Originally posted by : Shruthi Shetty
	No it was not out of syllabus

Agreed....

Originally posted by : SAMIR KUMAR
	No such instruction is given to the examiners. I can not reveal the source but i know it.

why such news comes ...I don't know ...

well even it's good news ..

bt there is last time one person came with some marks detail ...i don't know where such person was lost after exams.

I am not criticizing you ...but please remember such news increase the heartbeat of others ...

and do remember always we are also students ... :)

peace ...

this is not done in ca exams.

yes agree the q was within the syllabus

I think if a question comes out of syllabus, they won't give free marks for it...

I think they would divide that marks among the remaining question and value...

But in this case I think this is not out of syllabus because when I studied PE 2 the questions were asked from CA Final too... and that's ICAI...

If you have any doubt please check... Most of the questions in PE2/PCC/IPCC will be questions of CA Final of previous decades...

anurag Jee, it was May'2011 there was a problem on NGO account problem there was a print mistake in the question it self.  how far the marks are being given at that time. If it was given on that paper, chances of a compensation marks will be there in this time. This is my opinion only. by this we may expect some marks out of any mistakes from the institutes. Please gothrough and confirm your self and post your opinion. thanx.

Dear Friends, Today i directly talked to G Someshekhar sir (Examination Departent) and discuss about the matter . He told if anything is out of sylabus the surely commitee will think on it .

And as per information Question was out of sylabus as acquistion problem is not covered in IPCC it is in final .

Rest u can check on 7th august . I am only sharing what i have told by ICAI

Dear Friends, I am also a student why should i wl post any rumors . i am only sharing the information what i have. 

If anybody says that question was within the sylabbus then show me a single question or method in IPCC material . i wl leave CA CLUBINDIA for Always 

Hope u may all understand  that i am also a student