In the recent protests made by some renowned faculties of CA fraternity along with CA students, grievances have been brought forward regarding the evaluation of answer scripts. Students have come forward stating that there has been inconsistency in the process of evaluation of answer scripts. There are many discrepancies in the marks allotted.
Protest have been made seeking transparency in the evaluation of answer scripts. Students and teachers are demanding that a clear process of evaluation should be set which should be transparent in nature.
While students have stated their grievances, ICAI has issued a press release clarifying the process of evaluation.
Here's what they have stated in the PR-
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ANNOUNCEMENT- Evaluation of answer books of CA exams
It has been brought to our notice that certain adverse reports relating to the system of evaluation of answer books of CA exams are doing the rounds in social media. In this connection, following reforms which have been put in place recently are brought to the attention of the stakeholders in respect of the ICAI examination system
1. Digital evaluation : As communicated in January 2019 Chartered Accountant Student newsletter , continuing further from the pilot e evaluation for first group of Intermediate Nov 2018 exams; all papers of Intermediate and Foundation level exams in November 2019/May 2020 will be put through the digital evaluation mode bringing in following benefits
- Doing away with stages of physical handling of answer books
- Avoiding variations in marks awarded by examiners.
- Eliminating scope of any totalling errors
- Continuous review of performance of the Examiners on real time basis;
- Generation of analytical reports enabling quality control checks; and
2. Central evaluation: Further the Central Evaluation is being carried out in several papers of CA exams, w.e.f November 2018 wherein examiners evaluate answer books under the supervision of Head Examiner/Associate Head Examiners.
3. Machine based evaluation: Effective May, 2019 exams, objective type questions for 30 marks have been introduced in select papers of Intermediate and Final Exams. Further the Institute has decided to introduce OMR based evaluation for MCQ’s of Elective Papers 6A to 6F of final New course with effect from November 2019 which are machine processed thus avoiding subjectivity.
4. Stepwise marking : Provision regarding stepwise marking is being enforced whereby in case the stepwise marks are not awarded ; it will be deemed as unevaluated answer and stepwise marks will be awarded during the course of re verification of marks
5. Mandatory on-line test for empanelment of examiners: All applicants shortlisted for empanelment as examiners are required to qualify an on-line test in the subject of their choice before inclusion of their names in the Panel of Examiners. It has further been decided that all existing examiners would also be required to undergo an on-line test in their respective subjects, once in 3 years.
Budding students are the backbone of the Chartered Accountancy profession as with them lies the future and growth of the profession. Various endeavours of the Institute through its Board of Studies like World class study material, Live Virtual /Revision Classes, training opportunities for article/industrial training, constant study updates, monthly student journal ,GMCS and ITT batches are targeted to build capability of students providing due scalability .Students are requested to be not to be misled and swayed by any tirade as ICAI stands committed to fulfil their genuine concerns.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
While this seems to be a befitting clarification, we would like to know what's your take on it.
CAclubindia
