1 in 5 Directors should be a woman
Suresh Prasad (www.aubsp.com) (15630 Points)
09 March 2011
One in five directors should be a woman: New Companies Bill
31 Replies
sweet_priyanka_20@yahoo.co.in
(sweet_priyanka_20@yahoo.co.in)
(28 Points)
Replied 09 March 2011
it's a great opportunity for womene's.
great ..........
Krish
(CA Final )
(3331 Points)
Replied 09 March 2011
| Originally posted by : sweet_priyanka_20 @ yahoo.co.in | ||
 |
it's a great opportunity for womene's. great .......... |
 |
Vikas Gupta
(CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT)
(16295 Points)
Replied 09 March 2011
| Originally posted by : sweet_priyanka_20 @ yahoo.co.in | ||
|
|
it's a great opportunity for womene's. great .......... |
|
Dhaval K.Toprani
(CA-IPCC Student)
(1150 Points)
Replied 09 March 2011
Absolutely unbelievable...What next??
1 in every 5 directors from the SC/ST and BC/OBC categories....
Don't know where the country is heading towards...Reservations everywhere!!!
Satvir Singh
(Newly minted CA)
(1733 Points)
Replied 09 March 2011
I don't think its a good step. It will reduce quality. If a woman is able enough, she can hersef become member. even 5 out of 5 can be women, if they are capable. Reservation is stupidity.
Deeejey
(May'11: The Final Assault in making of CA)
(201 Points)
Replied 09 March 2011
| Originally posted by : Dhaval K.Toprani | ||
|
|
Absolutely unbelievable...What next?? 1 in every 5 directors from the SC/ST and BC/OBC categories.... Don't know where the country is heading towards...Reservations everywhere!!! |
|
Sheh!!
What is the use of knowledge if someone needs Reservation to prove He/ She is Educated or qualified.
"Bheek mei mili Izzat aur Khud se Kamaai Izzat mei Zameen Asmaan ka fark hota hai"
dj
Deeejey
(May'11: The Final Assault in making of CA)
(201 Points)
Replied 09 March 2011
| Originally posted by : sweet_priyanka_20 @ yahoo.co.in | ||
|
|
it's a great opportunity for womene's. great .......... |
|
Can it be called as OPPORTUNITY???
its like a racing on track where "Some people" have dedicated track and they claim they are winning the race..
those had caliber already proved themselves. May be Chanda Kochar, Naina lal Kidwai, Indira Nooyi and so on...
(Guest)
| Originally posted by : Deeejey | ||
|
|
Originally posted by : sweet_priyanka_20 @ yahoo.co.in it's a great opportunity for womene's. great .......... Can it be called as OPPORTUNITY??? its like a racing on track where "Some people" have dedicated track and they claim they are winning the race.. those had caliber already proved themselves. May be Chanda Kochar, Naina lal Kidwai, Indira Nooyi and so on... |
|
AGREED
Abhishek
(CA FINAL)
(119 Points)
Replied 09 March 2011
Its an insult for all the womans of this country as this shows that they lack something which a man possess or rather it shows they can never match to the man's level and for which they require these kind of assistance....
Also there is a proposal of reservation of womans in lok sabha(one-third)
But is there any place in India which gurantees a position for mens...
What if someday there are more than 50% womans in Lok sabha ?? Is anyone going to complain ??
I am not saying that men's shud prevail every-where but instead everything shud be chosen on the basis of merit...
if womens are skilled, talented etc then why one instead all five directors shud be women.
Womans today are growing almost at par with man in almost all fields....when all are saying men and women shud hv equal rights then why to make difference between them by offering such reservation....it shows womens in India are still under-skilled......
CA Madhukiran Reddy
(CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT)
(12714 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011
| Originally posted by : sweet_priyanka_20 @ yahoo.co.in | ||
|
|
it's a great opportunity for womene's. great .......... |
|
Raunak
(CA Final)
(227 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011
well, i think its a bold step but...its not right to make reservations in directors!! tats insane... a company is not run by democracy but merit, quality..!! if u wann bring women parity thn do so in othr fields were proper representations are required...example d parliament..tats a better deal..!! its jst a politics gimmick..!!
brining reservations in things like these is like bringing reservations in CA exams !!! (quoating CA exams here coz this is d most genuine exams wherein its based only on merit)
Jayashree S Iyer
(Company Secretary)
(3224 Points)
Replied 10 March 2011
Yes , as a woman when I see such remarks it definetely pains me. But folks see the reality before making such comments.
There have been some sarcastic remarks for reservation of SC/ST. I was also one of the members like you in my teens questioning the reservation policies of the Government. But now as a matured person I can definitely understand the reason and can also convince anyone that RESERVATION FOR backward community is very much justified.
You are seeing the urban culture where there is not much discrimination against SC/STs. Rather they misuse the benefit given to them which in fact makes us feel that Government is wrong in extending the Reservation Policy. In many cases we abuse the Government that this is done for VOTE GAIN. May be they do it for vote gain, but my dear friends, go to villages and small towns and you will know what they are and how they are treated?
Being Purohit's daughter I have always seen that these people are never respected, even today they are not allowed inside our houses. For the past 25 years my family has been in metro but the thinking of elders have not changed, rather it has perculated to next generation also. If this is so in metro, think of villages and small towns.
We people may be financially week but are always respected. We don't have any inferiority feelings. But those minority community people have always been subjected to ill treatment and disgrace and their family background never allow them to think broadly and freely. I have seen my daughter's friends (who are in college) always asking if there won't be any issue if they come to our house. Never such question come to our mind? Just because they are born in lower community does it mean that they are inferior.
Again due to the continued harrassment for years, they definitely need to get CONTINUED RESERVATION not only for another 10 or 20 years but till the time we all say that we all are ONE INDIANS.
But one thing we need to assure is that the benefit of RESERVATION must reach all the deserving candidates and not restricted to select urban people only. If the benefit doesn't reach the bottom then it will not achieve the real purpose for which it was extended.
Now raising voices against WOMEN RESERVATION in BOARD ROOMS or for that matter even in PARLIAMENT- How many of you really share the family chores? Women already have RESERVATION in major areas viz.,Household work, Kitchen, Children, etc. Then how do you expect them to come upto BOARD ROOM level without RESERVATION. Mind you dear, without a woman, you would not be sitting in the BOARD ROOM. Women are not less intelligent nor are they incapable. She puts her FAMILY BEFORE ANYTHING and that only prevents her from reaching THE BOARD ROOM.
Come on. from now onwards you share the family responsibility equally and then see for yourself the heights the WOMEN reach? Probably you may then need RESERVATIONS. Few SUCCESSFUL WOMEN ENTREPRENUERS like Chandra Kochar, Indira Nooyi, Kiran Mazumdar, etc. are probably blessed with SUCH COUNTERPARTS. I wish more WOMEN to be blessed with such life partner. I would definitely say I am one of the blessed ones and that's why I am here expressing my views very freely and openly.
Friends, it's only my reaction to your comments.
Recent Topics
- Urgent doubt on GST
- Profit or Loss on Sale of Assets Accounting treatm
- Clarification on RCM on Rent Payment for QRMP Deal
- Reclaimed itc in gstr9
- Gamification in Accounting Software: Boosting Enga
- I want to knw Hsn code and gst rate of resin produ
- Schedule FA clarification
- Income tax on freelance income from crypto
- ITC temporary reversal and reclaim
- Query on Transactions
Related Threads
CAclubindia
