
(Managing partner)
(54 Points)
Replied 31 January 2010
I detail my question here. In this case there are three parties- Seller (of material), Buyer (of material) and Outsider(who discounts GRNs). There is one document i.e GRN.
Activity 1. Seller brings material to the Buyer
Activity2 Delivers material and takes a copy of Goods Received Note (GRN) issued by the buyer.
Activity 3 Seller again sells the GRN to an outsider for a discount.
Activity 4 The outsider buys several such GRNs from many sellers.
Activity 5 The outsider comes to the buyer on an appointed date (say monthly once).
Activity 6 The buyer pays the bearer (Outsider) the GRN
Therefore in my opinion the buyer has to make entries of GRNs in his accounts but should not operate the seller's account. In such case, can we consider GRN as a legally valid IOU?
Live class on PF & ESI Enrollment & Returns Filing(with recording)
CAclubindia
