Live Course on Drafting of Appeal and Reply of Penalty Notice by CA Sachin Sinha. Register Now!!

Reliance compiler or Paduka which is better?

B.S. Shekhawat (article) (80 Points)

09 March 2010

Please suggest me , which book is better( in case of self study) for 3 practical subjects ACC, MAFA, COST in CA final.

as i want to know either rel compiler or paduka, contain better detailed answers with proper working notes and assumptions for proper understanding,

* if there is any other book pls do suggest.(in format of past examination question and answers.)

* i really want to avoid a book which contains copied material of CA institute examination suggested answers which lacks working notes.

please HElp

Reply
Follow
Share

12 Replies

Ankur Garg (Company Secretary and Compliance Officer) (114773 Points)
Replied 09 March 2010

BOOKS FOR CA FINAL

You may go for the following options regarding books for ca final:

For Accounts: M.P.Vijay kumar or Shukla & Grawal along with Module And Compilation and for AS part go for D.S. Rawat

For CA Final AS preparation---Dolphi Desouza is good.

For Audit: Prakhar Sharma/Paduka/ V.K Agrawal
Note: (MP Vijay Kumar can be used for AS reference)
For Corp Law: Munish Bhandari
For Mafa: Module and Notes of Tarun Mahajan. You may also refer A.N Sridhar.
For Direct Taxes: TN Manoharan (Theory part), Circular, Notification, Amendments, case laws. Also refer Vinod Gupta Modules.
For IDT: Vandana Bangur
For MICS: Module and Dinesh Madan
For Costing: Saxena and vashist or Ravi M Kishore with module

Also refer Scanners and Suggested Answer issued by ICAI for previous year exams and revised them properly.

For some good notes explore CAClubindia forum and share file section. You may also use search facility of club.

Also explore some CA books at the link below:

www.cabooksonline.com

Best Regards

Amit Nishania (CA Final - Student) (495 Points)
Replied 09 March 2010

For Accounts and Cost Padhuka is the best and for MAFA you can refer Padhuka or Reliance as it will not make any difference as i have gone through both the books.

1 Like

B.S. Shekhawat (article) (80 Points)
Replied 09 March 2010

Please note :) as i need detailed answers for past examinations for these 3 practical subjects, so do reply suggestion in context of compilation books not illustrative book like hanif and MP Vijay kumar etc.

thanks.