PUNEET OBEROI (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (100 Points)
24 September 2010B IS WHOLLY OWNED SUBSIDIARY OF A. A IS HOLDING ENTIRE SHARES OF B. SINCE FOR A PRIVATE COMPANY MINIMUM TWO SHAREHOLDERS ARE REQUIRED? HOW CAN THIS SHAREHOLDING BE MADE. IS IT POSSIBLE THAT 99% SHARES ARE HELD BY A AND 1% SHARES ARE HELD BY Mr.X (MANAGING DIRECTOR OF A) ON BEHALF OF A. HOW THIS FACT IS REPRESENTED IN MCA. IS THERE ANY SPECIAL CARE REQUIRED FOR ANNUAL FILING?
KINDLY ADVISE.
ravindranth
(company secretary)
(114 Points)
Replied 24 September 2010
Hi
While incorporating a 100% subsidary, you need to give a board resolution for applying a name. in that you need to specify how the shareholding will be made.
Generally 99% on behalf of the holding company will be held by one director who is authorised by Board resolutiona and the other1 % will be held by another director of the holding company who is also authorised by the Board of directors. these two will be nominees of the holding company. you have to mention the same inthe subscripttion sheet also.
These two people will be considered as members.
sudarshan
(CA)
(745 Points)
Replied 24 September 2010
section 49 requires shares to be held in its own name ,but only for the purpose of minimum membership permits holding by holding co in the name of nominees. So in my opinion, entire share capital should be subscribed by holding company and allow only 1 share to be held by nominees .so 99% cannot be held by one director on behalf of holding company , only share of nominal value can be held by him. Experts can share there views.
Manmohan ACA, CS
(Chartered Accountant )
(14243 Points)
Replied 24 September 2010
It is not necessary that 100% share should be held by a single company, even if parts of share are held by nominee of A Ltd. for which A limited in beneficial holder, it shall be said that B Ltd is fully owned subsidiary of A ltd.
Ajay Mishra
(Company Secretary)
(74342 Points)
Replied 24 September 2010
In case of private company, whether it is holding company or subsidiary company should have minimum two shareholders.
For making wholly owned subsidiary, there is different way of making shareholding, but in case of minimum two member, the following structure you can apply:
1. Company (XYZ Ltd) 75% or more or less
2. Mr. S (Whether director or any person) hold as nominee of Company (XYZ Ltd.) 25% or more or less.
Regards
Mohammed Shariq
(Chartered Accountant)
(51 Points)
Replied 24 September 2010
soory i m not sure with my view....
SUNIL KUMAR JAIN
(PRACTISING COMPANY SECRETARY)
(187 Points)
Replied 10 October 2010
Dear Friends,
"Wholly Owned Subsidiary" indicates 100% shares of the Subsidiary Company are held by the "Holding Company". But to ensure minimum number of two Members of the Subsidiary , 'One' share may be held by an individual or a Company as a Nominee of the Holding Company.
In respect of "One'" Share held through the Nominee , necessary compliance of Section 187C of the Companies Act,1956 is to be done.For this purpose Declarations in Form-I & Form-II of The Companies ( Declaration of Beneficial Interest of Shares) Rules,1975 are to be signed by the 'Nominee' and ' the Holding Company' respectively. The Subsidiary Company is to file Form-22B along with the scanned copies of above two declarations as attachments with ROC.
Regards,
Sunil K. Jain, FCS, AICWA, BAL, PGDFM
Practising Company Secretary
skj13 @ rediffmail.com, 9810104162
sudarshan
(CA)
(745 Points)
Replied 11 October 2010
dear Mr.Jain,
can you give detailed note on incorporation of 100% subsidiary step by step to clear misunderstanding attached to this subject.
sudarshan s CA
sunil prakash jain
(Sr.manager)
(101 Points)
Replied 11 October 2010
Say capital of B is 10000 shars then arrange share holding as below
A ------------9999 equity shares
A jointly with Mr.X ---------------1 equity shares
It will serve your purpose without any compliance U/s 187C
Regards
RAKESH KUMAR SINGH
(Practicing CS)
(39 Points)
Replied 13 October 2010
Dear all
I agree with Mr. Sunil Kr. jain view. one shares will be held by nominee of holding Company and section 187 of the Act will have to be followed. advise of Mr. Sunil Prakash is normally followed by many companies in very casual way but it is not valid.
regrds
sudarshan
(CA)
(745 Points)
Replied 13 October 2010
can some one elaborate how to make the other person or company as nominee of holding co. Is board resolution is enough or nominee has to give any consent.
sudarshan CA
RAKESH KUMAR SINGH
(Practicing CS)
(39 Points)
Replied 13 October 2010
Other person or company can be made as nominee by resolution. However if the company is made nominee then the resolution of that i.e. proposed nominee company is required giving authority to some person to sign on behalf of the company. no consent is required as the nominee will sign the document i.e moa & aoa
regards
PUNEET OBEROI
(CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT)
(100 Points)
Replied 16 October 2010
Dear All,
Thank you very much for the valuable inputs. This is the best forum to interact and grow collectively. I would like to ask one more question. The client has a 100% subsidiary, however, in forms 20B, 23AC etc, of the subsidiary, the no. of shareholders was being shown as 1 only. He had not shown in this any second person as joint holder or nominee. MCA has been accepting the forms and no action has been initiated.
Can you suggest the best way to rectify the problem now? Section 187C entails heavy penalties. Is there a way out?
Regards,
RAKESH KUMAR SINGH
(Practicing CS)
(39 Points)
Replied 16 October 2010
Dear Punnet
Please file forms u/s 187 with the additional fees as the RoC can take action for one member only. it is clearly a violation of Companies Act
alok
(proprietor)
(21 Points)
Replied 31 July 2012
In my view since at the time of incorporation, it is very clearly mentioned by subscribers who is actual owner and who is nominee as to the One share, therefore, a separate declaration is not neeeded. Likewise on allotment of shares to suscribers to the memorandum no return of allotment in Form-2 is filed.
25 Hours GST Scrutiny of Return and Notice Handling(With Recording)
Survey, Search and Seizure under Income Tax Act 1961
CAclubindia
